Absolutely the best pizza. Crust is perfect, toppings a plenty.
robert chinnis
The staff were pleasant but the pizza was like chewing rubber. We ordered a 14 inch with pepperoni. Hardly any pepperoni was on it, either. Two of us dined and we each ate most of one piece. I ate the cheese off a second slice but couldn't stomach the idea of eating any more of that rubbery crust. The other person with me had a couple bites of a second slice. We decided it was not worth wasting calories on any more of it. It was like the dough didn't rise and was just not good. We left half a pizza behind to throw out. No one asked how it was, I guess they already knew. I'm giving two stars because the ingredients seemed good for what they used.
Dawn Cooper
If you want some really good Pizza, go to Pizza on Main in Alachua, FL. For taste on a scale of 1-10, gotta go with a 10...best Pizza ever ?❤
Lezlee C.
Delicious pizza. Salad was fresh and generous. We had a sausage and onion thin crust. Nicely cheesy, fresh ingredients. Staff was very friendly. Great as stopping point on our trip from the Keys. We will definitely stop again the next time we are in town.
Jocelyn E.
wonderful experience, people were so kind and the food was AMAZING!! Also went to My Happy Place right next door for custard and bought some beautiful jewelry, so lovely!! thank you!
Evan R.
My family made an online order for pizza while on vacation and stopped through to eat on our way to Tampa. The people running the shop put our pizza in right on time to make sure it was piping hot. They do not skimp on topping as there was an entire overlapping layer of delicious pepperoni. Well worth the detour.
Bruce Jacob
The pizza is phenomenal. As are the desserts. Can’t recommend enough. Wether date night or with family-We always enjoy the experience. And anyone we take always asks us to go back.
Sebastian Solano
Incredible place with amazing food. Located in the beautiful mainstreet of Alachua Florida. The pizza was amazing and their tiramisu was delicious.
Liz I
Excellent pizza and stromboli. And the cheesy bread is sooo good that you can just it for your meal and still leave happy!! We haven't found a better place in all of Tanpa Bay... it's that good.
I love this place. When I'm feeling healthy I order the doughless pizza with a salad, and when I want to splurge, I order the Stromboli and a tiramisu. No matter what you order, it's a treat. While you're there, step next door and grab a gourmet coffee.
Mike
Stopped in for a 14" thin pizza. They do a great job. Very tasty. Nice Mom & Pop place.
J C.
Came in around 1230, not busy at all. Waited on quickly and my wife, and I, both ordered the Lunch Specials. She got a personal calzone, I the Stromboli, and it included a side garden, or Cesar salad. Salads came out quickly and the balsamic vinaigrette was great. Calzone and the Stromboli both came out 20 minutes after being seated. They were both fantastic. Great dough and lots of cheese. Will definitely be back. Loved it!!!!
YouSee AllDifferent
Put quite simply, My Pizza Place serves the BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD‼ I had a slice each of the Buffalo Chicken and the Jalapeño Popper pizzas. They were hot with fresh ingredients, the perfect amount of cheese. In fact, my husband asked if I requested extra cheese: I did not! Settled in a quiet, quaint part of town, it was just what I was craving...& you WILL crave it. The restaurant was clean; staff are attentive and friendly; food is moderately priced (and WORTH IT). There's even a nice little gift store connected to it that serves desserts: custard, milkshakes, "REAL, New York Italian Ice", and coffee, owned by same kind couple. I recommend, which was also recommended to me, the custard, served with Italian Ice, also the BEST ITALIAN ICE I've EVER had...TRULY, & I'm from St. Augustine, FL, not Alachua, FL, the location of this wonderful duo ?I HIGHLY recommend both, My Pizza Place & My Happy Place‼ Go ahead and try it yourself. I guarantee you will not be disappointed.
Deonte L.
We ordered the stuffed mama! It was amazing, service was great. No qualms whatsoever and the view is perfect for people watching lol. We'll definitely be back.
Great food, big portions
Absolutely the best pizza. Crust is perfect, toppings a plenty.
The staff were pleasant but the pizza was like chewing rubber. We ordered a 14 inch with pepperoni. Hardly any pepperoni was on it, either. Two of us dined and we each ate most of one piece. I ate the cheese off a second slice but couldn't stomach the idea of eating any more of that rubbery crust. The other person with me had a couple bites of a second slice. We decided it was not worth wasting calories on any more of it. It was like the dough didn't rise and was just not good. We left half a pizza behind to throw out. No one asked how it was, I guess they already knew. I'm giving two stars because the ingredients seemed good for what they used.
If you want some really good Pizza, go to Pizza on Main in Alachua, FL. For taste on a scale of 1-10, gotta go with a 10...best Pizza ever ?❤
Delicious pizza. Salad was fresh and generous. We had a sausage and onion thin crust. Nicely cheesy, fresh ingredients. Staff was very friendly. Great as stopping point on our trip from the Keys. We will definitely stop again the next time we are in town.
wonderful experience, people were so kind and the food was AMAZING!! Also went to My Happy Place right next door for custard and bought some beautiful jewelry, so lovely!! thank you!
My family made an online order for pizza while on vacation and stopped through to eat on our way to Tampa. The people running the shop put our pizza in right on time to make sure it was piping hot. They do not skimp on topping as there was an entire overlapping layer of delicious pepperoni. Well worth the detour.
The pizza is phenomenal. As are the desserts. Can’t recommend enough. Wether date night or with family-We always enjoy the experience. And anyone we take always asks us to go back.
Incredible place with amazing food. Located in the beautiful mainstreet of Alachua Florida. The pizza was amazing and their tiramisu was delicious.
Excellent pizza and stromboli. And the cheesy bread is sooo good that you can just it for your meal and still leave happy!! We haven't found a better place in all of Tanpa Bay... it's that good.
Restaurantji Recommends
I love this place. When I'm feeling healthy I order the doughless pizza with a salad, and when I want to splurge, I order the Stromboli and a tiramisu. No matter what you order, it's a treat. While you're there, step next door and grab a gourmet coffee.
Stopped in for a 14" thin pizza. They do a great job. Very tasty. Nice Mom & Pop place.
Came in around 1230, not busy at all. Waited on quickly and my wife, and I, both ordered the Lunch Specials. She got a personal calzone, I the Stromboli, and it included a side garden, or Cesar salad. Salads came out quickly and the balsamic vinaigrette was great. Calzone and the Stromboli both came out 20 minutes after being seated. They were both fantastic. Great dough and lots of cheese. Will definitely be back. Loved it!!!!
Put quite simply, My Pizza Place serves the BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD‼ I had a slice each of the Buffalo Chicken and the Jalapeño Popper pizzas. They were hot with fresh ingredients, the perfect amount of cheese. In fact, my husband asked if I requested extra cheese: I did not! Settled in a quiet, quaint part of town, it was just what I was craving...& you WILL crave it. The restaurant was clean; staff are attentive and friendly; food is moderately priced (and WORTH IT). There's even a nice little gift store connected to it that serves desserts: custard, milkshakes, "REAL, New York Italian Ice", and coffee, owned by same kind couple. I recommend, which was also recommended to me, the custard, served with Italian Ice, also the BEST ITALIAN ICE I've EVER had...TRULY, & I'm from St. Augustine, FL, not Alachua, FL, the location of this wonderful duo ?I HIGHLY recommend both, My Pizza Place & My Happy Place‼ Go ahead and try it yourself. I guarantee you will not be disappointed.
We ordered the stuffed mama! It was amazing, service was great. No qualms whatsoever and the view is perfect for people watching lol. We'll definitely be back.