Ordered on the slice app for pick up. Got home and opened my salad which was filled with old meat and cheese. Contacted slice and business refused to refund unless they seen the salad in person. Drove back there to show them and they still refused. They claim to use only fresh ingredients and obviously this is not the case. Will no longer be ordering from them or slice. We’ve been ordering from them for YEARS but this is actually the third time this has happened with their antipasto salad.
Karen Miller
If I could pick zero I would. Spent over 100 bucks on pizza and they could not get it right. Made the mistake of using the slice app which I am deleting right after I review because “there hands are tied if the restaurant says they prepared it correctly”. Cheese pizza, olive pizza and pepperoni pizza were ok.Penne ala vodka tastes like straight white wine.Palace calzone that is supposed to come with “roni, sausage, mushroom, onion, pepper,bacon, and meatball and cheese” forgot to add the pepperoni and sausage and used a dollop of cheese.Seafood pizza forgot the seafood. There was only garlic on the pizza. No shrimp. No clams. It doesn’t even smell like seafood.Save your money and order from a place with actual customer service. Who wants to keep customers. First time ordering from here. Never again. And now I’m never using SlICE again either. Who had this place rated 4.8 stars. Definitely fake ratingsDon’t get scammed like we did!
leon wojcak
Pizza is inconsistent some times it is really good other time's it missis the mark wish it could be more consistent
Raquel T
Got pizza here. I liked it. My kids liked it. We are from NY and tend to be pizza snobs from an Italian neighborhood. Decent for a reliable place to order. Crust is tasty and almost like a deep dish style. Glad to support local business.
Jeffrey Bryce
Price on menu at the counter are NOT what they charged. A Greek salad was less than $7 on the menu. They charged me over $10 and said “our new menus aren’t here yet.” No way would I have ordered a $10 small salad.
Lee Lee
Only 10 minutes for a freshly cooked pizza! I was reading reviews from others but I think the primary concerns with other people is that they’re not realizing that this is not a New York style pizza place. They specialize more so in a Greek style… Pan pizza. Deep crust pizza kind of similar to the way that Domino’s makes there’s. Overall pretty good for a quick bite to eat. I recommend taking out. Inside is a little run down
Judy Brown
Very good Greek style pizza made by hard working manager/ owner? Only employee working, answered phone, opened dining area for us, took our order, made excellent pie, delivered it, rang us out. Go for food, decor is dated but so happy to find pizza dine in that it really didn't matter. Bathroom clean, pizza toppings plentiful, corona beer, what's to complain about?
N Borrero
Love this Pizzeria.Childhood memories.The food is still delicious like back than ..it wasn't crowded at all.. that's what we love about it!!We get to enjoy our quality time together with family and friends! Keep up the great service ? God bless us ????❤️?
Scott Robinson
Back in the 80s and 90s the pizza was excellent.Since the 2000s it all went downhill.First the mozzarella went from great to not good. Then the sauce from great to not good. What happened,the original owner died and the son took over and he is only about profit. He ruined a good thing.That is why I don’t go there anymore.
Jonathan Carriere
I love this place they have amazing underrated gyros and their pizza is great as well. Who ever reviewed and said “too much cheese” is missing out. I go here very often and they treat their customers very well.
Ordered food at 7:15pm via Grubhub. Called at 830 to see where my 2 grinders are and the number is out of service. The place closes at 830 so, I guess we're not having dinner tonight. They could have called so to say they were or werent coming. Terrible way to do business. I will never try again or recommend them to anyone.
Mitch M.
I have ordered from them twice and each time their food was delicious! Their gyro is excellent! Salads are always fresh and their fries are delicious. Will have to go eat in there soon.
joanna carrero
Shelton has a variety of pizzas but by far this is my favorite pizza shop. Not only are there pizzas made exactly the way I love it, their staff goes out of their way to make you feel like you are family. My son and I have never been a big fan of pizza because of the sauce. But this woman makes her sauce from scratch, I don't know what she puts in it but my son and I are always in AWE when we eat it. I know everyone prefer their Pizza a certain way but if you like your pizza dough to have a crunchy bottom and still gooey on the top, then you gotta try this place.
