Amici Tavern

43 Broadway, North Haven
(203) 691-6761

Recent Reviews

Scotty D.

Plans changed and we found ourselves traveling and in need of a dinner spot. Found this on a search and took a chance. Ambiance was great. Service was attentive. Food was good but nothing stood out. Need to give it another try to give a better review.

Josh B.

Food and service are good, parking sucks, atmosphere is nice as well. Easy location, accessible to highway

K H.

We come here almost once a week with our two elementary schoolers. The staff is always kind, solicitous, and patient, even when one of our kids wants a number of "customizations" to her mac and cheese order. We always look to find a table near the one tv that isn't playing sports but rather is playing funny videos to keep our kids engaged so that the adults can catch up on our days. The cocktails are good and filled to the rim. And, we always appreciate the rotating specials menu so there is something new to try each time for the adults. Can't ask for much more in a go-to neighborhood restaurant.

Nancy Angelopoulos

Had a very good sandwich, turkey club. Also have a good

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger

Ryan Andrews

Rude staff...got a bacon egg n cheese and it had a single piece of bacon on it. Coffee flight was garbage. Never going back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Cassidy Javo

This used to be one of our favorite restaurants but after this time, we won't be returning! We ordered takeout and the food was flavorless. The Korean chicken sandwich was over cooked and so were the chicken waffle sliders. The hot dog bun was stale and hard. The fries weren't fully cooked and the serving size was for a child, not for an adult.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Anna Marie Carasone

Food was awesome but our waitress never checked back with us. We had to call her over several times and there was only 2 tables of guests besides us.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Adam S.

The best way to describe this place is a dive bar that's trying not to be a dive bar. If it were only slightly darker and dirtier you wouldn't question it. In regards to food they have a large burger selection which appear to be their staple but it taste like the kind you buy in bulk that are frozen. Also if you are going to be a burger place I think frozen fries are unacceptable. When we arrived there was only one server. They worked harder but were clearly stretched thin.

Dee P.

Great menu with a ton of choices. The Korean chicken sandwich was sweet and spicy. It was excellent. We also ordered the poutine tater tots with shredded beef. Amazing!!! Really great bar to watch a game and tons of drink options.

Mark Aiello

Good food and not just bar grub.Friendly and attractive serviceWheelchair accessibility: Have have a ramp up to the door

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Darknight002

Ordered a burger well done and i got a medium rare patty. The place was empty, so I dont see why they couldnt cook the meat to specification. Will definately not return, i dont eat raw

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Margaret Schmidt

We hosted a baby shower at Amici's Middletown this past weekend. It was fabulous!! The staff was very helpful while we set up decorations and gracious during the party to us & guests. Thank you all, especially to the serving team that came down to Middletown from Avon. Highly recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

vakamalua

Nice local place with Italian fare. Almost empty on a Sunday evening & unfortunately, it was a freezing temperature which made it uncomfortable. The food was quite good. Partner had Chicken Parmesan & enjoyed it. I thought the Pasta Da Vinci was very good, just wish it was served with a side of vegetables. The service was very attentive.

Donna Mrazik

Too much drama at work, a lot of disrespect and a lot of bullies

Bob Griswold

Meh. I would describe the food as average. Like on par with Ruby Tuesday or other such chains. Not that it was bad, but with so many other better restaurants in the area, it is unlikely we will ever return.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Load More