McGlynns Pub - Pike Creek

After 5 years of horrible experience after horrible experience, decided to give them a try and just grab a sandwich. what a mistake. Roast beef sandwich came out LITERALLY (and trust me I know how to properly use the word, and I'll post a pic) RAW. Sent it back and told them to keep it, it was disgusting. Total incompetence, I have no idea how that could be served and meat that raw be placed onto a roll. They're going to get someone sick! NEVER AGAIN!

Tried to stop in for the prime rib special and all you can eat shrimp special after a 10 hour work day and eating nothing. Seated at a table and after almost 15 minutes the host who sat us didnt even recognize us or remember where we were. Mind you it is not even remotely busy for this location. After mentioning we haven’t been greeted by a server the people that were seated after us were immediately met with a server (the server was the same boy that my girlfriend had just told we had been waiting to be helped at our table.) Terrible, unorganized service. Walked out after seeing that.

Service: 1

Jill was a spectacular bartender! She was very up beat and friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good place for some drinks with friends or a meal with the family

Kid-friendliness: Always see families in there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hamburger, Los Nachos Grande

Pretty standard pub food but well-executed. We came for their appetizers, which are especially good. The french onion soup was delicious. We also enjoyed the apple salad. We didn't order alcohol (it was like 2:30 PM , and we're not big drinkers).

Our meal ended up being a bit more expensive because we ordered four apps and split one entree, but it was a tasty and relaxing late lunch.

Service was great. The wait staff were exceptionally attentive and helpful, without being intrusive. We had a ton of little plates on the table to shuffle. They helped us manage it, bussed dishes quickly to make more space for us as we finished them, and were quick with drink refills.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup

Great atmosphere incredible wings there Chesapeake sauce wings are incredible Id come back just for those

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My first time ordering from here I got the salmon and they didn't give me mashed potatoes that I chose for my side or the pineapple sauce that was supposed to go on it. I called and the guy gave me an attitude when I asked for a refund and then hung up on me so on my way home I stopped up and the manager said I should have never been hung up on and they refunded me for my meal. They didn't. I'll never eat here again. The one in Peoples Plaza is so much better but too bad I don't live near there anymore. I don't recommend this place at all and I do like McGlynns food.

Wings are gross! Ranch and blue cheese were gross too! Waste of money.

Food: 1

My friend and I were looking for a late lunch sandwich / burger in the area. We stopped by McGlynn’s Pub. We are certainly glad we decided to try their “Kitchen Sink Burger”. What a fantastic meal, yes this burger is not just a burger but an entire meal. You name it because it’s part of the burger ensemble. Fried egg, mozzarella, Onion rings, etc.
I’m from Southern Maryland and this is the best burger I have had in quite some time.
4.5 stars
Very friendly staff
If you’re in the area check out McGlynn’s on Polly Drummond Road Newark you won’t be sorry.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hamburger

Got the hot roast beef sandwich and it was incredible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got the hot roast beef sandwich and it was incredible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wait staff did what they could, however the kitchen was extremely backed up. We order drinks and app at 6pm and it wasn’t until 7 the apps were brought out. Then when the entrees came out, short ribs and mash were ice cold. Waited another 25 min while my family ate their food while I waited for my meal to come out. The manager brought out my food and apologized for the wait. The waiter was nice stating the short ribs would be comp. When the receipt came out the short ribs weren’t comp. When my husband asked why it wasn’t the server stated the manager refused. When my husband asked to speak with the manager the server stated the manager would not come out. Then another waitstaff stated the manager was a D**K which I see to be true. For a customer to request a manager and be told the manager basically didn’t care. And for a waitstaff to tell a customer what they really thought about the manager. Just goes to show you. At that point it is what it is. We would not be stepping foot back into any of your establishments and I would not recommend this place to anyone either. And I wish I didn’t just go there, I wished I would’ve read the reviews before. My stomach hurts even more after reading about roaches crawling out of someone’s food. Disgusting.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Friendly local tavern with great sandwiches and beer selection

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Popcorn, French Onion Steak Sandwich, French Onion Soup

Pike Creek's best bartender and hand-cut fries that'll make you give up keto.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hamburger

Service is good from the bar staff though I had on two separate days occasions a roach once outa my food which the Bartender caught it and the second I killed it In a napkin the manger gave the meal for free the second time nothing but a apology. The patrons are good people ! The popcorn is old the all you can eat shrimp was over cooked .

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3