Very good pizza! I was very impressed. The crust is crispy and does not flop! I will be coming back multiple times nowI got a boardwalk slice and a pepperoni and sausage. Both were excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holly S.
Really great people! Also, their pizza is fantastic! My husband and I are From New Jersey and we moved here a couple years ago and we haven’t found anything that competes with this!! So yummy!! Our go to spot. You will not be disappointed if you try it!??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawn Snow
Being a native South Jersey couple, we are very picky about our pizzeria type food. I worked at many pizzerias in Jersey and Philly area for a good 20 years.We ordered their regular stromboli and a cheesesteak because we were to eager to just try one thing at a time. Both came out at the same time and the cheesesteak was just as hot as the Stromboli so I know it didn't sit around waiting for the stromboli to finish. The pizza sauce for the Stromboli was excellent, just enough sweetness that I could taste it, the exact way we like our sauce. It was loaded with cheese and toppings, they did not skimp at all. My husband and I both looked at each other and thought they've got to be losing money on this because it was only 13 bucks And it had to have more cheese in it than a large pie. The roll for the cheesesteak was excellent. That is the biggest issue for us in Florida is that nobody can make a good cheesesteak roll. You could taste that the cheese steakmeat wasn't a watered down frozen puck, it was definitely real shaved beef. Now that we live 5 minutes away from this awesome place I will be trying something different every week! Definitely a little slice of Jersey in Bradenton as their motto suggests. ❤️
The food used to be outstanding ! I recommended it to everyone. But new management took over and it’s not even close now. Hope they get it together . Def not a busy as beforeParking: Very busy shopping center . Hard to find a close spot
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich, Cheese Pizza by the Slice, Meatball Appitizer, Greek Salad
Ika
Friendly staff. The pizza is just not my taste. Maybe not warm enough with the website stating much longer time than the pizza being ready. You do get email notification, but plan for less time.
Ethan
Best NY style pizza in the area. I've tried all the others. It's not even up for debate that this is the best tasting!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza by the Slice, Wings, Greek Salad
MR J
Pizza was 2 hours old and and lady refused to make a new pepperoni pizza fresh to put in shelf. They do have good pizza but customer service was horrendous!! Come on people that’s your job job job!!!! Get with the program
Vince J.
The pizza here is really good and Florida needs more pizza shops like thisMy one major gripe, and I mean major it's what gave me reason to only give it three stars was when I order chicken Parm it came to me sliced. It looked as though the cook tried to give me chicken Parm using chicken that was set aside for the pizza topping instead of making me a fresh cutlet. When I raise this to the young lady at the front and I showed her, she said the chicken sometimes falls in pieces. I even took photos of it for you all to see yourselves. When I said no that can't be. She said well the chef wouldn't lie well the chef did lie and that's why I'm only giving two stars.The pizzas great the chicken Parm, not great coupled with a chef that fibs and was lazy not making me a fresh cutlet. That makes me wonder. What else is he lazy with? Try but only eat the pizza. You are welcome.
Ronnie C.
The food was great and one of the best pizza locations in Bradenton area. Crust was thin and crispy with excellent ingredients to make it even better
Marianne Maxin
Pizza was excellent! The baked ziti, on the other hand, was not…hardly any sauce, mostly cheese and pasta…threw it away. Tried to message the restaurant, no
I'm from NJ and am extremely picky when it comes to pie. Some places in the Bradenton area are decent but they'll have off-days and you'll be disappointed. Jersey Brothers has not had an off-day yet and is now the only pizza place in the area I will give my money to. If you're from NJ and are picky about pizza like myself, go to Jersey Brothers!!
Kerry Drake
Perfect pizza. Thin crust was not overcooked. Toppings just right.Returning soon for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Galterio
Ordered the Lasagna Pizza online yesterday and it was one of the best pizzas that I have had in a very long time. Normally stick to the pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, meatball usuals (which have always been very good). Saw the Lasagna Pizza on the online menu and had to try. They knocked it out of the park. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and meatballs, plus ricotta. It was like being back in NYC again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carl Gustav
Best pizza I've had in Florida. By far. I'm from Queens. Ate pizza all over NYC/ NJ, and lived here in FL for 17 years. West Palm, now Bradenton. This is real sauce. Real mozzarella. No straight out of the can marinara, and Dollar General cheese. Great crust. I HIGHLY recommend Jersey Brothers. These guys are good. Real good. Just got done stuffing my face, and I look like the blueberry girl from Willy Wonka. Eat here. You will not be disapointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Malisa P.
The pizza sauce and crispy crust! They have a great lunch special that I get while working and its two slices and a drink. The slices are a good size. They have so many options to choose from! Its a small place but you can dine it. Its a very casual place. Everything has been great from there and I would recommend the margherita pizza, chicken parm pizza bbq or buffalo pizza! All were delicious!
