This place was a gem! The best calzone we’ve ever had! The crust was off the charts🙌🏻🔥 Savanna was a great server and she took good care of us! We will take the drive and come back!!!
johnnies159
I can’t give them a good review. They are never open when they say they are. Happens once I let it pass two different times and I am pissed! You don’t need anyone’s business or money so you will never get mine again. Average food at best. Terrible business model
robynh270
This was our first time here and it will not be our last! We have been to a lot of great places but our experience here was as good as any. We were greeted at the door by the friendly staff and it continued until we were finished. The food quality and quantity are top notch. I can’t say enough good things!
James Plucknett
My wife and I came to your restaurant on Friday 4/4/2025 at 3:30pm when we entered the front door their were 3 staff members at the front counter who did not greet us when we entered so we asked if they were open and where to sit. Two staff members just looked at probably the manager who said they closed after lunch and would reopen at 4pm. This confused us because we had checked their website before driving here from South Gulf Cove (and paying the toll) and the website says open 11am-9pm. There is a big banner on the fence outside that also says open 11am-9pm and the hours posted on the door also say open 11am-9pm. The newspaper adv in the Boca Beacon also says open 11am-9pm. So we just left confused and disappointed. We love and make a real effort to support this and the other independent businesses on the island. We hope Sisters will make clear in their signage and advertising what their actual hours are so others are not disappointed.
Abigail Connolly
I can't say I've had the opportunity of eating here, as I was trying to get a table and got completely ignored by all the servers. It would've been one thing if they were busy, the inside of the restaurant had one person, and the outside was maybe at half capacity. Overall terrible experience. I have never been completely ignored when walking into a restaurant before. Will not return.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Edward Kowalski
Showed up for dinner did not look very busy sat down at a table as we watched waiter after waiter waitress after waitress passed us by for nearly 30 minutes we were very disappointed. We have had service like this in the past needless to say I like sisters food and atmosphere but we along with so many others are very supportive of family owned and small businesses. After this experience which was not our only experience that resulted this way I will say I wish them luck no hard feelings but I probably will not show up again. When a restaurant like sisters is owned by family they need to take consideration for those of us that really try to support them. I just could not believe we sat there with the staff continually just looking at us with no effort to wait on us.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cindy Yeakle Maguire
7 of us were there for dinner tonight. Pizza was wonderful, lasagna & salads were delicious. The BEST part was our waitress Tosha. She.Is.Hilarious. Seriously, a gem.
Richard May
Food good but service slow. Good thing we were not in a hurry. Waitress did recognize slow food and compted a glass of wine.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Peter McDowell
Solid restaurant with pizza and Italian options
Food: 4
Service: 4
987greggp
I visited Sisters Restaurant with my wife and daughter in early January. My daughter and I had the Grouper sandwich with fries. Mine was blackened, hers was grilled. Both were excellent. Healthy portion size and meal came with a small serving of cole slaw. My wife had the Ultimate sandwich (grilled grouper topped with cole slaw, thousand island dressing and swiss cheese.)Excellent as well. Sandwiches come with potato chips, fries are an additional $2.00. Service was prompt, attentive and polite, and the food came hot and in a reasonable amount of time. Soda and water comes in tall glasses, which is a great idea, and free refills for soda were a very nice touch. We sat outside on one of the many outdoor tables. The interior of the restaurant and bathrooms were clean and inviting. The only reason I did not give a five star rating was the restaurant's 3.99% upcharge for using a credit card. I strongly oppose this practice which seems to be spreading in restaurants and other small businesses across the U.S. Additionally, 3.99% is very high. My limited research on credit card processing fees for small businesses is that they range from 1.5% to 3.5%. In my opinion, anything higher than this is confiscatory and, sad to say, a money grab. I understand this can get costly for businesses who process many small dollar transactions. But restaurant bills are typically at least $50, and frequently exceed $100, even for smaller parties. (Our bill, with tax and tip came to $91.) Rather than "nickeling and diming" me to death, restaurants should either absorb this cost since an overwhelming majority of bills are paid with credit cards OR raise the menu price to cover their costs. Let me also state that I came prepared and willingly paid with cash, so my rant isn't because I was charged this fee. That said, the food, service and value at Sisters Restaurant were superb and I will visit again the next time I'm in Boca Grande. But I hope they drop the credit card fee.
