Atlantic Social

We dined on a Saturday night with a group of 9. Our server was very kind and attentive, the atmosphere was chill and not too loud or chaotic, and the food was perfect! The cocktails were also delicious. We had a reservation and were seated immediately. I highly recommend this restaurant. Great service, good food, and all done in a friendly and efficient manner. I also recommend the SoHo penne and the limoncello martini!

I just want to say that the food and drinks were really good. Pizza is a little pricey, but it is what it is... I was there with a few ladies from our neighborhood to have drinks, food and chit chat. We were so rushed that the pizza came out as we were having appetizers and salad We did tell the staff to slow down and not bring everything at once. Before you knew it the check was there and we were done.

Had a great dinner tonight at Soho slice. Husband and I split a salad, ordered a Margherita pizza, and had dessert. Everything was very tasty, especially love the pizza with a nice thin crispy crust! Our server, Kevin was great and we will definitely go back again!

12 of us and the staff did a great job. I would recommend the Greek salad and the cheese bread. The cheese bread is like a pepperoni pizza but cut up. That all you need to be filled up!

Our party of six was seated quickly because we made a reservation earlier in the afternoon. This was our 2nd visit and did not disappoint. We've sampled most of the pizzas and all have been very good. The dough was just right, not too heavy or overly-doughy and just the right mix of sauce, cheese as well as other ingredients depending on the pie selected. The garlic cheese bread starter was excellent. Crispy and not soggy and not overly garlicy either. The meatball sub was excellent as well as the spaghetti and meatballs; delicious tomato sauce. The smoking soho pie was excellent; delicious mix of flavors and light on the red onions which I prefer. Service was very good and the prices are reasonable. The bar toward the front of the restaurant seems like a cool spot to hang out with plenty of tv's broadcasting sports while we were there. Given the great service, reasonable menu prices and delicious food options we will be back for a 3rd visit soon.

Very accommodating staff. Good food and a fun evening. The one comment I would make is that twice I have ordered a martini but said not dirty. Both times arrived dirty. Also we ordered food with changes they said they were willing to make but the food came with the sauce from the menu and had to be redone so reading what the wait staff puts down would really enhance the experience

Good pizza - lots of options too - the kids individual pizza was basically the same size as adults - good to know for sharing! Had Cobb salad - huge portion with good - fresh ingredients - definitely enough to share. Our server was very knowledgeable about the menu choices & she took good care of our party of 2 adults & our 2 grandkids. It was a later lunch on a weekday so pretty quiet but we absolutely appreciated being able to make a reservation to ensure a table! Would recommend & return.

Server was excellent - Kevin paid just the right amount of attention to us. We enjoyed our conversation and our food - great place.

The chicken was rubbery and the pizza was no where close to a soho slice. We didn't finish our food and threw out the leftovers.

Good not great. Wings were very good, pizza was alright. Thought it was a bit flat and needed more seasoning. It's also not really NY style as the name might imply.

We had a good night. Nice environment but my ricotta pizza has no flavor. I ate one piece and tossed the rest. I was sad! My family did enjoy their food though

We were a group of 6 for dinner. We all ordered dinners which were very enjoyable. The eggplant parm was very good. Excellent flavored red sauce.

The pizza and sandwich were both solid—especially the NY-style pizza, which was done really well. Hoping they can maintain that level of quality over time. Service was just okay, which seems to be a trend with this restaurant group (similar experiences at Blackwall Hitch and Atlantic Social). So, if top-tier service is a priority for you, this might not be the spot. The atmosphere is lacking—it feels a bit bare, with no art on the walls and a wide-open layout that makes it feel unfinished. Could use a bit more personality to match the food.

First of all, strange name for a restaurant which does not serve pizza by the slice. Decor is fresh and modern. Service is very attentive. Four cheese pizza had nice crust but was ultra bland in taste. Filet mignon rigatoni was tasty but unexpected in a sort of brown scallopini type sauce. Noise level in restaurant was high, considering it was half empty. Willing to try again with some other entree choices.

Can't say enough good things about this new pizza/Italian place that recently opened in the former Atlantic Social location on Rt.1. Drinks are reasonably priced, and while the cost of the pizza is in the “gourmet” range, the quality is superb, the toppings are generous, the sauce is truly homemade tasting, and the service was excellent and friendly. Every table was filled, so it pays to make a reservation.