Elenni's Italian Ristorante & Pub

40 Sherman Hill Rd #3611, Woodbury
(203) 263-2566

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kathleen Capozziello

Went there tonight for dinner. Ordered mussels and clams fried Diablo. I was lucky I got four clams and it wasn’t fried Diablo at all. The pizza was just OK Ordered coffee with cream cream was bad.Asked for my bill in which the owner waited on us, We sat there and waited because he was at the other end of the bar socializing with another Customer instead of getting us our bill. The bathroom is absolutely disgusting. The toilet was filthy and so is the floor. It was one of my favorite places not anymore.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nicholas Cicale

Fantastic restaurant! A must visit in May 2026!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Reggie coley

Two thumbs up. Great experience. Couldn't have been more pleased. Highly recommend eating here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gail Lawlor

This place is a joke. Went there for my husband's birthday, and the waitress was very rude. The food wasn’t great; it was hot in there, no air conditioner. I asked them to turn it on, and they did, but the door was open, so it wasn't efficient. Then I had a cake for my husband. I asked for plates, and they charged me $3.50 for two plates to use for the cake, but I was never told that I would be charged. Stay away from this place

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

carole peters

Today is Saturday, August 9 at approximately 4:45 My friend, And I entered this establishment with the intention of having a nice peaceful, good meal. There was a beautiful statue of Mother Theresa in the vestibule. When we sat down, there was no air-conditioning or lights. We politely asked move our table, because was very hot. I asked the man who came out of the kitchen. How was the steak and he just raised his arms in the he ordered drinks, soda, and water. We decided to leave I asked her to check to pay for my Gingerale and the gentleman came out of the kitchen. I think he may have been the owner yelling and cursing at us. Continuously asking us to leave using very dirty words and emotions towards us and said never to come back. His behavior was threatening, abusive, and hostile. This man should not be near an establishment with people. His mouth is full of disgusting filthy words towards women so we don’t know how the food was because we didn’t get a chance to even get a straight answer the question about the steak and we are calling our attorneys.
His behavior was biased and uncalled for what a disgusting Miserable man! First thing Monday morning, I am calling my attorney First thing Monday morning, and the Better Business Bureau and maybe even channel 12 and other news stations

Will Peter

Second time visiting better than the first. Food was timely in excellent. The staff was very friendly and accommodating as we arrived a bit late towards the kitchen closing hours.
And the owner really knows how to take care of the customer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Van Wormer

Dinners are average. Pizza made with red sauce was good.

Recently order a speciality white pizza with chicken sun-dried tomatoes mushrooms mozzarella and fresh basil. It was terrible. Basil was all you could taste.

We threw it out. I guess that says it all.

Dawn McCartin

A fantastic setting for a great meal. The service, food and atmosphere was awesome. Kudos to a great Easter ! You guys are the best!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alisa S.

i came here for the first time and it didn't disappoint. the environment is great and the food was incredible!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

VS

good place to hold an event with good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marvin Paige

Group luncheon. Large servings served family style. Great service and excellent food .

Rich P.

My wife and I stopped there for lunch. We waited almost 15 minutes at our table, the waiter never came over. After seeing the bad service and looking at the unappetizing food on the next table we decided to leave and find another place to have lunch. We were in the parking lot when the owner came out and started talking very loudly at us and accusing us of only coming in to use the restroom. I went to the men’s room to wash my hands before eating. Maybe they don’t wash their hands there. SCARY! We should have known right away that it would not be a good place to eat as there were only two tables of customers in the entire restaurant at peak lunch hour. It appears as others have delt with the owner with a bad attitude also. We won’t go back there to eat!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Erica Dian

The owner is extremely short tempered. The food was subpar. I would not recommend trying to reason with the owner.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

lizistrata

Kind of a throw-back look - but we liked it! Ordered pizzas and a pasta dish. The vegetable soup that came with the pasta was absolutely delicious and homemade. The pasta dish (cavateli with broccoli) was decent - heavy on the olive oil and not a lot of flavor, but not bad. It was a simple dish. The pizzas were ok/average - crust was a little underwhelming, the shrimp that came on the pizza were the baby shrimps. Would come back to try some of the other dishes to give it one more try before making a real decision on it.

B P

Excellent Italian food at reasonable prices. Great wings

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...