Fenwick Ice Cream Co.
910 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook
(860) 943-3009
Customers' Favorites
Coffee Chocolate Chunk O Oreo
Butter Pecan O Maple Walnut
Vanilla Black Cherry Chunk
Toasted Almond Ice Cream
Banana Split
2 Scoops
Toppings
Menu
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We couldn’t resist getting some ice cream from Fenwick after having lunch at Johnny Ad’s! They have a bunch of flavors to choose from, and all of the ice cream is handmade by them. We indulged in a banana split, and it came with all of the classic toppings, and our friends enjoyed the mint chip and toasted almond. It was a cute, casual spot, and the girls at the window were friendly. This was our second time getting ice cream here and we will definitely be back for more!
I ordered the vanilla black cherry chuck. I have to say was absolutely fantastic! Cut little store front with pinlcnic tables to sit at. We came at the moment with no shade so we ate in the car. Service was quick and the girls were very nice. They have a CLEAN bathroom behind the building. We will be back!
After coming here the first time I just can't understand how it has so few reviews! Amazing ice cream, just delicious from top to bottom. Hubby loved almond, I 100% recommend Mississippi Mud, hands down amazing.Atmosphere is also very cool, the outside sitting, the music and the girls working here super sweet, best customer service.
You May Also Like
Johnny Ad's - 910 Boston Post Rd
![]()
Seafood, Pet Friendly
Parthenon Diner-Old Saybrook - 809 Boston Post Rd
![]()
Diner, Greek, Vegetarian, Vegan
Duby's Bagels & Bakery - 785 Boston Post Rd
![]()
Bagels, Bakery, Coffee & Tea