This was our first time dining at this restaurant, been meaning to go for a while and are very glad we did! Everything was great, will definitely be going back and also plan to check out the tavern downstairs.
Thomas
This was an exceptionally wonderful dining experience! The staff were upbeat and friendly, as well as helpful in suggesting things on the menu that complimented one another. The food was well prepared to our liking and severed in a timely manner while not rushing us between courses. The wine list was extensive and the mixed drinks like espresso martinis and chocolate martinis with our deserts were over the top. We were celebrating a birthday, and the staff went above and beyond to make it very special. This location will most definitely be our go to steak house!
Leigh
This is the second time dining here, and we'll certainly be back. There were six of us celebrating a birthday. Four had steaks, one lobster ravioli, and I had lamb chops. They were the best I've ever had. The 20oz rib eyes were ordered thinking they could take some home, but the plates were finished! Couldn't see anything left of the ravioli. Drinks were very good. The atmosphere in the steakhouse is perfect and good choice of music. If you love steak, come here. It is not cheap, but worth every penny. Filet mignon $46, Ribeye 20oz. $56. There is also 40-day dry aged for $66. It's worth it.
Nicolette
Greeted warmly by Michelle who sat us near the fireplace as requested. Our server Dom was excellent & very attentive. Food was fabulous. We have been dining at Millpond (both Tavern & Steakhouse) since it opened & have never been disappointed!
Deborah
Millpond Gathering never fails to deliver. The food is excellent, the staff is outstanding...professional, friendly, knows how to make you feel welcome and appreciated (Roland is the best). We will always go back.
Fred
This place has quickly become one of the best steakhouses in Connecticut. We've been here a couple of times already and each time it has exceeded our expectations. The location is legendary and rustic. Cocktails are very satisfying and new selections are rotated in regularly. The raw bar offers great local oysters at a moderate price. Steaks are cooked to perfection with a tasty exterior char. I value when a restaurant really understands what medium rare is without having to be told. Its fantastic that most of the steak dishes include a potato starch and veggies unlike many others where all sides are a la carte. However, their sauced mushrooms with onions and creamy spinach are awesome compliments to any steak dish. If you have room for dessert, the churros and carrot cake are yummy. Service is excellent with a very friendly and professional staff. They really make you feel welcomed and appreciated. Will definitely be coming back often!
Lisbeth Blake
Very disappointed. Brought family of 7 from out of town for taco Tuesday. Waiter couldn't speak English or describe what type of fish was used in fish tacos. Regardless, i ordered 1 chicken and 1 fish taco. The order arrived wrong. Waiter took so long to check on the food after delivery that there was no time to return.Tacos came on plates instead of holders. Taco shells were very soggy. Would not do this again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Mark
Amazing place! Went for dinner at the Steak House, every part of the meal was excellent, drinks, apps, main. Nice rustic charm. Can't wait to go back when it's light out to see more of it.
Mary
Usually I look forward to a bite of the warm buttery popovers served before dinner even though I'm gluten free. This time the popovers weren't just cold but also burnt and the butter was hard as a rock. Also my brick chicken was extremely fatty. I'm pretty disappointed because in the past the food has been good. Also, they should offer some gluten free dessert options.
Linda Wawrzeniak
Food and service were very good, as was the entertainment. However, the entertainment was MUCH too loud and I feel it should have been directed more toward the bar area, as opposed to the dining area.
Millpond truly impressed us in every way! The food is outstanding — fresh, well-balanced, and full of flavor. You can tell the chef and the team put passion and care into every dish. The atmosphere is warm, cozy, and very inviting. The new owners have done an incredible job — Millpond feels completely renewed: more comfortable, more welcoming, and with a special charm. It’s wonderful to see how the place has been brought back to life.The service is excellent: attentive, fast, and genuinely friendly. You’re treated like a valued guest from the moment you walk in. Millpond is definitely a place you want to return to. A perfect combination of great ambiance, delicious food, and people who truly care. Highly recommend! 🍷✨🫶
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Henka Cho
The food was amazing and our server was awesome love ambience thank you Marissa
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Artemis Vallianatos
Everything was perfect for husband’s birthday dinner, but what really elevates this place to a full 5 stars is the outstanding service. The staff struck the ideal balance of attentive and relaxed: warm greetings, thoughtful check-ins, and a truly friendly energy throughout the night. You can tell the servers enjoy working there and take pride in their work. It shows in every interaction.
The food was exactly what we hoped for: well-seasoned, generous without being heavy, and beautifully prepared. Our table ordered a combination of tavern classics and steakhouse selections from the lounge level (the lower part of the restaurant), and every dish landed. It felt like the best of both menus in one cozy setting.
A memorable meal, wonderful hospitality, and a place we’ll gladly return to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
veronica ann
Went last night with my partner for dinner in the tavern and it was amazing! Drinks and food were great and our bartender Ava was awesome. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mayling diaz
First time here and the atmosphere was beautiful quiet, the music was perfect the service was exceptional. The food was delicious but I ordered medium well and 1/2 of the steak was well and the other medium well
This was our first time dining at this restaurant, been meaning to go for a while and are very glad we did! Everything was great, will definitely be going back and also plan to check out the tavern downstairs.
