The food was delicious as usual. Never disappoints. I have to give a shout out to the staff members serving at the bar. Each and every one of them was fantastic. Friendly, knowledgeable, great servers & bartenders . It's hard to find places were the staff is all of those things these days . They hit it out of the park , great job !
Gina
First time visiting, all around great food (short rib ravioli 😊) expresso martini 😊🍸and atmosphere! Waitress was great as well. My friends and I will definitely visit there again.
Linda
Always a great meal at New Mill. We live nearby and frequent this place often. Everything is delicious!!!
Morris
It was my first time there and my wife and enjoyed it. We will return for sure. Our server was Gabby and she was anything but! She was the consumate professional and refreshed our glasses when needed, kept us informed on our order and was generally delightful. I had looked at the website the day before attending and knew what I was going to have - the roasted beet salad and the stuffed chicken cutlet dish. Both were delicious, but I think I was thinking of a stuffed breast, cordon bleu so to speak, but the cutlets were delicious. The menu and specials should appeal to most people. My wife had a salad and fettucini dish which she enjoyed as well. The portions are generous and the food was very good. The tables were nicely spaced so no one felt cramped. It was a very nice experience and I will definitley return.
Edward
The best restaurant we have been to in 5 years through post covid. Great food. Genuinely attentive service and excellent value
Mary Anne
Excellent dining experience! Wonderful service (Lindsay was gracious & attentive), delicious food & wine. Would definitely recommend New Mill Restaurant!
Jennifer
I had the crabmeat stuffed cod which was cooked to perfection and the presentation was outstanding. The service was exceptional. Our waitress was friendly and timely. I would highly recommend the New Mill Restaurant.
Thomas
Excellent food and service. Very nice ambiance and vibe. We were able to have a conversation without having to raise our voices. Pricey menu but worth it for a special occasion.
KEn
Always a good meal with great service Bar area is very loud but there are plenty of other places to sit and enjoy the experience
Linda Mary
Always an amazing experience! We went last night for dinner - delicious. Gabby, our server, was friendly, knowledgeable, full of spunk and attentive. We will be back
I cannot say enough great things about this restaurant. The service, food, and atmosphere have made it a favorite place of ours. Thank you to our amazing server who was so sweet and you will not find a better steak anywhere.
Deborah
First and foremost, your favorite restaurant in town With that said, we chose the NEW OLD MILL in Celebrating our anniversary, & my husbands retirement ! Oh...we were pleasantly surprised at the tucked away romantic booth in the corner with the curtains. Thank you for accommodating my request!!  Michele, our server was outstanding. We enjoyed Vueve & Caymus perfect. My husband's steak special & my fish simply delish
Robert
Wonderful Dinner with Friends – A Perfect Evening! A group of five good friends got together for dinner on a Wednesday evening, and this restaurant turned out to be the perfect spot. The menu was impressive, offering a wide variety of options, plus several excellent specials that made deciding what to order a fun challenge. The food was absolutely delicious — every dish at the table was a hit. What really made the evening stand out, though, was the service. Michele, our waitress, was outstanding. She struck the perfect balance of attentiveness and giving us space to enjoy each other's company. Her timing and care added so much to the experience. All in all, it was an excellent evening — great food, great service, and even better company. We'll definitely be back!
Geri
I am never disappointed with the New Mill! My husband and enjoyed my birthday dinner there last night. Everything was amazing as always. I highly recommend the New Mill!
Nancy
I had the ribs, mashed potatoes and beans mine was delicious. My husband felt his chicken and shrimp was to garlicy. The main dining room was way too noisy. Unable to hear our conversation. Would return if we could request a quiet area of the dining room. Maybe second dining area.
The food was delicious as usual. Never disappoints. I have to give a shout out to the staff members serving at the bar. Each and every one of them was fantastic. Friendly, knowledgeable, great servers & bartenders . It's hard to find places were the staff is all of those things these days . They hit it out of the park , great job !
First time visiting, all around great food (short rib ravioli 😊) expresso martini 😊🍸and atmosphere! Waitress was great as well. My friends and I will definitely visit there again.
Always a great meal at New Mill. We live nearby and frequent this place often. Everything is delicious!!!
It was my first time there and my wife and enjoyed it. We will return for sure. Our server was Gabby and she was anything but! She was the consumate professional and refreshed our glasses when needed, kept us informed on our order and was generally delightful. I had looked at the website the day before attending and knew what I was going to have - the roasted beet salad and the stuffed chicken cutlet dish. Both were delicious, but I think I was thinking of a stuffed breast, cordon bleu so to speak, but the cutlets were delicious. The menu and specials should appeal to most people. My wife had a salad and fettucini dish which she enjoyed as well. The portions are generous and the food was very good. The tables were nicely spaced so no one felt cramped. It was a very nice experience and I will definitley return.
The best restaurant we have been to in 5 years through post covid. Great food. Genuinely attentive service and excellent value
Excellent dining experience! Wonderful service (Lindsay was gracious & attentive), delicious food & wine. Would definitely recommend New Mill Restaurant!
I had the crabmeat stuffed cod which was cooked to perfection and the presentation was outstanding. The service was exceptional. Our waitress was friendly and timely. I would highly recommend the New Mill Restaurant.
Excellent food and service. Very nice ambiance and vibe. We were able to have a conversation without having to raise our voices. Pricey menu but worth it for a special occasion.
Always a good meal with great service Bar area is very loud but there are plenty of other places to sit and enjoy the experience
Always an amazing experience! We went last night for dinner - delicious. Gabby, our server, was friendly, knowledgeable, full of spunk and attentive. We will be back
Restaurantji Recommends
I cannot say enough great things about this restaurant. The service, food, and atmosphere have made it a favorite place of ours. Thank you to our amazing server who was so sweet and you will not find a better steak anywhere.
First and foremost, your favorite restaurant in town With that said, we chose the NEW OLD MILL in Celebrating our anniversary, & my husbands retirement ! Oh...we were pleasantly surprised at the tucked away romantic booth in the corner with the curtains. Thank you for accommodating my request!!  Michele, our server was outstanding. We enjoyed Vueve & Caymus perfect. My husband's steak special & my fish simply delish
Wonderful Dinner with Friends – A Perfect Evening! A group of five good friends got together for dinner on a Wednesday evening, and this restaurant turned out to be the perfect spot. The menu was impressive, offering a wide variety of options, plus several excellent specials that made deciding what to order a fun challenge. The food was absolutely delicious — every dish at the table was a hit. What really made the evening stand out, though, was the service. Michele, our waitress, was outstanding. She struck the perfect balance of attentiveness and giving us space to enjoy each other's company. Her timing and care added so much to the experience. All in all, it was an excellent evening — great food, great service, and even better company. We'll definitely be back!
I am never disappointed with the New Mill! My husband and enjoyed my birthday dinner there last night. Everything was amazing as always. I highly recommend the New Mill!
I had the ribs, mashed potatoes and beans mine was delicious. My husband felt his chicken and shrimp was to garlicy. The main dining room was way too noisy. Unable to hear our conversation. Would return if we could request a quiet area of the dining room. Maybe second dining area.
Loading...