Nutter's Sandwich Shoppe

1219 Nottingham Rd, Newark
(302) 731-4672

Recent Reviews

Michael Forman

Great local sandwich shop with many unique items. Good quality ingredients and they have never gotten my order wrong. Note that Nutter's is take out only

Daniella Volochii

Drove all the way out here to get food just to find them closed. I watched 2 other people pull in to end up in the same predicament within the 5 minutes I was there. Please list your hours correctly

AeLin Compton

Our sandwiches were so good! Exactly what you want after mountain biking or a long run. Friendly staff, nice variety of vegetarian and meat options. Highly recommend.

Bam Townley

Great crab bisque and sandwiches. Sandwich portions are large. Parking is tight and no where to sit down and eat but it's worth the stop!

Mark H.

Great sandwiches and amazing crab bisque! Everything is reasonably priced and high quality. The only draw back is parking can be a little hard to find but it is well worth it for the food!

Regina Tucker

We stopped by and got the crab cake platter and cream of crab soup! It was delicious!

Ellen M.

Best crab bisque around. Unique blend of ingredients in sandwiches. Always delicious.

john hughes

They do not skimp and make a nice fat sandwich for you. Try the chicken salad..it is delicious. Parking and leaving can be a challenge with traffic sometimes

Matthew Stark

I would give 5 stars but they toasted my bread and it was too hard to eat. Food is great otherwise and staff are really nice. Next time I'll ask them not to toast my bread. Make it an option please.

Dreà

Very Friendly, Staff made recommendations and they bring your order out to your car when it’s ready :) The Crab Bisque & Cuban Sandwich are Delicious! Will be Back!!!

Brennen Raimer

Today I went to try Nutter's for the first time. I ordered the cuban. 10 minutes later, when they brought it out to me, they had the wrong order and had to go back and remake it. Another 5ish minutes pass, apologize and hand me my order. I get home, open my order: italian sub and crab (?) fries. It s a good sandwhich, but this is not what I ordered. Also getting in and out of that parking lot is a nightmare

Edward Stubbs

This was our first time ordering from there. One of the best things was, you were greeted with a friendly ? sincere "hello" as soon as you walked through the door, by the staff. That was really refreshing. We had the crab cake special. One crab cake sandwich and the crab cake platter. Both were very delicious. The Homemade Crab Bisque was DEE? LICOUS. Hot when served and the "soul slaw?" was great! It was a little hike for us, about 7 miles but, it was worth it and we can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Thank you "Nutter" for a delicious meal and a wonderful experience ?

Rick S.

Excellent local find. All take out at the time but we ordered several Italian subs and the Gouda Buddha. All were crash and excellent. Solid joint.

Jason H.

Amazing Crab Bisque. They don't have it everyday, but when they do, get in line. It will change your world

Brad Beebe

Great sandwiches and subs. The meatball sub is outstanding. The crab bisque was very well executed.

Load More