Cutie Pies Bakery & Cafe

Everyone loved our daughter's wedding cake and asked where we got it. Now we're getting cookies for our granddaughter. August is our grandsons birthday. Guess where we're getting the cake 😁

We haven’t been to Cutie Pies since the old owners left which was a while ago. We used to go a ton before. I finally stepped in because I was hoping for the cupcakes to match what was there prior since they still kept the Cutie Pies name. The frosting was hard as a rock & a little too sweet !! The cupcakes that used to be on display had a whipped frosting, soft, and flavorful and the cupcakes were just fluffy! These lacked some filling & seemed a tad over baked or a little dense. Kind of disappointed, but happy others had a better experience. The service was great though and it’s always nice to have kind people behind the desk. I am sure they offer what I was expecting if asked, but it would be nice to be able to just walk in if I want a cupcake randomly and be happy with my decision.

Purchased a dozen cupcakes for $42.00. Was very excited to bring these to graduation party for the kids. Cupcakes were small and somewhat stale. Basic cupcake with hard buttercream. No flavor..just sugar and hard. I had a strawberry cupcake which was a strawberry cake with little to no flavor, a mound of sugar buttercream topped with a very stale mini powdered donut. Not impressed...

I’m not fan of sweets but when I’m craving something sweet I only go to Cutie Pie, they have so many different flavors and different varieties.
The best place ever 10/10.

Chocolate cream pie was expensive, not firm and little taste

As a loyal customer of Tanya's cutie pies, I finally found myself back in the area to try out the new ownership. I thought the interior upgrade looked very cute so I optimistically bought some cupcakes. I got a cannoli cupcake, and aside from the small piece of cupcake shell I'm not really sure what was cannoli about it. It seems to be a marble cupcake with just a plain buttercream frosting. No cannoli filling. The cupcake was also extremely small, like almost comedically small. Disappointed because I would have paid accordingly what it would cost for a cannoli cupcake. Instead I wasted $3.50 and tossed the cupcake after 1 bite. We also got carrot cake cupcakes and they were just average. Not incredible like they used to be. I know it's hard to compare since they are 2 different ownerships but I was hoping there wouldn't be much change since the same staff was kept.

Everyone was super friendly, no complaints there!

I was Pokémon hunting and I always search for bakeries and I came upon this little cutie pie bakery you walk in it’s very clean. The service is friendly. They have all kinds of yummy scrumptious looking cupcakes and cookies. I chose to go with something light. I got a vanilla cupcake with whipped cream frosting. It was really whipped cream. It was delicious and fruit on top. Then I got the M&M cookie. The M&M cookie was good, but the cupcake was where it’s at. It was very delicate light and just scrumptious. I will definitely try some more and I suggest you try it as well. Very very good.

Very good dessert at such a good price!

When we had issues with our initial wedding cake order at a different bakery, we were recommended Cutie Pies instead. We could not believe our luck! We ordered two-tiered display cake and it was beautiful and delicious to boot! We could not have asked for better service or quality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake

my mom and i bought this tiny custom cake from cutie pie bakery for $100 and we were so disappointed :( the cake was super cute but the border wasn’t quite the color we asked for..plus we asked for a chocolate ganache filling and we got a block of hard chocolate in the middle of the cake instead! i just wish the bakers could’ve said they couldn’t make us a proper ganache for the cake before selling it to us. i am a baker. i worked at patisserie and i know what ganache is supposed to taste and look like, this was not it. the cake itself was pretty good, but definitely not worth the price. :/

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

They made a custom designed cake for our wedding, listened exactly to all the details and made it so perfect. It looked great, tasted great, and all our guests loved it. They even came in early to make it and deliver it on a holiday for us when they were closed. Thank you so much we highly recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kamela and staff nailed it for our wedding cake on 9/29/24!!! The quality of the cake was outrageous, and it was a mirror image of the picture we gave her!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Perfection!! Cutie Pies made our wedding cake and cookie favors for our beach wedding. Just as delicious as it was beautiful, all of our guests loved it! All of the staff at Cutie Pies were so helpful in the planning and execution of our vision. I highly recommend Cutie Pies and look forward to our next sweet treat from them in the future. Thank you for making our wedding day so special.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

I’ve ordered cakes for the last 5 birthdays of family and each cake has been fresh, delicious and wanting me to go back for a second piece every time! Will be ordering again for any celebrations

Very disappointed. Cutie Pies is under new ownership and it shows. I ordered 36 cupcakes for my baby shower and I expected them to be as good as the last time I ordered a party sized order. I found the cupcakes were hastily decorated and dry. They honestly tasted like leftovers and not as fresh as they once were. To be specific on flavors, I ordered resees cupcakes expecting them to have peanut butter and chocolate as I've previously had there. When I picked up the cupcakes there were no resees cupcakes in the order when I brought it to the attention of the workers there they opened up Easter Resees out of a bag and put them on top of the cupcakes right in front of my and said there you go. Like I was an inconvenience and they had to do more work to fix an order. Not only did I feel very undervalued as a customer but I also had the Resees falling off the cupcakes and were more work for me in the end to have to make the cupcakes presentable for the cupcake display at my baby shower.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2