Demi Vitkute
Excellent service! Great pizza! Thank you.
ingrid vitkute
Exceptional service, great pizza, great good. Love their dressing!
Ordered on the slice app for pick up. Got home and opened my salad which was filled with old meat and cheese. Contacted slice and business refused to refund unless they seen the salad in person. Drove back there to show them and they still refused. They claim to use only fresh ingredients and obviously this is not the case. Will no longer be ordering from them or slice. We’ve been ordering from them for YEARS but this is actually the third time this has happened with their antipasto salad.
If I could pick zero I would. Spent over 100 bucks on pizza and they could not get it right. Made the mistake of using the slice app which I am deleting right after I review because “there hands are tied if the restaurant says they prepared it correctly”. Cheese pizza, olive pizza and pepperoni pizza were ok.Penne ala vodka tastes like straight white wine.Palace calzone that is supposed to come with “roni, sausage, mushroom, onion, pepper,bacon, and meatball and cheese” forgot to add the pepperoni and sausage and used a dollop of cheese.Seafood pizza forgot the seafood. There was only garlic on the pizza. No shrimp. No clams. It doesn’t even smell like seafood.Save your money and order from a place with actual customer service. Who wants to keep customers. First time ordering from here. Never again. And now I’m never using SlICE again either. Who had this place rated 4.8 stars. Definitely fake ratingsDon’t get scammed like we did!
Pizza is inconsistent some times it is really good other time's it missis the mark wish it could be more consistent
Got pizza here. I liked it. My kids liked it. We are from NY and tend to be pizza snobs from an Italian neighborhood. Decent for a reliable place to order. Crust is tasty and almost like a deep dish style. Glad to support local business.
Price on menu at the counter are NOT what they charged. A Greek salad was less than $7 on the menu. They charged me over $10 and said “our new menus aren’t here yet.” No way would I have ordered a $10 small salad.
Only 10 minutes for a freshly cooked pizza! I was reading reviews from others but I think the primary concerns with other people is that they’re not realizing that this is not a New York style pizza place. They specialize more so in a Greek style… Pan pizza. Deep crust pizza kind of similar to the way that Domino’s makes there’s. Overall pretty good for a quick bite to eat. I recommend taking out. Inside is a little run down
Very good Greek style pizza made by hard working manager/ owner? Only employee working, answered phone, opened dining area for us, took our order, made excellent pie, delivered it, rang us out. Go for food, decor is dated but so happy to find pizza dine in that it really didn't matter. Bathroom clean, pizza toppings plentiful, corona beer, what's to complain about?
Love this Pizzeria.Childhood memories.The food is still delicious like back than ..it wasn't crowded at all.. that's what we love about it!!We get to enjoy our quality time together with family and friends! Keep up the great service ? God bless us ????❤️?
Back in the 80s and 90s the pizza was excellent.Since the 2000s it all went downhill.First the mozzarella went from great to not good. Then the sauce from great to not good. What happened,the original owner died and the son took over and he is only about profit. He ruined a good thing.That is why I don’t go there anymore.
I love this place they have amazing underrated gyros and their pizza is great as well. Who ever reviewed and said “too much cheese” is missing out. I go here very often and they treat their customers very well.
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered food at 7:15pm via Grubhub. Called at 830 to see where my 2 grinders are and the number is out of service. The place closes at 830 so, I guess we're not having dinner tonight. They could have called so to say they were or werent coming. Terrible way to do business. I will never try again or recommend them to anyone.
I have ordered from them twice and each time their food was delicious! Their gyro is excellent! Salads are always fresh and their fries are delicious. Will have to go eat in there soon.
Shelton has a variety of pizzas but by far this is my favorite pizza shop. Not only are there pizzas made exactly the way I love it, their staff goes out of their way to make you feel like you are family. My son and I have never been a big fan of pizza because of the sauce. But this woman makes her sauce from scratch, I don't know what she puts in it but my son and I are always in AWE when we eat it. I know everyone prefer their Pizza a certain way but if you like your pizza dough to have a crunchy bottom and still gooey on the top, then you gotta try this place.
Excellent service! Great pizza! Thank you.
Exceptional service, great pizza, great good. Love their dressing!