Mystic Market South

70 Mill Rock Rd E, Old Saybrook
(860) 661-5910

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stacey Moronta

Fantastic spot for breakfast sandwiches & latte baked goods, pre-prep meals looks extremely delicious. great variety & service! Will def recommend & come back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oh Damn It's Sam

It's normally crowded and the prices are very high for the quality and amount of food you get. It's not worth it in my opinion. Good selection of sandwiches and desserts though.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Kevin Flick

EXPENSIVE for what you get. Have gotten the same thing 3 times and each time it was made slightly different....

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Dana Serikbayeva

good spot, food is nice, but the cashier Stacy just isn’t it. I noticed she gets really passive aggressive with me when taking my order, but then turns around and is all polite and sweet with other customers. No idea why and honestly don’t care I could’ve asked her today but I’d rather just stop going. Everyone else there is great though, always smiling and polite.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

E P

Great spot for sandwiches. Conveniently close to the highway as well. Highly recommend pit stop if youre traveling on 95.

stephen paulsen

Always good food. Great food at a great price. Whenever I'm in the area I stop by.

Miles Schlomann

good food but ridiculously overpriced

Caiti Appell

Great location, cute atmosphere. Very friendly people, the kitchen seems a little discombobulated though. Ordered a chicken salad wrap with added cheese, which I paid extra for. Unfortunately- there was no cheese, and the chicken salad was dry and tasteless. For $17 (one wrap and one iced tea) I had hoped for better.

CT Wraps

Very Tasty. 👌

Shonya Kowal Collier

I’m here at least 3 days a week for dinner items and it’s great every time.

Shannon Curran

Such a cute spot. Great prepared food options. We had sandwiches for lunch that were excellent. Our only hesitancy was that the prices were a bit high

Nicholas Cunningham

Best lunch in Old Saybrook!

Emma M

Love this place ?????? so good the food the service the atmosphere everything. The orzo lemon pasta is so good. And the blackberry lemonade is my favorite. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Pamela Good

The food and selection are great. The employees are friendly and kind. My only issue is the chaos. It seems like these workers have no direction. They are definitely trying. But it seems that more than one of them were confused as to what they should be doing while a lot of customers waited to be checked out. There was no flow. We will continue to visit. We enjoy it. But it has been this way for a while and we just need to keep in mind what we’re getting into when we go here.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Salad, Bakery, Sandwich, House Roast Beef

John Walenczyk

I originally gave this place a 5 star review a few years ago but after today I am changing it. Over the years the service has always been a bit spotty, mainly because they mostly employ young stoners that are quirky which isn't the worst thing in the world, but incompentce should be expected, something always gets messed up.

Today we ordered a sandwich and it was made wrong (they covered it in onions, no onions were asked for), so I went back in and asked for them to remake it, no apology, they remade it wrong again, so I went back in again and asked what was going on. They brought the sandwich back and explained they did something wrong and I asked if they remade the sandwich or just scraped the onions off...which they tried to fool me with and so I asked for them to remake it one last time. Which they did but it was made haphazard and looked like they tried to salvage the old sandwich and used the same bread. They don't mind asking for a tip every order but when they mess things up they will do the bare minimum just to get you out the door. This place is expensive and not the only sandwich game in the area, go to Simons in Chester or Olive Oyls in Essex, you won't get charged an arm and a leg for a sandwich and it will get made right.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Loading...