Theo's Steaks, Sides & Spirits - Rehoboth Beach

We read such great reviews of Theo's that we decided to try it. Every single thing we had, was mediocre at best. We were expecting Prime steaks and we got, choice or lower. Having been in the restaurant business ourselves for over 40 years, I think we are a pretty good judge of the quality of food. We don't mind paying $70+ for a great steak if, we get the best. We had to search for the tuna, in Tuna Tartare. You seem to have a good location with good clientele. Give them the quality that the prices, equate. Being in the business, we always give a restaurant a second chance. Hopefully, we will see a difference in our return.

Our first visit to Theo's, although the restaurant has been there for a few years... A very nice indoor space, the food was excellent. The French Onion soup was very good. We had a wagyu steak for two that melted in your mouth. The chateaubriand was also excellent. For dessert, we had the brownie, and the crème brûlée cheesecake, which was outstanding. Very high marks to our server, Craig, who was patient, engaging, friendly and professional. We remembered him from another restaurant, so it was nice to see him again. A++

We love going to Theo's. This evening we were served by Tina. Excellent service and ambiance. Look forward to going back.

Our waitress Lauren and her trainee, I can't remember his name, were absolutely wonderful! My mom and sister need to eat GF and Lauren and her trainee were super supportive and extra cautious making sure the food was safe and accurate. They always had a smile on their face regardless of how many questions we asked. Lauren paced our dinner out wonderfully. My martini with stuffed olives was fantastic, beef tournedos were cooked perfectly and I highly recommend, the shrimp and grits which had amazing flavor... kudos to the chef. And the bartender made one fantastic old fashioned. We will definitely be back!

An excellent evening. The service beverages and entrees were delicious. Our server was attentive and took great care of us. Definitely worth a visit.

Made our 1st trip this year for Date Night last evening .......... Service and food were exceptional!!!

Another excellent dining experience. The menu, with its outstanding meat and seafood options (a vegetarian entrée is available for those so inclined), offers wonderful choices. This evening we opted for Parmesan Salmon, moist and flavorful, with the accompany couscous with asparagus tips delicious enough to be an entrée on its own; and Steak Diane, featuring expertly prepared tenderloin medallions (two three-ounce filets), mushrooms and fabulous red wine sauce, accompanied by silky mashed potatoes. Both dishes arrived professionally plated – works of culinary art. Pre-dinner drinks are very good and arrive quickly. A substantial wine list offers many options: a Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc and a Malbec were the evening's choices, both perfect accompaniments to our entrees. The dessert list, while limited, allows for some delightful possibilities. The “Fried” Ice Cream is comprised of three sizable scoops of vanilla ice cream rolled in toasted corn flakes, creating the semblance of the standard fried ice cream dessert: crunchy and delicious, expertly placed with drizzles of delectable honey – perfect to share. Service is always professional and cheerful, making one's dining experience that much more pleasurable (a shout out to Rob for providing excellent charming and attentive service). The culinary genius which emanates from this kitchen makes dining here an easy choice, resulting in a memorable evening.

Amazing dinner in a beautiful restaurant to celebrate a friends birthday. The Himalayan salt rock shrimp and tenderloin combo was an excellent start, followed by Parmesan encrusted Salmon superbly prepared. The wine selection was delightful. The surprise ending was a pink cotton candy cake complete with a candle to celebrate the big 60. Highly recommend Craig was our waiter and made our night extra special.

came for 44th anniversary, Server Rob was awesome as was the salmon, New York, margaritas and cheesecake. way above 5 stars

Best steaks in town. Worth the price. Staff top notch. A little tight inside tho.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

Had drinks at the bar. Then to a table for an outstanding dinner. Can't wait to go back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

A charming, smaller restaurant that does everything in a big way! Tastefully designed interior with a cozy, inviting feel. They have a wide range of dishes so something for everyone. We had the Steak Diane and Parmesan salmon. Both were delicious! Our friends had the Chateaubriand which was enough for 3 people and very tasty. The place was packed when we were there so it seems they have a good following and reputation. We are certainly coming back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chateaubriand

Subsequent visit. Thank you so much for bringing back the barbecue shrimp!

Love coming to Theo's. But what happened to your BB shrimp? Was one of my favorites. Was disappointed to no longer see it on the menu. Please bring it back.

Theo's sent me a coupon for my birthday. $25 off. We went there specifically to use the coupon. We had Chateaubriand, a salad, a martini and a dessert. The bill came to $148. They would not honor the coupon because it was a Thursday and the Chateaubriand was the special (it came with a bottle of wine for $99). Given how much we spent, it seemed cheap and short sighted to not take the coupon they sent me. It doesn't say on the coupon its not allowed with specials. It was a cold Thursday so the place was not that busy. Its not likely we will go to Theo's again. Yes they have good steak (the rest is mediocre) but there are other places that arfe happy to have our business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chateaubriand

All of our food was delicious, from the drinks, to the appetizers, to the main courses, to dessert. The serving size was perfect. Service was excellent, and the restaurant has a great atmosphere. They also offer weekly specials, a great happy hour, and even have a reward program. The food is so good, and we highly recommend eating here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Salad, Meatloaf & Creamy Whipped Potatoes & D, Steak