Dalmata Italiano

28 Wilmington Ave E, Rehoboth Beach
(302) 227-8512

Recent Reviews

Vicky T.

Pizza was really good - had the fig & prosciutto - yummy! Caesar salad was also good. Drink menu options were also good. Very friendly service - though it was obvious they were short staffed (bar, waiter & kitchen staff) they remained unruffled & attentive. Cute atmosphere - old school family bistro style. Family friendly & we noted a busy carry out service. Would definitely recommend & will return!

Bob L.

The food here was very good. I got the steak pizza, and it was a good thin crust pizza. Not a whole lot of food, and pretty expensive. Service was good, and had an interesting atmosphere. Bathroom lights add some character.

Bruce B.

Friendly service, pizza is excellent ( and I'm from NY), different kinds pizzas, definitely try the fig and prosciutto.

Janet P.

My first experience with the pizza from this place was a takeout order. We sampled the Pepperoni 101 and the Sausage and Peppers. The pepperoni was crispy and with had loads of little pepperoni slices. Of course, my traveling friends have noted that you don't really see pepperoni served in Italy, but it's a staple over here! Very flavorful sausage and peppers, a lot less heavy on the meat topping than the pepperoni. We visited the restaurant on a rainy evening. Not at all crowded. Decor is old style American pizza place, even the beer mugs are the old heavy glass. Cute, but a much smaller pour than a pint. The white lightening is tasty with these crispy kale chips. The spicy boy is a very flavorful. Note, the anchovies on the Caesar are an upcharge. Not your average pizza and priced for it as well. (Now, let's see if "joe t" from Lewes gives this an "oh no").

Meg S.

Handmade pasta, yes! Sublimely thin crust pizza, yes! Peanut butter pie, yes! This has been our winter comfort food go to and it has not disappointed! Also want to note the conscientiousness of Tamara, who went out of her way to make sure our order was perfect. Tip top customer service!

James L.

Very good food, especially the pasta. All the staff were wonderfully welcoming and friendly. A hidden gem that despite the address, is around the corner on 1st Street. Perfect restaurant for a winter night.

victor hall

Went in to nite on recommendations from a friend. Website says they were open. They were not.

ally yan

The pizza and pasta is incredible. I loved the sauce, cheese, crust combo. Perfect. It's the best pizza I've had in Delaware.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jules

Over priced for very unsatisfying food. I ordered the pepperoni pizza and added ricotta and roasted garlic as a recommendation from another patron who wrote a review on here.The pizza was ok. Nothing special and not worth the price for 6 slices. But what really pissed me off was the carbonara pasta I ordered. I asked for the dish to be made with spaghetti instead of the option they had but didn't get it, maybe they didn't read the note I left on my doordash order but whatever. Upon first looks it looked absolutely dry so i knew i was gonna be pissed. After the first bite I was tempted to go back and return all the food I got but I was on my way to work while picking up my order and couldn't. That dish was so far from carbonara its ridiculous. It was just grease and "homemade" noodles of all sizes and lengths with hard bacon thrown on top. Flavorless and dry. Italian is my favorite so I've tried many pasta dishes from everywhere and this has to be the worst experience I've ever had. The staff was nice when I picked up the food and the atmosphere was kid friendly and mom-pop-ish. But it was a waste of money for me. I hope they revamp their pasta dishes, add flavor and serve more authentic food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Rosemarie S.

A cold rainy night. A warm, welcoming restaurant. Wonderful staff, very solid pizza. It really is a hidden gem. I love pizza, but always do a calorie:tasty balance on how much I eat. No pizza came home. Give it a try as your neighborhood pizza/Italien restaurant.

Mary Wiegand

Amazing pizza and incredibly welcoming and fun staff (both to us and our two pups)!! We got the margherita, spicy boy, and a lovely bottle of wine. Vegetarian and gluten free options too! Will be coming back!! 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carolyn Wegemann

Went for the first time tonight and had a wonderful meal! We got a Caesar salad, pepperoni pizza and cocktails and everything was great! The owners were fabulous and the vibe was impeccable! Definitely will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kyle Sefcik

Amazing Food and Service. They make it all fresh and on house, and you can taste it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Guide53095346585

Outstanding food & service we were treated like royalty. Wonderful experience pizza’s were delicious.we have lived on the shore for 18 years and this was one our best experiences. When we arrived the owner held he door open for us and directed us to our table, unfortunately I’m in a wheelchair and l was treated so good and they have large enough restrooms that we could easily get into with room to spare unlike most places in our area we will go back often thanks to the owners for a delightful dinner and service.

Mia Collins

This place is amazing and the managers are wonderful! We went here for the first time yesterday and the managers were so nice and attentive. We met the owner as well and she was lovely. The food is so yummy! We had the burrata salad, mushroom soup, the white pizza, and pasta. The pizza was crispy and hot. The salad was delicious! We went back the next day because of how great everything was. We got the Cesar salad and the margarita pizza as well as the burrata salad and white pizza again. Thank you Kevin and Tamara for making our last two days great and yummy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More