Starkey's Ice Cream

13 S Wilmington Avenue, N Boardwalk, Rehoboth Beach
(484) 557-7269

Recent Reviews

Gabrielle Stacy

Turned out lights before 9:45 while listing says open until 11pm.... Not that hard to change a time on Google...

Juliet Lancey

This is the best ice cream in Rehoboth with tons of great, unique flavors. The young woman working the Friday and Saturday of Labor Day weekend went above and beyond with how kind and helpful she was. Great people & great ice cream :)

Michelle Compton

The brown butter brittle truffle shake was amazing, will definitely get again. We also had rainbow snow cones, chocolate pb ripple shake, and double fudge brownie cone. I can say that all were approved by the kids and disappeared quickly.

Evgeniya Smith

The worst customer service! The guy with red face (manager/owner?) yelled at me because I did not want to deal with his employee's mistake. I just wanted a scoop of ice cream in a waffle cone. The girl told me that in order to get a cone, I had to get 3 scoops. I said nevermind then, I'll take 1 scoop in a plastic cup. The girl went to get it and handed me the cup. My friend asked what's the smallest amount of ice cream she could get. I showed her my cup, saying this is 1 scoop. The girl then said no this is 2 scoops. I was confused why 2 and the girl said because this is the minimum they can sell. If she told me that upfront, I would have gotten 2 different flavors. At that point the guy with red face walked in and started yelling at me saying 'come on, she DID tell u that, she is my best employee, and if you don't like something, you can leave.' He was not present for the conversation, so he just chose to escalate the situation instead of fixing the ice cream. Very rude!

Jason Persaud

Great ice cream right on of the boardwalk.Lots of interesting ice cream options. Tons to choose from...indeed something for everyone: ice cream, sundaes, snow cones, drinks and milk shakes. Soft serve options too!Efficient and friendly staff.

Jemlnlx

Great ice cream right on of the boardwalk. Lots of interesting ice cream options. Tons to choose from...indeed something for everyone: ice cream, sundaes, snow cones, drinks and milk shakes. Soft serve options too! Efficient and friendly staff.

E V

Starkey's slaps harder than Will Smith at the Oscar's! It is THE QUINTESSENTIAL boardwalk icream. The selection is massive, overwhelming in the best way. The actual ice cream: technical perfection. The sevice: friendly AF. The ambiance: legendary. Don't worry about the line, the treat is worth the wait - you won't be dissapointed!

Erik V

Starkey's slaps harder than Will Smith at the Oscar's! It is THE QUINTESSENTIAL boardwalk icream. The selection is massive, overwhelming in the best way. The actual ice cream: technical perfection. The sevice: friendly AF. The ambiance: legendary. Don't worry about the line, the treat is worth the wait - you won't be dissapointed!

Nelson Ruiz

Lots of options for the whole family

Lisa D

Ice cream was ok. I ordered a peanut butter marshmallow and it had chocolate which was unexpected. Oddly you cannot get a single scoop serving. Minimum two scoops.

Ruth R Larrabee

We got chocolate and vanilla swirl frozen custard on a waffle cone. Delicious!

Mark Witmer

Good ice cream, loved the hazelnut!

Tylisa Hampton

It was a one-man show this Saturday but the gentleman was very professional and very nice

Emily Cajigas

The oatmeal cookie ice cream was really good, very small portions for the price and this ice cream melted really fast.

Jennifer Ferrufino

Really yummy funnel cakes! Big crowd but fast service :)

Load More