Awesome, this place is the place. Go to here and enjoy yourself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Seafood Lasagna
Balance Headwear
What a fabulous place...can honestly say I have not enjoyed a meal that much for a long time! Jax are server was awesome...think we've found our new go to! See you very soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Crab Cakes
Lee Sillitoe
The seafood Lasagna was awsome!!! Great Marinara sauce:) Oh yeah, and the home made bread, what a delight !!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Roland
It's rare to find a place that leaves such a lasting impression it draws you back not just for the ambiance or the hospitality but for the culinary experience. At this delightful family-run establishment, our first encounter included the much-lauded Bread and Dipping Oil—believe the hype, it's sensational! The sheer delight compelled us to return the very next day, this time bringing our niece along to share in the experience. Although typically reserved for dinner, the staff graciously accommodated us with the bread and oil during lunch, instantly winning over another fan.
With separate menus for lunch and dinner, the variety is commendable. The lunch menu is impressively extensive, and everything we tried—from the savory pizza to the hearty sandwiches—was a hit. The dinner menu promises an equally enticing range with standout dishes like robust eggplant and perfectly layered lasagna. Indeed, the lasagna was so delightful that I cleaned my plate, prompting the server to comment that she would show the chef, a small but memorable gesture that speaks volumes about their pride in the food they serve.
Not only is the food exceptional, but the prices are also reasonable, which is a breath of fresh air. The warmth of the service matched the quality of the meals. Each staff member we interacted with was exceptionally friendly, including one of the sisters who run the restaurant. Her kindness added a personal touch that made our meals even more enjoyable.
Should I ever find myself in the area again, I will undoubtedly go out of my way to visit this remarkable restaurant. It’s the epitome of what a family-run venue should be: exceptional food served with genuine care. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick Madrigal
Jax was amazing, thanks for such a wonderful evening ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pepperoni and Sausage, Caesar Salad
This place was a gem! The best calzone we’ve ever had! The crust was off the charts🙌🏻🔥 Savanna was a great server and she took good care of us! We will take the drive and come back!!!
I can’t give them a good review. They are never open when they say they are. Happens once I let it pass two different times and I am pissed! You don’t need anyone’s business or money so you will never get mine again. Average food at best. Terrible business model
This was our first time here and it will not be our last! We have been to a lot of great places but our experience here was as good as any. We were greeted at the door by the friendly staff and it continued until we were finished. The food quality and quantity are top notch. I can’t say enough good things!
My wife and I came to your restaurant on Friday 4/4/2025 at 3:30pm when we entered the front door their were 3 staff members at the front counter who did not greet us when we entered so we asked if they were open and where to sit. Two staff members just looked at probably the manager who said they closed after lunch and would reopen at 4pm. This confused us because we had checked their website before driving here from South Gulf Cove (and paying the toll) and the website says open 11am-9pm. There is a big banner on the fence outside that also says open 11am-9pm and the hours posted on the door also say open 11am-9pm. The newspaper adv in the Boca Beacon also says open 11am-9pm. So we just left confused and disappointed.
We love and make a real effort to support this and the other independent businesses on the island. We hope Sisters will make clear in their signage and advertising what their actual hours are so others are not disappointed.
I can't say I've had the opportunity of eating here, as I was trying to get a table and got completely ignored by all the servers. It would've been one thing if they were busy, the inside of the restaurant had one person, and the outside was maybe at half capacity. Overall terrible experience. I have never been completely ignored when walking into a restaurant before. Will not return.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Showed up for dinner did not look very busy sat down at a table as we watched waiter after waiter waitress after waitress passed us by for nearly 30 minutes we were very disappointed. We have had service like this in the past needless to say I like sisters food and atmosphere but we along with so many others are very supportive of family owned and small businesses. After this experience which was not our only experience that resulted this way I will say I wish them luck no hard feelings but I probably will not show up again. When a restaurant like sisters is owned by family they need to take consideration for those of us that really try to support them. I just could not believe we sat there with the staff continually just looking at us with no effort to wait on us.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
7 of us were there for dinner tonight. Pizza was wonderful, lasagna & salads were delicious. The BEST part was our waitress Tosha. She.Is.Hilarious. Seriously, a gem.
