Matthew's Bakery

152 Selleck St, Stamford
(203) 658-8803

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cady H

Horrible customer service especially if you’re not Spanish. Went there 3 times for a cake they could never find my order had an attitude messed up the cake order design

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

jayasudha Reddy- Joseph (Jaya)

We have been customers for over a decade( started at their old location). Their sweets are well made, breads are fresh. Although, there are times I bought stuff which was not fresh and quite dry.
However, the customer service really needs an upgrade. I called to order, I was placed on hold for over 10 minutes after the initial hello, to place the order so I hung up. It's not the first time. It's quite frustrating. If this was streamlined better, I'm sure they will be amazing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Yefroim Troyb

Very nice place

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elder Sandoval

Their Bread is great, a little pricey but sometimes is worth it

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Donna Harrington

They have everything and anything you could want, and everything we tried was delicious! The tres leches cake was fantastic, as were the cookies and eclairs! The staff were helpful and friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Moses Boone

Local bakery with French esthetics.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

jamonia mercurius

Made my babies birthday cake. The cake was Minnie themed and they HAND DREW it for us. It was beautiful!! And I don’t say that lightly because I’m picky. They have a tablet of over 2K pictures and examples of their work. I don’t have a picture because we ate it up so quick.

Missy Heckman

I'm absolutely livid. I've been coming to this bakery for almost 2 yrs, as my husband loves the flan. When I first started coming the small personal flan was $5, then $7 and today $8. Too much for the size, but I could live with that for a flan once in awhile. What I find is outright extortion was the decorated cookie I purchased today. My son always asks for a cookie when we go and they are always $3 or $4. Today double. One cookie, very thin and not large by any means was $8. My son was extremely anxious today and there was a long line behind me so I was distracted and didn't notice till I left, and checked the receipt thinking about how 1 small flan (not a pie size), a soda and a cookie would be $18. I wasn't going to go back with my son in this mood, but I sure won't be returning! I feel totally taken advantage of. I have included pics of receipt, and the items next to other items to compare size. I'm so disappointed in this bakery!

Christine Agosto

I usually go to Matthew bakery with my Austic son. He loves it there. On 5/30/25, he usually well behaved but he accidentally drop one of there cookies in the container on the floor. He himself try to pick them up and it was by accident. Instead after me trying to explain it was an accident they charge me $4.00. Even just after purchasing already some of their items. Only one lady understood that it was an accident and didn't want to charge me but the other worker told her to still charge me.

Leinad Sonalletsac

Only the breads filled with cheese, the rest is average, nothing like Peru.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

LES45

First time here. I am a pastry nut and travel all over for great experiences in food so had to try this place. Pear tart is very good. Close to French bakeries. Cupcakes not so great and cream is not whipped and was hard. Their tarts are very good and cookies as well but cakes looks better than taste and texture.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Peach Tart, Flan Topped with Fresh Fruit

Glorimar Chiruzzo

It was three Kings Day And we bought a Rosca And it was very hard, very dry and very flavorless. We have Been using this bakery for over 10 years and I’ve Never been this disappointed in those 10 years of loyal clientele. I am Very furious and want a full refund I will be speaking to the owner/manager. Do not waste your money and I mean, do not waste your money on this nasty flavorless Bakery. If I was Able to Give this bakery less stars it would be 0

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

edel ramirez

I love the bakery and pastries here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lily “Lilylicious” Rohn

Had a craving for some new year chocolate, and this seemed to be the only bakery open.
We got a chocolate cigar that was hard as a rock and tasted like it was sitting around for at least 3 days. Disgusting. We also got an apple turnover that had maybe 2 bites of apple inside and was also hard as a rock and tasted stale. Total waste of money. We bought a chocolate cake that we haven't tried yet, but I don't have high expectations.
The sales girl didn't know pricing, and when we asked for a bag, she said they didn't have any. Then, seeing bags on the shelf, we asked for a plastic bag whi h I could plainly see, and she said no and gave us a paper bag that the cake box didn't fit in.

NEVER AGAIN

Edit: the chocolate cake that we wete.yold was a mousse with ganache WAS NOT. It was yet another old dry stale tasteless cake that was way overpriced. Not a mousse but a chocolate cake with chocolate icing
VERY DISAPPOINTED 😞

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Darwin Alvarez

The cakes are very expensive and the quality is standard to low. Ask about prices before buying..... The quality does not justify the price

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...