New York Pizza Plus

$ • Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian

Hours:
15202 NW 147th Dr #100, Alachua
(386) 418-3857

About New York Pizza Plus

New York Pizza Plus provides a tasty and authentic dining experience. The seafood bisque on Fridays is a family favorite, and the Roma spinach pizza is a standout. The service is friendly, and the food is excellent, with options like the California salad and Chicken Oscar. Customers enjoy the casual atmosphere, plenty of food and drink choices, and the staff who remember regulars’ favorite orders. The restaurant is known for huge portions, fresh ingredients, and unique offerings like fresh hot garlic rolls and homemade olive oil. Many customers have praised the cleanliness, professional handling of food allergies, and the quality of their takeout. The crust is buttery, flaky, and crisp, with fresh cheese and veggies, making it a popular spot for those willing to travel from nearby areas. The staff consistently provides great service, making NY Pizza Plus a favorite for groups and special occasions.

Customers' Favorites

New York Pizza Plus Reviews

4.7
296 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
85%
4
5%
3
5%
2
1%
1
4%
Food
4.7
Atmosphere
4.6
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about New York Pizza Plus

Restaurantji Rating

I came all the way from Georgia to have New York Pizza it has always been DELICIOUS… I was SO disappointed …. the crust was like it was made from crackers … they need to go back to the original recipe …. This was worst than a frozen pizza in a super market … what a shame they use to be the best PIZZA place in town 🥲 … I won’t be back

The food here is good but the wait staff are lazy. Everytime we go in theres a bunch of teenage boys standing around chatting. Tonight it took so long to get our drink and food order my husband had to ask someone to come to our table, 2 of our drink cups were dirty, and my husband had to go back up AGAIN and ask our waiter for the condiment he said he'd get us. The resturant wasnt even busy with only one other table occupied. Im not saying not to buy food from here, but order...read full review

Love the lasagne too

Read All Reviews(296)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
New York Pizza Plus Menu
New York Pizza Plus Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
New York Pizza Plus
New York Pizza Plus
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 10AM - 8:30PM
Tuesday 10AM - 8:30PM
Wednesday 10AM - 8:30PM
Thursday 10AM - 8:30PM
Friday 10AM - 9:30PM
Saturday 10AM - 9:30PM
Sunday 10AM - 8:30PM
Updated on: