We love the peanut butter pie. Our favourite. Be good to offer one with oreo crust. Next best is the orange cake. It is awesome! The chocolate is also awesome and so is the strawberry. However the lemon is flavourless. Customer service could improve...the young girl serving us was always in a hurry, and one time refused to accommodate us with orange cake slices even though there were orange cakes in the fridge that could have been sliced up. It was 2 in the afternoon, so still a lot of time to sell more orange cake slices the rest of the day. A big however.....coffee is Kureg but u r charged barista pricing!!! Signifying this would b upfront as I find it deceiving and a rip off.
Kendall Sompolski
I can't thank Cindy and Hometown Desserts enough for the incredible cake and bite-sized desserts they created for our wedding. Choosing them was an easy decision because I grew up eating their infamous Coconut Key Lime Cake, and having one for our special day made it even more meaningful. Cindy's attention to detail and talent shone through in every bite of our delicious cake. It was not only delicious but also a beautiful centerpiece that added even more magic to our wedding. I highly recommend Cindy and her team for any special occasion. Thank you, Cindy, for making our day even more unforgettable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kendall S.
I can't thank Cindy and Hometown Desserts enough for the incredible cake and bite-sized desserts they created for our wedding. Choosing them was an easy decision because I grew up eating their infamous Coconut Key Lime Cake, and having one for our special day made it even more meaningful. Cindy's attention to detail and talent shone through in every bite of our delicious cake. It was not only delicious but also a beautiful centerpiece that added even more magic to our wedding. I highly recommend Cindy and her team for any special occasion. Thank you, Cindy, for making our day even more unforgettable!
Grace Skalicky
I love it here so much! The blackberry lemonade is so delicious, I’ve had it three days in a row. The key lime pie was also super good. Some of the best on the island and all the desserts are fresh. My friend loved the cake pops. The prices are also amazing and the owner was very friendly. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Sip
Cool shop only tried the ice tea.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sarah Spevack
Cindy made my wedding cake and it tasted amazing along with the little desserts. There was more than enough for everyone and it all tasted so good! We went with lemon and raspberry and it was a great mix of flavors ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Terry
As mentioned... the brownies are next level. Friendly staff. Ask about the coconut,chocolate,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mr 777
Great place, tasty items. Good price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rich S.
Worth the trip from across the country for the coconut key lime cake!! It is AMAZING We get it every time we are in the island
Brian Albers (Mr.Fabulous)
We placed an order in advance for cupcakes for my daughter's birthday. Showed up to get them to find out that she didn't make them. I'm unable to get them until the day after her birthday. I appreciate them still being made but birthday cupcakes ordered in advance should be ready for the birthday.
Cute little spot! Big chocolate chip cookies warmed up was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patricia B.
During our trip from Connecticut to Anna Maria Island, we had the delightful opportunity to visit Hometown Desserts and it was a highlight of our journey! The customer service we experienced was nothing short of exceptional. The staff was welcoming, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure we had a wonderful experience. The cupcakes and cappuccinos were a real treat - the cupcakes were moist, perfectly sweetened, and beautifully decorated, while the cappuccinos were expertly crafted, offering the perfect blend of rich coffee and smooth froth. Each bite and sip was a testament to the quality and care put into their products. The cozy and inviting atmosphere of the shop made our visit even more enjoyable. We are already looking forward to our next visit to Hometown Desserts when we travel back from Connecticut. It's a must-visit for anyone looking for exquisite desserts and outstanding service on Anna Maria Island!
Kris Lindebrekke
Try the Keylime Coconut cake!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Coconut Cake
Michael Via
Fabulous cakes!
Food: 5
Amanda Comstock
Beautiful job on our wedding cake/cupcakes! We loved being able to give our guests a special Florida experience with key lime and orange cakes. It was wonderful and Cindy is great to work with!
We love the peanut butter pie. Our favourite. Be good to offer one with oreo crust. Next best is the orange cake. It is awesome! The chocolate is also awesome and so is the strawberry. However the lemon is flavourless. Customer service could improve...the young girl serving us was always in a hurry, and one time refused to accommodate us with orange cake slices even though there were orange cakes in the fridge that could have been sliced up. It was 2 in the afternoon, so still a lot of time to sell more orange cake slices the rest of the day. A big however.....coffee is Kureg but u r charged barista pricing!!! Signifying this would b upfront as I find it deceiving and a rip off.
I can't thank Cindy and Hometown Desserts enough for the incredible cake and bite-sized desserts they created for our wedding. Choosing them was an easy decision because I grew up eating their infamous Coconut Key Lime Cake, and having one for our special day made it even more meaningful. Cindy's attention to detail and talent shone through in every bite of our delicious cake. It was not only delicious but also a beautiful centerpiece that added even more magic to our wedding. I highly recommend Cindy and her team for any special occasion. Thank you, Cindy, for making our day even more unforgettable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can't thank Cindy and Hometown Desserts enough for the incredible cake and bite-sized desserts they created for our wedding. Choosing them was an easy decision because I grew up eating their infamous Coconut Key Lime Cake, and having one for our special day made it even more meaningful. Cindy's attention to detail and talent shone through in every bite of our delicious cake. It was not only delicious but also a beautiful centerpiece that added even more magic to our wedding. I highly recommend Cindy and her team for any special occasion. Thank you, Cindy, for making our day even more unforgettable!
I love it here so much! The blackberry lemonade is so delicious, I’ve had it three days in a row. The key lime pie was also super good. Some of the best on the island and all the desserts are fresh. My friend loved the cake pops. The prices are also amazing and the owner was very friendly. Definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cool shop only tried the ice tea.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy made my wedding cake and it tasted amazing along with the little desserts. There was more than enough for everyone and it all tasted so good! We went with lemon and raspberry and it was a great mix of flavors ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As mentioned... the brownies are next level. Friendly staff. Ask about the coconut,chocolate,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place, tasty items. Good price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worth the trip from across the country for the coconut key lime cake!! It is AMAZING We get it every time we are in the island
We placed an order in advance for cupcakes for my daughter's birthday. Showed up to get them to find out that she didn't make them. I'm unable to get them until the day after her birthday. I appreciate them still being made but birthday cupcakes ordered in advance should be ready for the birthday.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Cute little spot! Big chocolate chip cookies warmed up was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
During our trip from Connecticut to Anna Maria Island, we had the delightful opportunity to visit Hometown Desserts and it was a highlight of our journey! The customer service we experienced was nothing short of exceptional. The staff was welcoming, attentive, and went above and beyond to ensure we had a wonderful experience. The cupcakes and cappuccinos were a real treat - the cupcakes were moist, perfectly sweetened, and beautifully decorated, while the cappuccinos were expertly crafted, offering the perfect blend of rich coffee and smooth froth. Each bite and sip was a testament to the quality and care put into their products. The cozy and inviting atmosphere of the shop made our visit even more enjoyable. We are already looking forward to our next visit to Hometown Desserts when we travel back from Connecticut. It's a must-visit for anyone looking for exquisite desserts and outstanding service on Anna Maria Island!
Try the Keylime Coconut cake!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Coconut Cake
Fabulous cakes!
Food: 5
Beautiful job on our wedding cake/cupcakes! We loved being able to give our guests a special Florida experience with key lime and orange cakes. It was wonderful and Cindy is great to work with!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5