Only a few others there, but took ages to get pizzas, then they brought one of the 4 out and said they’d deliver to table as they’re ready…apparently they can’t make 4 at once? Toppings were just ok, nothing special. One was very greasy, one was burnt. Definitely not worth all the hype or folks just haven’t had great pizza to compare to. And cash only? Any legit business accepts credit these days if they care about customer convenience more than skimming tax free off their books.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Jayne Leitzel
I have been a customer for many years. I have always enjoyed the fantastic pizza and sandwiches with homemade chips! I’ve referred many people. Yesterday when I returned home with my takeout sandwiches I was very disappointed to discover that the homemade chips had been replaced with bagged chips and there were no pickles either! When I called a nice young man very politely apologized and explained that the owners had changed the policy. You only get the homemade chips if you ask for them! I’ve never heard of such a thing. I always go there and don’t mind paying more for quality but that should not be something that should have to be requested.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Holly Miller
We ordered Mr. P's pizza for a work retreat recently. Justine and the team took great care of us and made everything easy. The pizza was delicious! Quite honestly the best pizza sauce I've ever had. The whole experience was top notch.
Fantastic pizza! Great service and food! Highly recommend! Happened to be in the area and glad we stopped for lunch!
Sharon Shaffer
Great pizza, but the busboy kept a bucket of water with rags right by the beer tap and in front of us, wringing out his dirty rags and going to tables to wipe them down with dirty water. It ruined my dinner thinking how many germs were spread about the restaurant and splattered my way. Will never go back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Jarrett Daffern
Great pizza, they should rent the space next door and expand into it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
M
Told us to sit wherever we wanted then made us move to another table. Only a couple other folks were there. Pizza slices were messed up, she even said they were but gave them to us anyway. If that's what they serve and are fine with that sad service, I'll go elsewhere. Pizza was just o.k. better than little Ceasars.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Mike Maurer
Excellent pizza and Italian fare. Cash only.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kendra Fogelberg
Delicious pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly Egbert
We wanted to find a local pizza place to enjoy with our family at the beach that wasn't a big chain company but was also reasonably priced. Mr. P's is reasonably priced and the wood fired pizza is not only delicious but also extra filling. The staff was very attentive and kind. It was a nice, locally owned vibe. I appreciated that they had a kid friendly movie playing and there was only one TV as opposed to a dozen and there was no loud music blaring. All of that made it more sensory friendly. We will definitely come back to eat their pizza when we come again. There are no restrooms, so plan appropriately if coming with children. Also, they are cash only but have an ATM.
Darn good pub style pizza! Speaking as pizza connoisseur, I can tell you there’s all different kinds of pizza and I don’t discriminate( I draw the line at “flatbreads”) Mr. P’s is pub/bar style which is honestly my personal favorite. The dough could use a little more cold fermentation but Im a pizza snob from NY so take what I say with a grain of salt. The cheese is high quality, the toppings are out of this world and the service is amazing. All in all, I’ll absolutely go back when Im in town and I’ll look forward to it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jacob Sines
On hold for 38 minutes and then they hung up on me. Ordered a pizza from Nicola's and they had it done in no time
al monster
Great pizza! Coal fired oven makes all the difference. Nicolas for Nicabolis, Mr. P's for pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Pizza
Daniela P.
The pizzas are pretty good, just that it's better to order in advance. Last time I went I have to wait 45 minutes to get 3 pizzas.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Carrie Davis
Great pizza ! Great Atmosphere!!! Definitely be back
Only a few others there, but took ages to get pizzas, then they brought one of the 4 out and said they’d deliver to table as they’re ready…apparently they can’t make 4 at once? Toppings were just ok, nothing special. One was very greasy, one was burnt. Definitely not worth all the hype or folks just haven’t had great pizza to compare to. And cash only? Any legit business accepts credit these days if they care about customer convenience more than skimming tax free off their books.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I have been a customer for many years. I have always enjoyed the fantastic pizza and sandwiches with homemade chips! I’ve referred many people. Yesterday when I returned home with my takeout sandwiches I was very disappointed to discover that the homemade chips had been replaced with bagged chips and there were no pickles either! When I called a nice young man very politely apologized and explained that the owners had changed the policy. You only get the homemade chips if you ask for them! I’ve never heard of such a thing. I always go there and don’t mind paying more for quality but that should not be something that should have to be requested.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
We ordered Mr. P's pizza for a work retreat recently. Justine and the team took great care of us and made everything easy. The pizza was delicious! Quite honestly the best pizza sauce I've ever had. The whole experience was top notch.
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Pizza, Mr P's Style Margherita, Wood Fired Pizza Peperoni
Fantastic pizza! Great service and food! Highly recommend! Happened to be in the area and glad we stopped for lunch!
Great pizza, but the busboy kept a bucket of water with rags right by the beer tap and in front of us, wringing out his dirty rags and going to tables to wipe them down with dirty water. It ruined my dinner thinking how many germs were spread about the restaurant and splattered my way. Will never go back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Great pizza, they should rent the space next door and expand into it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Told us to sit wherever we wanted then made us move to another table. Only a couple other folks were there. Pizza slices were messed up, she even said they were but gave them to us anyway. If that's what they serve and are fine with that sad service, I'll go elsewhere. Pizza was just o.k. better than little Ceasars.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Excellent pizza and Italian fare. Cash only.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
We wanted to find a local pizza place to enjoy with our family at the beach that wasn't a big chain company but was also reasonably priced. Mr. P's is reasonably priced and the wood fired pizza is not only delicious but also extra filling. The staff was very attentive and kind. It was a nice, locally owned vibe. I appreciated that they had a kid friendly movie playing and there was only one TV as opposed to a dozen and there was no loud music blaring. All of that made it more sensory friendly. We will definitely come back to eat their pizza when we come again. There are no restrooms, so plan appropriately if coming with children. Also, they are cash only but have an ATM.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Darn good pub style pizza! Speaking as pizza connoisseur, I can tell you there’s all different kinds of pizza and I don’t discriminate( I draw the line at
“flatbreads”) Mr. P’s is pub/bar style which is honestly my personal favorite. The dough could use a little more cold fermentation but Im a pizza snob from NY so take what I say with a grain of salt. The cheese is high quality, the toppings are out of this world and the service is amazing. All in all, I’ll absolutely go back when Im in town and I’ll look forward to it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
On hold for 38 minutes and then they hung up on me. Ordered a pizza from Nicola's and they had it done in no time
Great pizza! Coal fired oven makes all the difference. Nicolas for Nicabolis, Mr. P's for pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wood Fired Pizza
The pizzas are pretty good, just that it's better to order in advance. Last time I went I have to wait 45 minutes to get 3 pizzas.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great pizza ! Great Atmosphere!!!
Definitely be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...