Amore Pizza

430 S Old Baltimore Pike, Newark
(302) 369-1600

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Fatmack 410

They dont miss, food be bussin bussin

Myquia Wilks

Simple and easy for a quick bite

Trevor C

Their pizza is very salty. I throw up everytime I eat it.

Jennifer Brandon

This place is amazing, everything that I have ordered here was warm and tasty. I love the service that I received. ❤️

Stephanie k

From the food to the service this place has gone downhill… PSA everyone doesn’t eat pork so only having the option for cheese pizza available is with half pepperoni is inconsiderate! Ciao has better pizza anyway.

freshta Nisar

I use to love going to amores and ordering from the special menu that they had. I ordered a cheeseburger special and when I went to pick it up I looked at the receipt and saw it said double patty and I was told their cheeseburger special is now double patty which I don’t know why they did that. When I got home and started eating it wasn’t good at all the burgers were too salty and the fries were way too fried and salty. I don’t know why they made this change but I was upset because I love amores food but I’m going to be honest that was my last order with them.

Cassandra Sifford

I've been coming to Amore for years. Some months ago I started saucing my own wings from them. Seems like their wings started to get cooked hard so I asked them to not cook mine that way. My Mom had been having the same experience. I decided to just make my own wings instead. I love their canolli's! The lady with the chest tattoo does them the best lol I think her name is Jen. I've been in there 3x to get them and seems as tho she hasn't been there lately. The last 3x the middle has been completely empty. Last night I asked the young lady to make sure they're filled all the way thru. I get down to dessert and here they are again empty in the middle. I called to advise and they apologized. Now I gotta either make my own or go somewhere else 😢 Their pizza is pretty good tho! One time I asked them to add onion to the sausage slice, but he said they were too busy. Nevermind then smh

Tara Carbo

We took my son and his friends here after his birthday party. It's a small, cozy, little pizza spot in a little strip mall. It's hard to miss as it's not on a major highway, however it's perfect for what I needed it for. It has a few booths in there and the staff were amazing. We were the only ones there at the time so it was obvious that they knew we were there for my son's birthday, a pizza, etc. They asked if he wanted a couple slices of cake (said he would throw them in for free because it was his birthday) since we had already bought a cake we didn't need the slices but the fact that they offered was really thoughtful. They even sang with us and clapped after he blew out his candles. The pizza was great too. I like the fact that it wasn't like a big popular pizzeria. It seemed family owned because the pizza was that city type of pizza not like a papa John's or domino's pizza if that makes sense. Bottom line I would definitely recommend it.

Stacy Stewart

The food is always good no matter what I order.

June Novack

My ordered was wrong and when I called my choice was to come back and they would redo my order or come the next day. I asked for my money back!!

Debora Martin

We have been loyal customers here for a very long time! We love the staff so much!

Noah Conaway

Really great pizza. I have been a customer here since I moved to Bear back in 2021. Today I had an issue after calling in a pickup order for 3 large pizzas for a family gathering. Shortly after I called the order in, our family gathering got postponed. I called back the restaurant immediately (this is 10 minutes after calling in the order) and asked to have two of the pizzas cancelled, and that my wife and I would come get the one and have it for dinner. I was told that they would no longer let me order from them going forward because they were already done cooking them. I understand this is a waste of supplies by the business and I apologize for that, I don’t think this warrants being banned from the store (this was a one time thing, there ia not a repeated history of us doing this) it’s a shame, they have good food, and now we need to find a new place to order from.

Rod Symba

Amore Pizza is our family’s go-to spot, and Sam always makes it an incredible experience. Her kindness and attentive service make us feel so welcome every time we visit. My oldest son even knows her by name, which shows just how memorable she is!

The pizza is always fantastic, and the spaghetti is some of the best we’ve had. It’s become a cherished tradition for my son and my mother to stop by whenever they’re together. Thank you, Sam and the team at Amore Pizza, for consistently making our visits special! Highly recommend!

Mr. Steven Craig Smith Sr.

Wonderful large dishes of food

lady lush

Absolutely delicious food! Expeditious delivery and quality customer service!! EVERY TIME! EVERYTHING IS SPECTACULAR!

Loading...