Gatsby's Pizza

Delivery was on time. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and garlic bread. Was not a fan of the sauce or any of the food in general. Very expensive for the quality. Hate leaving negative reviews.. Friendly delivery guy.

Food: 2

Service: 5

Best potato skins. Parmesan sandwich amazing. Not greasy and overly salted.. just perfect

Tim and Robin are fantastic—friendly, welcoming, and clearly passionate about what they do. The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and you can taste the quality in every bite. The cannoli dessert was absolutely awesome. Excellent flavor, excellent service—highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Friendly service and excellent pizza. Crust was thin and crispy with fresh toppings. Cheese blend and sauce was a favorite.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great people and great food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Went in for cheese fries and was told by the counter person they did not know how to make that. Also half off on appetizers is advertised from a certain time (does not state any specific exclusions) after ordering a few times for take out , I was told by a younger guy that that special is for dine in only. When it doesn’t state that anywhere. Save your money

EDIT, fries are on your menu, under sides. Hand cut fries add cheese sauce. I was told when ordering that the kitchen staff did not know how to make them. As for the half off special. There’s nothing that says dine in only.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amazing pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Payed $40 for a 14 inch pizza. I'd compare it to a Tostino's frozen oven pizza but that would be doing it justice. They're also fishing for 5 star reviews and ask upon purchase for u to take out your phone and rate them 5 stars.

Great pizza, the best thin crust aroundhere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped in to try out Gatsby’s Pizza & everything from the time I walked in until i left. I had great experience with ordering and the pizza was delicious. Very friendly and outgoing, Great service

Robynn and Tim were fantastic, I’ll be back again and again! Great pizza and cannoli and service!

Fabulous & Savory pizza joint in Bonita Springs, Fl. Our party of 5 arrived a few minutes before closing at 9:00pm on Sunday, June 1st and Tim the owner was so kind to prepare two amazing pies! The complimentary cannolis were perfect to cap off our last night. Thank you, Tim. We will be back!

Great food and wonderful service! Will definitely be back!

Great pizza shop owned by Ohio couple. We stopped in on a Friday night with our golden retriever and sat on the patio - got the buckeye pizza and Italian sub. For the Ohio people… It’s like a donatos but better! :) soooo yummy, not greasy, and good portion sizes. Will def be back.

The buckeye special was amazing and the service and atmosphere were top notch while we waited for our pizzas!