Food good but service slow. Good thing we were not in a hurry. Waitress did recognize slow food and compted a glass of wine.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Solid restaurant with pizza and Italian options
Food: 4
Service: 4
I visited Sisters Restaurant with my wife and daughter in early January. My daughter and I had the Grouper sandwich with fries. Mine was blackened, hers was grilled. Both were excellent. Healthy portion size and meal came with a small serving of cole slaw. My wife had the Ultimate sandwich (grilled grouper topped with cole slaw, thousand island dressing and swiss cheese.)Excellent as well. Sandwiches come with potato chips, fries are an additional $2.00. Service was prompt, attentive and polite, and the food came hot and in a reasonable amount of time. Soda and water comes in tall glasses, which is a great idea, and free refills for soda were a very nice touch. We sat outside on one of the many outdoor tables. The interior of the restaurant and bathrooms were clean and inviting. The only reason I did not give a five star rating was the restaurant's 3.99% upcharge for using a credit card. I strongly oppose this practice which seems to be spreading in restaurants and other small businesses across the U.S. Additionally, 3.99% is very high. My limited research on credit card processing fees for small businesses is that they range from 1.5% to 3.5%. In my opinion, anything higher than this is confiscatory and, sad to say, a money grab. I understand this can get costly for businesses who process many small dollar transactions. But restaurant bills are typically at least $50, and frequently exceed $100, even for smaller parties. (Our bill, with tax and tip came to $91.) Rather than "nickeling and diming" me to death, restaurants should either absorb this cost since an overwhelming majority of bills are paid with credit cards OR raise the menu price to cover their costs. Let me also state that I came prepared and willingly paid with cash, so my rant isn't because I was charged this fee. That said, the food, service and value at Sisters Restaurant were superb and I will visit again the next time I'm in Boca Grande. But I hope they drop the credit card fee.
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome, this place is the place. Go to here and enjoy yourself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Seafood Lasagna
What a fabulous place...can honestly say I have not enjoyed a meal that much for a long time! Jax are server was awesome...think we've found our new go to!
See you very soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Crab Cakes
The seafood Lasagna was awsome!!! Great Marinara sauce:) Oh yeah, and the home made bread, what a delight !!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's rare to find a place that leaves such a lasting impression it draws you back not just for the ambiance or the hospitality but for the culinary experience. At this delightful family-run establishment, our first encounter included the much-lauded Bread and Dipping Oil—believe the hype, it's sensational! The sheer delight compelled us to return the very next day, this time bringing our niece along to share in the experience. Although typically reserved for dinner, the staff graciously accommodated us with the bread and oil during lunch, instantly winning over another fan.
With separate menus for lunch and dinner, the variety is commendable. The lunch menu is impressively extensive, and everything we tried—from the savory pizza to the hearty sandwiches—was a hit. The dinner menu promises an equally enticing range with standout dishes like robust eggplant and perfectly layered lasagna. Indeed, the lasagna was so delightful that I cleaned my plate, prompting the server to comment that she would show the chef, a small but memorable gesture that speaks volumes about their pride in the food they serve.
Not only is the food exceptional, but the prices are also reasonable, which is a breath of fresh air. The warmth of the service matched the quality of the meals. Each staff member we interacted with was exceptionally friendly, including one of the sisters who run the restaurant. Her kindness added a personal touch that made our meals even more enjoyable.
Should I ever find myself in the area again, I will undoubtedly go out of my way to visit this remarkable restaurant. It’s the epitome of what a family-run venue should be: exceptional food served with genuine care. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jax was amazing, thanks for such a wonderful evening ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pepperoni and Sausage, Caesar Salad
Loading...