Good Old Days Pizza & Cocktail Den
19 Main St, Newtown
(203) 491-2920
Customers' Favorites
Plain Square Pie with Pepperoni
French Onion Pizza with Bacon
Ice Cream Sandwich
Vodka Sauce Pizza
Heat of the Moment
A Cheese Pizza
Bikini Bottom
Supreme Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Pizza was good... would've given it a 4.5 star review. If they would have had the square Pizza available, it maybhave been a 5. Pizza eas crispy and full of flavor, but I've had better. Service was phenomenal . Fo the location, I think the atmosphere is as good as it gets. Both indoor and outdoor seating available. Great drinks.
Nice restaurant with cozy atmosphere. The fireplace was on and staff were super friendly and attentive! Ordered the frisée and it was a unique salad, loved it! Spicy pizza without meat tasted good when it was hot but was not at all spicy, it was bit sweet, the crust was good though! Alagash white went good with it. Overall good experience!
Dietary restrictions: Yes
Dietary restrictions: Yes
After hearing great things and seeing positive reviews of how they handle gluten and dairy free pizzas, we decided to give it a try. Even though we have very few choices of trustworthy restaurants in the area, I will not be returning here. The prices are outrageous…and I’m not even speaking of the extensive upcharges for gluten and dairy free options. $50 for 2 pepperoni pizzas (one gf/df)?! Absurd. Way too many pepperonis. Waitress did her minimal job and talked me out of...
You May Also Like
Marygold's on Main - 19 Main St
![]()
Venues & Event Spaces, Lounges
Tamarind Fine Indian Dining - LIBERTY POLE BUILDING, 33 Main St
![]()
Fine Dining, Indian, Noodles, Soup
Boost Bowls - 6 Queen St
![]()
Health Food, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Vegan