I ate last November before COVID-19. One server, who doubled as bartender. Ran out of Burrata, so they substituted smoked mozzarella. Not that tasty and marinated tomatoes and prosciutto accompaniment were not easy to combine on the board the meal was served on. Worse yet was the veal tenderloin in a creamy mushroom sauce which contained some type of hot spice with a kick. Totally ruined the dish. The same spice was added to the sautéed broccolini. The meal was utterly forgettable.Maybe they had a bad night, but so did I.
Terri Singleton
Delicious, authentic food.
tilly brand
food was ok, but expensive. Service poor, it took a long time before we got our drinks. And the surprise was that the waiter charged our creditcard with an extra 290 usd. We asked several times to pay back the 290 usd, but no reaction. Finally Mastercard helped us to get our money back. Unreliable italian.
John Apsley
We came as a group of experience organic eaters 3 physicians and CEO. WONDERFUL! Every bite a true delight. Muscles were succulent and tender. Sea Bass, exquisite. Salmon - moist, perfectly flavored. Seasonings could not be more delicate and perfect.
Barb Neri
My husband and I were quite disappointed when our gift certificate would not cover tax and gratuity. There's nothing stated on the gift certificate to that effect.
Mary L.
Fantastic and authentic! Loved the pasta fagioli, gnocchi, ravioli, veal piccata and tiramisu!! We will be back.
Jason Andress
Food is excellent and service is great! If you're looking for authentic fresh Italian food this is the place to come.
Good Italian food, ok service, average ambiance, higher than average prices. In my humble opinion there are way too many really good restaurants in the Sarasota Manatee area for me to come back here.
Andra Alina Colón
The first time we went to this restaurant was absolutely amazing. They gave us little bruschetta’s and they answered our questions. Today we wanted to have Italian food for diner and we really wanted to go at Eat Organico again. But.. The food was good, maybe a little bit disappointing. Desserts? Hmm..Maybe not their best day. I asked for a dry red wine, I received not what I would call “dry”, maybe more a simple “vino da tavola” I wish them success in the business, but they need to bring the same quality and nice atmosphere in the restaurant.
First time & will be back! Very quaint and inviting restaurant. Great service. The pasta is so fresh and you can taste it! We learned it’s made daily. Every dish made to order with chef making each sauce for each dish. Highly recommend Eat Organico. We will be back soon
ReneeinSA
Absolutely fabulous pasta!!!! Dover sole was the best ever!!! Off the beaten track. Great service!! Worth it!!
Jill Andress
We enjoyed Christmas Eve dinner here. it's hands down the best, most authentic Italian food we've had in a long time. We will definitely be back again soon!! What a gem!
204jeannew
Excellent authentic Italian food & the service was great...whether it’s for 2 people or 22 people, which was the number of people we had in our party. Each dish was made to order & all ingredients are organic & fresh. Highly recommend eat Organico.
Natalia Remizova
The food is great. Had 2 pastas- gnocchi with bolognese sauce (not pictured) and pasta Papalina (pictured). Good quality, no frozen ingredients and the amount of salt is just right. Finished off with almond ricotta cake with chocolate chips, amaretto and a hint of espresso. The server was super attentive and friendly. Can't really find anything to complaint about... imagine that.
I ate last November before COVID-19. One server, who doubled as bartender. Ran out of Burrata, so they substituted smoked mozzarella. Not that tasty and marinated tomatoes and prosciutto accompaniment were not easy to combine on the board the meal was served on. Worse yet was the veal tenderloin in a creamy mushroom sauce which contained some type of hot spice with a kick. Totally ruined the dish. The same spice was added to the sautéed broccolini. The meal was utterly forgettable.Maybe they had a bad night, but so did I.
Delicious, authentic food.
food was ok, but expensive. Service poor, it took a long time before we got our drinks. And the surprise was that the waiter charged our creditcard with an extra 290 usd. We asked several times to pay back the 290 usd, but no reaction. Finally Mastercard helped us to get our money back. Unreliable italian.
We came as a group of experience organic eaters 3 physicians and CEO. WONDERFUL! Every bite a true delight. Muscles were succulent and tender. Sea Bass, exquisite. Salmon - moist, perfectly flavored. Seasonings could not be more delicate and perfect.
My husband and I were quite disappointed when our gift certificate would not cover tax and gratuity. There's nothing stated on the gift certificate to that effect.
Fantastic and authentic! Loved the pasta fagioli, gnocchi, ravioli, veal piccata and tiramisu!! We will be back.
Food is excellent and service is great! If you're looking for authentic fresh Italian food this is the place to come.
Excellent , fresh food , cozy atmosphere. Highly recommend
Good Italian food, ok service, average ambiance, higher than average prices. In my humble opinion there are way too many really good restaurants in the Sarasota Manatee area for me to come back here.
The first time we went to this restaurant was absolutely amazing. They gave us little bruschetta’s and they answered our questions. Today we wanted to have Italian food for diner and we really wanted to go at Eat Organico again. But.. The food was good, maybe a little bit disappointing. Desserts? Hmm..Maybe not their best day. I asked for a dry red wine, I received not what I would call “dry”, maybe more a simple “vino da tavola” I wish them success in the business, but they need to bring the same quality and nice atmosphere in the restaurant.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time & will be back! Very quaint and inviting restaurant. Great service. The pasta is so fresh and you can taste it! We learned it’s made daily. Every dish made to order with chef making each sauce for each dish. Highly recommend Eat Organico. We will be back soon
Absolutely fabulous pasta!!!! Dover sole was the best ever!!! Off the beaten track. Great service!! Worth it!!
We enjoyed Christmas Eve dinner here. it's hands down the best, most authentic Italian food we've had in a long time. We will definitely be back again soon!! What a gem!
Excellent authentic Italian food & the service was great...whether it’s for 2 people or 22 people, which was the number of people we had in our party. Each dish was made to order & all ingredients are organic & fresh. Highly recommend eat Organico.
The food is great. Had 2 pastas- gnocchi with bolognese sauce (not pictured) and pasta Papalina (pictured). Good quality, no frozen ingredients and the amount of salt is just right. Finished off with almond ricotta cake with chocolate chips, amaretto and a hint of espresso. The server was super attentive and friendly. Can't really find anything to complaint about... imagine that.