Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza

5611 Concord Pike, Wilmington
(302) 477-1488

Recent Reviews

Vadim Shyfryn

Absolutely stunning experience!!! Best pizza I’ve ever had in my life!!!!This place is breathing with history

Tomspom

Anthony's is always a nice change. The original wings are my favorite.

Sharon Murphy

After waiting an hour for our delivery, it arrived burnt and cold, this was my first time ordering from this establishment and it will be my last. I called them immediately and after speaking with 3 different people and having to explain my complaint I was offered a restaurant credit to which I flatly refused. Let's see how quickIy I get my full refund.

Shaun Neal

Was shopping at Trader Joe's next door and needed a quick dinner. Ordered two 16" pizzas for take out - $40 + tax/tip. Crust was burnt, although maybe burnt pizza is a thing now? Sauce was really salty. Dough was not chewy. Pizza was cold after a 10 minute drive home. There are plenty of other local mom/pop places in the area where you will get a cheaper, better, non-burnt pizza. Pat's Pizza, Giordanos, heck even Grotto is better and cheaper. Look at the other reviews - there are months and months of similar comments, and they respond with some cut/paste corporate nonsense about how they will do better. Save your time and money, go elsewhere.

Andrea Mccullough

Can not say enough good things first time here food was amazing drinks were amazing service was great and the food was not over priced like many places definitely got our moneys worth and will be back soon

Frank J. Giacobbe

Pizza is thin and delicious. Wine menu is good. And beer selections good along with specialty drinks. Other items on the menu beside pizza. Great service.

Marcus Wilson

This place is Amazing! I recommend the dry rub wings, and the meatballs.

Jasmine S.

Stopped in for pizza (yay!) I haven't been to Anthony's since pre pandemic and remembered how amazing the pizza was, so I grabbed a friend and we went. I will say the hostess seemed a bit frazzled but it didn't take long to be seated at all and for our waitress (Hannah) to come and get our drink orders. Our order seemed simple enough: traditional pie (with pepp, mushrooms, and arugula) and a Caesar salad. The salad was out quick, and devoured. The pizza however took another 30 mins. It got to the point where we wondered if we should've ordered an actual appetizer. It was prime dinner time on a Friday, yes. Also, the inside picked up with people waiting for a table and the curbside pick up was at least 7 cars down. The pizza however ? Amazing. So if you want it, maybe order ahead.

Pat DiCola

One our favorite places. Great food, great service.

Vaughn Y

They were busy when we went, so I suppose they could be better during slower times. However, the pizzas were thin, overdone (as advertised), and not particularly good.The food is not worth nearly what they charge.

Alex Park

The delivery was late, but they did deliver eventually. They delivered cancer to me! Thanks Anthony!

Jason Firko

Just ate here last night. We had salad, wings (original and the romano), a margarita and a pepperoni pizza. Everything was great. The coal oven gives the pizza a unique taste which I like. The romano wings were fantastic. Our waitress Hanna G was very good, the best waitress we've had in a while. Timely with the food, new plates, napkins, drink refills, we were never waiting for anything or wondering where anything was. Overall a great experience, even though it is a little pricy for pizza it was worth it and we will be back.

Susie Turlington Pope

great service and loved the atmosphere.

Frank K.

This place is way overrated and not worth your time or money, IMHO. Pizza is sloppily thrown together, crust burnt black around the edges, and simple plain tomato sauce, nothing special. And over $20! Wings were so-so, nothing to get excited about. We've tried them 3 times because others rave about them. No more. Too many choices to keep going back. Not worth it.

Jim Rizzi

Excellent service, salad, and pizza!

Load More