La Piazza Di Caruso

830 Peoples Plaza, Newark
(302) 832-9000

Recent Reviews

Eva B.

I they are closed permanently. There was an article saying that the owner has passed.

S.L Lovesome

The owner used to make my pizza and it was always fresh. So sad to hear he was killed at his store. Such a nice guy who hired homeless people in hopes to help them get back on their feet. I will miss getting my pizza from here.

Corinne Youse

Alex, you were like my family. I sat there every Wednesday night with you for so long. You have no idea how much your company meant to me. The bartender, you and I were the only things I had to look forward too that was just for me. I wish I could get ahold of her. I want to tell her how much they meant to me I want to find peace and telling you how much I cared for you both would help. If you read this, try to get ahold of me.

GrandTour667586

The restaurant has outstanding service and food. I order delivery every two weeks, and the protons are large and a really wonderful value. I recommend this restaurant as excellent!

Jay T

Really good experience. Not enough staff. Waiter from El Salvador was totally awesome ?Chopped antipasta!!!!

jamiej68201

If I could give zero stars I would this was my first time and last time I’ll ever order from here! I got pizza, breaded mushrooms that were burnt to all hell, a caprese salad lol what a joke I’ll add pictures below and a Teramasu cake.. it came squashed this place is not my go to ever again and after calling and complaining they said they will give me a discount of 35% off.. not including my food was ordered and didn’t come for hour and half

bernarda426

Went with friends while back home and ate dinner. Had the lobster ravioli for the main meal. It came with baby shrimp in the sauce which I didn’t expect. The sauce was light and had a good flavor. The ravioli were good but lacked any actual lobster that I could tell. Service was a bit slow considering we were at one point the only table in the restaurant at the time. Overall not a bad place just not that great.

Dawn A.

We have been going here for years. I am not sure why the reviews aren't all great!? Alex and Cindy are always friendly and helpful! They have the best Mussels marinara and Pizza!!!!! Our food has always been fresh and delicious!!!

Erica Dunn

I heard great things about La Piazza Di Caruso but I am not impress. My co-worker and I wanted a go to place for our lunches when we do not bring lunch from home. After hearing such great things about this place I was excited. I love italian sub and unfortunately I am very picky about how the sub is made. I can't help it I was spoiled by Brother's Pizza when I lived in VA. I like my italian with lettuce, EXTRA EXTRA mayo, oil and vinegar and the WHOLE sandwich heated. I didnt get that though even though I was very detailed, I mean detailed!!! I could get past the no lettuce, the sandwich not heated but I draw on the line with the MAYO!!!!! There was barely any mayo on the sandwich, the sandwich was dry it didn't even taste edible. When a person says EXTRA EXTRA they mean extra mayo, not a slather. A slather is not EXTRA EXTRA mayo! I will just keep on looking.

Robin Chatterjee

Good New York style pizza. Wife and kid loves it..That's all that matters.. Highly recommended

Fred Straka

as soon as I opned my take out I found a HUGE HAIR in my meal and threw it in the trash. I remeber seeing a bunch of workers in the food prep area and not one hair net among them. disgusting! I will not be going back here!

Jaime Muth - Pearl Video

This place is filthy. Employees act like you bother them just by being there. The appetizer was good but entrees quite lacking. Couldn't even get a full refill on water.

Rivera

I placed an order on Grubhub about an hour ago. Finally received my order only to find out I got somebody else's order. I tried calling TWICE only to be sent straight to voicemail. Grubhub gave me a complete refund. This is my first and last time ever ordering from here.

Julie Greenwood

Do not go in this place. Would guess new owners or new management. So shady. Used to be a go to place for pizza. Will never set foot in here again.

Khaled Haider

This was possibly the worst meal I have ever had from a restaurant. I ordered Broccoli and Chicken Alfredo and the chicken was just pieces of cartilage. The broccoli was frozen and not thawed out properly so it was just soggy. The Alfredo sauce was so bad I threw the whole meal away. They gave me some shredded lettuce as a side salad but at least the complimentary bread was decent. It was a complete waste of time and money and I will never eat here again.

Load More