Keylime Bistro
11509 Andy Rosse Lane, Captiva
(239) 395-4000
Customers' Favorites
Key Lime Pie
KeyLime Pie
Menu
Photos
+74 photos
+73 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Don't believe 'Tripadvisor Messages' that claim that 'this place is closed'!\nIt is one of the better dining places on Sanibel/Captiva and it was OPEN when we dined there on 31OCT25. \nWe had Large Salad with grilled Mahi, which was excellent quality, and Paella which was incredibly lush for a poor man's dish originating in Valencia (Spain).\nThe Wine list is extensive and bottles can be found starting around 40 USD, which is reasonable pricing.\nThe...
Excellent food and service. We arrived for dinner shortly after they opened at 5:00 and got our choice of tables. Our server, Jennifer, was friendly and professional. My husband ordered one of their specials, I believe it was called Fungi Risotto, and it was a great mixture of shrimp, scallops and mushrooms in a creamy risotto. I had the 8 oz filet mignon. It was perfectly cooked medium rare topped with a portobello mushroom and asparagus, artfully displayed. We shared creme brulee...
We ate twice here June 21 and 22,2025 and both times were great. Service excellent and everyone was friendly but very busy and possibly need more servers which did Not affect the experience just a note. Food and drinks great, we can’t wait to go back. The grouper fresh and yummy, my first time having this fish and I loved the grouper piccata. Get the Bloody Mary with the 2 jumbo shrimp, what a treat! The key lime pie is more like a cheesecake I think, but good as was the key...
You May Also Like
Captiva Island Pizza - 11513 Andy Rosse Lane
![]()
Pizza, Vegan
Sunshine Seafood - Café and Wine Bar - 11508 Andy Rosse Lane
![]()
Seafood, Wine Bar, Cafe, Pet Friendly
RC Otter's Island Eats - 11506 Andy Rosse Lane
![]()
Seafood, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian