Randazzo’s Trattoria

$$ • Italian

About Randazzo’s Trattoria

Randazzo’s Trattoria is a popular Italian restaurant known for its good pizza and classic dishes. The atmosphere is basic, clean, and nicely decorated, creating a comfortable setting for diners. The staff generally provide very good service, with some reviews mentioning friendly and attentive servers, while others note that a waitress was not very friendly on one visit. The menu offers a variety of options, including pizza, Chicken Francaise, eggplant parm, and steak stromboli, all of which receive positive comments for their quality and flavor. The pizza, especially the classic slice, is highly recommended, with some diners describing it as very good even by Long Island pizza standards. Desserts such as cannoli, carrot cake, Tiramisu, and cheesecake are well-liked, with the Tiramisu and cheesecake receiving particular praise.

For drinks and sides, some guests experienced additional charges, such as a $3 fee for broccoli rabe instead of pasta and an unadvertised credit card up-charge. Despite these issues, most reviews highlight the restaurant’s good food, efficient service, and pleasant ambiance. The banquet room is also praised for hosting events with personalized touches that make guests feel like family. Overall, Randazzo’s Trattoria offers solid Italian cuisine, good pizza, and a welcoming environment suitable for casual dining and special occasions.

Customers' Favorites

Caesar Salad

Photos

Add a Photo

View All Photos

Randazzo’s Trattoria Reviews

4.5

92 ratings

79%

Food

Atmosphere

Service

Share your opinion about Randazzo’s Trattoria

Write a review

had them cater our Christmas dinner. The food was delicious lasagna meatballs sausage and peppers and out of this world banana pudding!! they are the best around!!

Place is amazing and food is awesome. Highly recommend!!

Wonderful meal! Our server, Angela, was excellent! Prices were reasonable. We are definitely coming back.

Read All Reviews(92)