Very good pizza! I was very impressed. The crust is crispy and does not flop! I will be coming back multiple times nowI got a boardwalk slice and a pepperoni and sausage. Both were excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really great people! Also, their pizza is fantastic! My husband and I are From New Jersey and we moved here a couple years ago and we haven’t found anything that competes with this!! So yummy!! Our go to spot. You will not be disappointed if you try it!??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Being a native South Jersey couple, we are very picky about our pizzeria type food. I worked at many pizzerias in Jersey and Philly area for a good 20 years.We ordered their regular stromboli and a cheesesteak because we were to eager to just try one thing at a time. Both came out at the same time and the cheesesteak was just as hot as the Stromboli so I know it didn't sit around waiting for the stromboli to finish. The pizza sauce for the Stromboli was excellent, just enough sweetness that I could taste it, the exact way we like our sauce. It was loaded with cheese and toppings, they did not skimp at all. My husband and I both looked at each other and thought they've got to be losing money on this because it was only 13 bucks And it had to have more cheese in it than a large pie. The roll for the cheesesteak was excellent. That is the biggest issue for us in Florida is that nobody can make a good cheesesteak roll. You could taste that the cheese steakmeat wasn't a watered down frozen puck, it was definitely real shaved beef. Now that we live 5 minutes away from this awesome place I will be trying something different every week! Definitely a little slice of Jersey in Bradenton as their motto suggests. ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich, Regular Stromboli
The food used to be outstanding ! I recommended it to everyone. But new management took over and it’s not even close now. Hope they get it together . Def not a busy as beforeParking: Very busy shopping center . Hard to find a close spot
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich, Cheese Pizza by the Slice, Meatball Appitizer, Greek Salad
Friendly staff. The pizza is just not my taste. Maybe not warm enough with the website stating much longer time than the pizza being ready. You do get email notification, but plan for less time.
Best NY style pizza in the area. I've tried all the others. It's not even up for debate that this is the best tasting!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza by the Slice, Wings, Greek Salad
Pizza was 2 hours old and and lady refused to make a new pepperoni pizza fresh to put in shelf. They do have good pizza but customer service was horrendous!! Come on people that’s your job job job!!!! Get with the program
The pizza here is really good and Florida needs more pizza shops like thisMy one major gripe, and I mean major it's what gave me reason to only give it three stars was when I order chicken Parm it came to me sliced. It looked as though the cook tried to give me chicken Parm using chicken that was set aside for the pizza topping instead of making me a fresh cutlet. When I raise this to the young lady at the front and I showed her, she said the chicken sometimes falls in pieces. I even took photos of it for you all to see yourselves. When I said no that can't be. She said well the chef wouldn't lie well the chef did lie and that's why I'm only giving two stars.The pizzas great the chicken Parm, not great coupled with a chef that fibs and was lazy not making me a fresh cutlet. That makes me wonder. What else is he lazy with? Try but only eat the pizza. You are welcome.
The food was great and one of the best pizza locations in Bradenton area. Crust was thin and crispy with excellent ingredients to make it even better
Pizza was excellent! The baked ziti, on the other hand, was not…hardly any sauce, mostly cheese and pasta…threw it away. Tried to message the restaurant, no
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Brooklyn Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm from NJ and am extremely picky when it comes to pie. Some places in the Bradenton area are decent but they'll have off-days and you'll be disappointed. Jersey Brothers has not had an off-day yet and is now the only pizza place in the area I will give my money to. If you're from NJ and are picky about pizza like myself, go to Jersey Brothers!!
Perfect pizza. Thin crust was not overcooked. Toppings just right.Returning soon for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered the Lasagna Pizza online yesterday and it was one of the best pizzas that I have had in a very long time. Normally stick to the pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, meatball usuals (which have always been very good). Saw the Lasagna Pizza on the online menu and had to try. They knocked it out of the park. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and meatballs, plus ricotta. It was like being back in NYC again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza I've had in Florida. By far. I'm from Queens. Ate pizza all over NYC/ NJ, and lived here in FL for 17 years. West Palm, now Bradenton. This is real sauce. Real mozzarella. No straight out of the can marinara, and Dollar General cheese. Great crust. I HIGHLY recommend Jersey Brothers. These guys are good. Real good. Just got done stuffing my face, and I look like the blueberry girl from Willy Wonka. Eat here. You will not be disapointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza sauce and crispy crust! They have a great lunch special that I get while working and its two slices and a drink. The slices are a good size. They have so many options to choose from! Its a small place but you can dine it. Its a very casual place. Everything has been great from there and I would recommend the margherita pizza, chicken parm pizza bbq or buffalo pizza! All were delicious!