Captain Cookie & the Milk Man
2800 10th St NE, Washington
(202) 248-3814
Recent Reviews
Sort by
2800 10th St NE, Washington
(202) 248-3814
My companion and I came here 11/29/25 around 6pm, looking for a restaurant but we ran into a gentleman named either Durk or Derek (not sure what he said)but he was working the captain cookie counter tonight.
He was beyond professional and his hospitality was exceptional! That alone made us get cookies and ice cream. He took time and explained the process of their cookie making and where the ice cream comes from. He definitely deserves some recognition for his amazing customer service skills.
It is 5 o clock on a Thursday and no one is at this location to serve me.
Good cookies made with quality ingredients.
Doesn’t open on time
My go-to neighborhood spot. Solid, consistent ice cream flavors and their milk shakes are great too.
I got a combo selection: chocolate chocolate chip, regular chocolate chip, sugar, and molasses. All the cookies were spectacular, but I am still dreaming about that molasses cookie! It was soooo good!
Cookies are usually good, but they seemed like they were kept in a humidifier this most recent time. They should also consider updating their hours online. I showed up around 10:20 AM, but they wouldn't serve me because apparently they open at 11 AM (it says 10 AM online.)
Delicious cookies. The Dubai chocolate cookie is outstanding!
Delicious cookies. The Dubai chocolate cookie is outstanding!
Ordered through too good to go and the pick up time was between 11 AM and 9 PM. I got there a little after 8 and the store was closed. The employees were still there and wouldn’t open the door or talk to me. Bad experience. Need to update pick up time.
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in to this place bc it was along the way. It’s on the corner and hard to spot but I’m glad I found it. They have several flavors and I loved most of them. The cookies are also cleanly made, the staff is hard at work preparing right in front of you. Guy with the short twists hair was polite and working hard. Follow the reheating instructions posted at the counter. Would pick this over insomniacookies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought about 1 dozen cookies for takeout. They were superior to Crumbl in my opinion. Fastastic experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fresh authentic cookies never hurt anyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The have very very delicious cookies they have a great variety a must try!!!!
Just stopped in after a lot of morning walking. The service was perfect And friendly but the ice cream sandwich was amazing. I will absolutely be back and highly recommend them!
Loading...