Custom Cakes near Casselberry, FL

“Unbelievably awesome service and the cake was jaw dropping beautiful. The owner went above and beyond to make my daughters birthday super special. 🎂 XOXO Thank you again!“

“We cannot recommend Michael Anthony Cakes enough! We hired him to make our wedding cake January '24 and were not disappointed! He happily worked with my vision and my husband's flavor requests for our cake. We were brought in for a tasting for various aspects of the cake and loved it so much we ordered a smaller version for the holidays the year before! Everyone is STILL talking about the wedding cake! The care Michael takes when customizing shows in every aspect of the cake. From the design, frosting, filling and the cake. The taste is perfect, not too sweet or overwhelming; every flavor complimented each other and nothing overpowered anything. It was a perfectly balanced cake. We have been requested by family to bring this cake each holiday season, and we will be ordering an anniversary cake annually!“

“I was on the hunt to find amazing cake for my wedding. I emailed about 25 different vendors in Orlando and I ended up choosing I&M Bakers! I loved the quick communication, the thorough emails (which showed me they cared), I LOVE the way they set up the tasting box, lastly, I love their professionalism. My cake decor was OUT OF THIS WORLD! I could not choose between 2 different cake designs and Ianna mentioned that they can merge both designs! I was SO happy! I trusted her instantly! Then, she sent us the sample and we were so in love. On the wedding day, it was even more beautiful. Not to mention the taste, unfortunately my husband and I did not get to taste it but ALL the guests i spoke to LOVEDDD it and ate every piece. We wer sad we didnt get to take any home, so we will be ordering more cake from them lol. I am very pleased with having them as one of my vendors, i'll always choose i&m bakers & you should too.“

“Highly recommend! Belen was so quick with her response when I emailed her letting her know this would be my first birthday in Orlando away from my family in NY! She accommodated my request for a cannoli cake and definitely exceeded my expectations!!! Thank you so much for making my birthday whole ❤️“

“They created a beautiful baptism cake for my granddaughter that tasted as great as it looked. Got so many compliments. Thank you!“

“Stopped in today for a Cruffin filled with pastry cream. Delicious! The owner was lovely. I will definitely be back!“

“This is a belated review, but back in late November of 2022 I had a somewhat last minute request for a custom cake for my husband and his twin sister Sylvia’s 60th Birthday that was on December 4th. It was to be a surprise for them and I wanted it to be extra special. I reached out to Dan and expressed to him my ideas and he accommodated them perfectly and beautifully. The cake was covered with photos of them together through the years. I will never forget how truly special the cake was and what it meant to my husband Ed and his sister Sylvia. What I didn’t express at the time was that my sister-in-law had been recently diagnosed with metastatic cancer and I realized how extra special this Birthday would be. Sadly, we lost her shortly after her 61st Birthday on December 16, 2023. I just want to thank you whole heartedly for being kind and considerate, providing incredible customer service, and of course, for making a very special cake for a very special occasion. I will attempt to attach photos. Sincerely, Celeste“

“When my friend told me she had never had a cake made just for her, I knew I had to change that—and Lina made it happen in the most beautiful way. She was a joy to work with from start to finish—responsive, creative, and so kind. She took my ideas and brought them to life in a stunning design. The cake wasn’t just gorgeous—it was absolutely delicious and quickly became the talk of the night. Thank you, Lina, for helping me make my friend feel so celebrated!“

“10/10 everything is delicious. I even got my birthday cake from here!“

“delicioso los dulce y las chicas la atención excelente“

“Always fresh and very tasty. Great atmosphere and staff as well.“

“Bakers Like Birthday Cake Too! I had the stressful task of getting a birthday cake for my good friend, who is also a baker—because, let’s face it, bakers deserve a special cake too, and she shouldn't have to bake her own birthday cake again this year! Luckily, Ms. Victoria from Simply Homemade 1913 in downtown Sanford came through and delivered an absolutely gorgeous cake with a quick turnaround. We went with a lemon cake, and it was not only stunning but also delicious. The flavors were perfect, and the cake was both light and filling. The design was simple yet elegant, with personal touches that made it feel extra special. You can really tell it was made with love. I’m so glad I chose Simply Homemade 1913 to make this memorable cake—my friend loved it, and I’ll definitely be returning for future celebrations!“

“I love the variety of products and the best ingredients. The attention is unique and they give a lot of support to small businesses! Marissa and her staff are tremendous people. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We ordered our wedding cake to her and she did an amazing job! I asked her to add the fillings that we traditionally used to use for our wedding cakes, and she did exactly what we asked for. I recommended her to everyone wanna have a great cake for their party :)“

“Saw this place courtesy of TikTok and finally got to try it today. My boyfriend got rainbow cookie pastries and two sweet buns that he loved. I had the Grapefruit Lemon Juice and an order of wonton dumplings in soup. That juice was FRESH and tasted so good, especially on a day like today. The wonton dumplings in soup were perfect and really quite filled with pork and shrimp. The broth and greens were a great finish too. All in all, definitely heading back.“

“Fast service, pleasant staff and great ice cream“

“Do yourself a favor and go get yourself a CHURRO CUPCAKE. Don’t wait, go now! Those things are sooooo good! I didn’t remember to take a photo but my mom and I wish we had gotten all 8 of that flavor instead of a variety 😋“

“I had to place a specialty cake last minute. The owner was very personable and friendly and made it happen for a friend’s 44th birthday. The cake was beautiful, taste great and made it from Fl to Tennessee cabins for our trip. I would definitely recommend.“

“Excelente servicio, buenos precios y buen sabor en los dulces. Tienen que mejorar los sándwich o cambiar la persona que los prepara.“

“I highly recommend 3 Leches Sweets! They made us a beautiful cake that tasted so good and their customer service is the best.“

“Our cake and cupcakes were absolutely delicious. They made it exactly how we wanted and all four of the cupcake flavors were so good. Thank you for making our day special.“

“Title: A Delightful Ice Cream Paradise!I recently had the pleasure of ordering an ice cream birthday cake from Cold Stone in Winter Park, and it was an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish and I left with a huge smile on my face.From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. Emily and Brianna were incredibly friendly, attentive, and eager to help.In conclusion, Cold Stone Creamery in Winter Park is a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast or anyone looking to treat themselves to a delightful experience. The combination of exceptional flavors, top-notch service, and a welcoming ambiance makes this place a true gem. I left with a happy heart.“