Absolutely loved the Canonball & Veggie Delight! The flavors were bold, fresh, and incredibly satisfying. The Canonball had the perfect balance of spice and richness, while the Veggie Delight was vibrant, hearty, and packed with colorful, crisp vegetables. Both dishes were beautifully presented and clearly made with quality ingredients. Whether you’re a meat lover or vegetarian, these options deliver big on taste and texture. Portion sizes were generous, and everything was served hot and timely. This has quickly become my go-to for a flavorful, wholesome meal. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a delicious and nourishing dining experience!
Alex Hardy
A lot of negative posts here. My pizza’s were excellent and the service great. If you have a problem with the service handle it directly before taking to social media and being a keyboard warrior. Do your research it’s not a dine in place but it’s a great joint!
Mike Biederman
Great friendly service and great pizza!
Anna K
The pizza was good and I wish my experience had gone better. I felt uncomfortable by the man working. I hope he was having an off day but it seems after reading the reviews I am not the only one he has decided to be unwelcoming to. He ignored me and then told me to wait outside until they were ready to take my order, but as I waited outside he took multiple orders from others who had shown up after me. When I went back inside he did not acknowledge me yet did acknowledge two other customers. Finally they took my order and he was dismissive and interruptive. Every customer they served ahead of me and instead of me was a man and I as a young woman do hope that this had nothing to do with my appearance as I was polite and patient towards the man in charge. It’s not abnormal to be dismissed as a woman but from a small business on this lovely island I come to every year is very very sad.
S Powell
Cheese pizza- would recommend. Great service over the phone and in person. Order placed on the phone and I was told 30min. Pizza was hot and ready when I walked in. Take out order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Cheese Pizza
Christopher Lemire
Their site says they deliver, but they said no and hung up. Then they called me back and hung up again. Not a place I would want to deal with.
Service: 1
Jeremy E
The guy working there is very unusual. I’m not sure if it’s a mental issue but he has no courtesy or customer service. Fix your phones so someone can actually call on a head of time. Pizza wasn’t bad but will never go back due to who I presume to be the owner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Rob Davis
Have had great experiences this year. Ordered by phone for pick up each visit. When busy, will take a few tries to get thru. Pizza is delicious. Really enjoyed the Canon ball.
Have had great experiences this year. Ordered by phone for pick up each visit. When busy, will take a few tries to get thru. Pizza is delicious. Really enjoyed the Canon ball.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven S
Have you ever wanted to experience disappointment in the shape of a circle? Look no further than Captiva Pizza! Its crust is so cardboard-like, you could build a house with it during a pizza apocalypse. The toppings are mysteriously scarce, making each bite a treasure hunt for flavor. If you enjoy feeling like you've eaten a culinary mirage, this pizza will leave you questioning your life choices and craving a real meal. 1 out of 5 stars – only because it technically qualifies as food. Do yourself a favor…before heading over the causeway, stop at Chuck e Cheese in Ft Myers for a better option.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Taylor Cable
Fantastic pizza! This was hands down the best pizza on all of captiva and sanibel, and we tried a lot of others during our stay! It was easy to order, and he was very kind and helpful even though we were thirty minutes late picking up our pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Antle
Great pizza, good prices, fast seevice and great staff!!! I recommend the pepperoni pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Hugh Jass
Delicious pizza, good prices and great service!!! We accidentally called at closing time but they were friendly and took care of us quickly. Great way to top off a long day at the beach.
Really good pizza on a really great island
Pizza was very good Owner was super nice!
Absolutely loved the Canonball & Veggie Delight! The flavors were bold, fresh, and incredibly satisfying. The Canonball had the perfect balance of spice and richness, while the Veggie Delight was vibrant, hearty, and packed with colorful, crisp vegetables. Both dishes were beautifully presented and clearly made with quality ingredients. Whether you’re a meat lover or vegetarian, these options deliver big on taste and texture. Portion sizes were generous, and everything was served hot and timely. This has quickly become my go-to for a flavorful, wholesome meal. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a delicious and nourishing dining experience!
A lot of negative posts here. My pizza’s were excellent and the service great. If you have a problem with the service handle it directly before taking to social media and being a keyboard warrior. Do your research it’s not a dine in place but it’s a great joint!
Great friendly service and great pizza!
The pizza was good and I wish my experience had gone better. I felt uncomfortable by the man working. I hope he was having an off day but it seems after reading the reviews I am not the only one he has decided to be unwelcoming to. He ignored me and then told me to wait outside until they were ready to take my order, but as I waited outside he took multiple orders from others who had shown up after me. When I went back inside he did not acknowledge me yet did acknowledge two other customers. Finally they took my order and he was dismissive and interruptive. Every customer they served ahead of me and instead of me was a man and I as a young woman do hope that this had nothing to do with my appearance as I was polite and patient towards the man in charge. It’s not abnormal to be dismissed as a woman but from a small business on this lovely island I come to every year is very very sad.
Cheese pizza- would recommend. Great service over the phone and in person. Order placed on the phone and I was told 30min. Pizza was hot and ready when I walked in. Take out order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Cheese Pizza
Their site says they deliver, but they said no and hung up. Then they called me back and hung up again. Not a place I would want to deal with.
Service: 1
The guy working there is very unusual. I’m not sure if it’s a mental issue but he has no courtesy or customer service. Fix your phones so someone can actually call on a head of time. Pizza wasn’t bad but will never go back due to who I presume to be the owner.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Have had great experiences this year. Ordered by phone for pick up each visit. When busy, will take a few tries to get thru. Pizza is delicious. Really enjoyed the Canon ball.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Have had great experiences this year. Ordered by phone for pick up each visit. When busy, will take a few tries to get thru. Pizza is delicious. Really enjoyed the Canon ball.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have you ever wanted to experience disappointment in the shape of a circle? Look no further than Captiva Pizza! Its crust is so cardboard-like, you could build a house with it during a pizza apocalypse. The toppings are mysteriously scarce, making each bite a treasure hunt for flavor. If you enjoy feeling like you've eaten a culinary mirage, this pizza will leave you questioning your life choices and craving a real meal. 1 out of 5 stars – only because it technically qualifies as food. Do yourself a favor…before heading over the causeway, stop at Chuck e Cheese in Ft Myers for a better option.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Fantastic pizza! This was hands down the best pizza on all of captiva and sanibel, and we tried a lot of others during our stay! It was easy to order, and he was very kind and helpful even though we were thirty minutes late picking up our pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, good prices, fast seevice and great staff!!! I recommend the pepperoni pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Delicious pizza, good prices and great service!!! We accidentally called at closing time but they were friendly and took care of us quickly. Great way to top off a long day at the beach.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...