Grotto Pizza

$$ • Pizza

309 Auto Park Dr, Middletown
(302) 314-9500


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Grotto Pizza

Surprisingly good pizza. I’m from NYC and I don’t care for most pizzas, but Grotto is pretty darn good. They have thin crust, really tasty sauce.Pro tip: they sell a “half baked” pie you can take home and finish off in your oven for the best to-go experience possible.

Ordered some Take & Bake (at home) pizzas from Grotto Middletown. Bake at home pizzas used to come in colorful waxy commercial-style packaging, now they just come wrapped in plastic in a standard take-out pizza box. I don't know IF they have changed how the pizzas are made and packaged, but our pizzas seemed OFF this time. We have had Take & Bakes before that taste pretty similar to the ones served in the restaurant. However, this time the pizza was dry. There was little to full review
Called ahead and placed an order for my Junior Pizza that was loaded onto my Grotto Swirl Rewards card for my birthday. Was told that it would be like 10 minutes. Staff on the phone was SUPER friendly. Upon arrival, I went inside to find that my pizza was not ready yet. I had to wait maybe another 5 minutes. My junior was served up hot and fresh. It was very tasty and a wonderful FREE reward! Overall, the pizza was excellent. I love Grotto's sweet sauce and slightly crispy full review

More Reviews(132)


Monday 4 - 10PM
Tuesday 4 - 10PM
Wednesday 4 - 10PM
Thursday 4 - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 12AM
Saturday 11AM - 12AM
Sunday 11AM - 12AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.