Grotto Pizza

309 Auto Park Dr, Middletown
(302) 314-9500

Recent Reviews

Margie Abbott

Our server Donald was great and we had a short conversation with him about his travels through Europe. We'll ask for him on our next visit

Michelle Lynn

Food was great as always. Our bartender Larry was great as always!

Justine Sass

Absolutely disgusting. Cold rubbery pizza. Cheese was awful. Thankfully the service was good but that didn't help with the food. Not at all recommended.

Kandy Hall

First time trying Grotto pizza it was delicious will definitely eat there again.

Sharon Czech

Best Pizza! Cooked Perfectly! Amazing Antipasto Salad! Our Server Manny was Awesome! He was so Sweet and a Very Experienced. Manny Rocks!

Anthony Wilson

I always go here before the movies! The cheesesteak is amazing here and their pizzas are pretty good, too. The servers and staff are always nice and friendly and they work to make the place clean!

Susy Cabazza

Abraham was such a great waiter/bartender. Definitely coming back for his long islands. Pizza was delicious

Jeanette Arellano

Awesome bloody mary and good pizza, make sure you leave room for gelato !

Michael A

Surprisingly good pizza. I’m from NYC and I don’t care for most pizzas, but Grotto is pretty darn good. They have thin crust, really tasty sauce.Pro tip: they sell a “half baked” pie you can take home and finish off in your oven for the best to-go experience possible.

Willoam MacMillam

As always very good food is always good and the waitress is always nice


Grottos is always a good place to go in Middletown for food we always have good service and food is usually pretty good ??


Great food, great customer service from servers.

Deanna Dorn

Amazing, my personal favorite pizzeria.

Laura Wilks-Simms

Clean, Fun, Yummy. Love their familiar beachy menu. AND Bethany is such a sweet waitress!

Diane Vasaturo

Best wings around. You have to try the Grand Slam sauce. Best pizza is the Bakers Choice. Stop by Middletown and say hello to the best waiter, Abraham and best bartender, Larry.

Load More