This was an exceptionally wonderful dining experience! The staff were upbeat and friendly, as well as helpful in suggesting things on the menu that complimented one another. The food was well prepared to our liking and severed in a timely manner while not rushing us between courses. The wine list was extensive and the mixed drinks like espresso martinis and chocolate martinis with our deserts were over the top. We were celebrating a birthday, and the staff went above and beyond to make it very special. This location will most definitely be our go to steak house!
This is the second time dining here, and we'll certainly be back. There were six of us celebrating a birthday. Four had steaks, one lobster ravioli, and I had lamb chops. They were the best I've ever had. The 20oz rib eyes were ordered thinking they could take some home, but the plates were finished! Couldn't see anything left of the ravioli. Drinks were very good. The atmosphere in the steakhouse is perfect and good choice of music. If you love steak, come here. It is not cheap, but worth every penny. Filet mignon $46, Ribeye 20oz. $56. There is also 40-day dry aged for $66. It's worth it.
Greeted warmly by Michelle who sat us near the fireplace as requested. Our server Dom was excellent & very attentive. Food was fabulous. We have been dining at Millpond (both Tavern & Steakhouse) since it opened & have never been disappointed!
Millpond Gathering never fails to deliver. The food is excellent, the staff is outstanding...professional, friendly, knows how to make you feel welcome and appreciated (Roland is the best). We will always go back.
This place has quickly become one of the best steakhouses in Connecticut. We've been here a couple of times already and each time it has exceeded our expectations. The location is legendary and rustic. Cocktails are very satisfying and new selections are rotated in regularly. The raw bar offers great local oysters at a moderate price. Steaks are cooked to perfection with a tasty exterior char. I value when a restaurant really understands what medium rare is without having to be told. Its fantastic that most of the steak dishes include a potato starch and veggies unlike many others where all sides are a la carte. However, their sauced mushrooms with onions and creamy spinach are awesome compliments to any steak dish. If you have room for dessert, the churros and carrot cake are yummy. Service is excellent with a very friendly and professional staff. They really make you feel welcomed and appreciated. Will definitely be coming back often!
Very disappointed.
Brought family of 7 from out of town for taco Tuesday. Waiter couldn't speak English or describe what type of fish was used in fish tacos. Regardless, i ordered 1 chicken and 1 fish taco. The order arrived wrong.
Waiter took so long to check on the food after delivery that there was no time to return.Tacos came on plates instead of holders. Taco shells were very soggy. Would not do this again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Amazing place! Went for dinner at the Steak House, every part of the meal was excellent, drinks, apps, main. Nice rustic charm. Can't wait to go back when it's light out to see more of it.
Usually I look forward to a bite of the warm buttery popovers served before dinner even though I'm gluten free. This time the popovers weren't just cold but also burnt and the butter was hard as a rock. Also my brick chicken was extremely fatty. I'm pretty disappointed because in the past the food has been good. Also, they should offer some gluten free dessert options.
Food and service were very good, as was the entertainment. However, the entertainment was MUCH too loud and I feel it should have been directed more toward the bar area, as opposed to the dining area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Millpond truly impressed us in every way!
The food is outstanding — fresh, well-balanced, and full of flavor. You can tell the chef and the team put passion and care into every dish.
The atmosphere is warm, cozy, and very inviting. The new owners have done an incredible job — Millpond feels completely renewed: more comfortable, more welcoming, and with a special charm. It’s wonderful to see how the place has been brought back to life.The service is excellent: attentive, fast, and genuinely friendly. You’re treated like a valued guest from the moment you walk in.
Millpond is definitely a place you want to return to. A perfect combination of great ambiance, delicious food, and people who truly care. Highly recommend! 🍷✨🫶
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was amazing and our server was awesome love ambience thank you Marissa
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything was perfect for husband’s birthday dinner, but what really elevates this place to a full 5 stars is the outstanding service. The staff struck the ideal balance of attentive and relaxed: warm greetings, thoughtful check-ins, and a truly friendly energy throughout the night. You can tell the servers enjoy working there and take pride in their work. It shows in every interaction.
The food was exactly what we hoped for: well-seasoned, generous without being heavy, and beautifully prepared. Our table ordered a combination of tavern classics and steakhouse selections from the lounge level (the lower part of the restaurant), and every dish landed. It felt like the best of both menus in one cozy setting.
A memorable meal, wonderful hospitality, and a place we’ll gladly return to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went last night with my partner for dinner in the tavern and it was amazing! Drinks and food were great and our bartender Ava was awesome. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time here and the atmosphere was beautiful quiet, the music was perfect the service was exceptional. The food was delicious but I ordered medium well and 1/2 of the steak was well and the other medium well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...