15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Fellsmere

“We stopped in last week...amazing! The pizza and salad were on point...and OMG the fresh hot bread!! It was a perfect dinner choice during a long week.“

“All the food is excellent!! Had the margarita pizza last night and it was by far the best i have had in a long time!!!“

“Love this place! Great pizza and always super nice to my son when we come in. Super friendly! Highly recommended“

“Hands down the best pizza I’ve had since moving to Florida. It tastes just like the pizza I used to get back home in Massachusetts. If you’re looking for real, authentic flavor, I highly recommend this place!“

“Normally I’d highly recommend Davila’s Pizza East. I’ve never gotten poor quality food from there before. Evening of Nov 12, 2025 I ordered delivery thru Instacart from Davilas East, and ordered a pasta dish called Shrimp Scampi. I wish I could post the pic / description / price from their online menu vs what I received. It was so disappointing! I tried to request a partial refund or credit thru Instacart and basically got back a message saying they understood how frustrating that must have been and hope it doesn’t happen again in the future. (Thannnnnnnnnnnks lol)“

“The server was very nice. The pizza is amazing. I’ve tried everything on the menu, and everything was Amazing.“

“The wings are delicious.also,the onion rings and chicken wings.Great services 😋🥰🥰“

“I like to order the pepperoni pizza when at this mall in Vero Beach. It has a thin crust, nice and crispy - baked perfectly. You will receive your pizza order wonderfully warmed up. Delicious! The gentleman behind the counter who served me was very respectful and gave quick service. Thank you!“

“The pizzas are amazing, I drive 45 minutes each way just for the pizza and cannolis. I have tried nearly everything they offer and it is all delicious. The coffee cake has the perfect cake to crumb ratio, cannolis are piped fresh when you order them. All the cookies, cakes, rolls and bread are fresh and delicious. 10/10 for me.“

“Big Roman's Pizza in grant.pretty good for Florida pizza. But my pallet is spoiled by growing up in New Jersey where the pizza is first rate. But big Roman's does pretty well . I will go back for sure. The crust is a little too thin. But still good.. we always get cheese and mushrooms. Never anything else.“

“Listen I ordered pick up, and arrived ten minutes after. This was the best freshest hottest pizza I think I've ever had in my life aside from back in the day when pizza hut had their buffets in the 90s! Customer service was amazing and lady at the register was as sweet as pie.“

“We were looking for a place close to where we were staying, this was only 4 miles away. Very quaint, clean, our waiter was awesome (thanks Andrew/Drew)!!! The food was yummy... had lasagna and manicotti. Nice and hot, the sauce was really good, and the bread they serve was nice and warm with soft butter (my mother-in-law would've loved that, huge pet peeve for her!). So glad we just happened to find this place. I think it must be a hidden gem. We will definitely be back.“

“In this negative world in which we live in, we are always quick to complain but never compliment. We have ordered from a lot of local pizza places only to get the wrong orders and a negative attitude. We finally made a switch to Little Caesar’s and at first I was a little skeptical. But I can honestly say after ordering pizza from them for at least 6 months, we have never had an issue until tonight. But this isn’t a complaint so much as a compliment. We ordered our usual, and as we were there to pick it up, one of their employees noticed our order was wrong. Instantly the manager offered us a variety of options to compensate. Neither of them we chose, due to the fact it was a minor issue. The pizza was lacking one topping out of five. That as it. But it was the attention to detail by the staff and the management wanting to make it right was when we felt we needed to do the right thing and give them a great review. As a business owner, I can deeply appreciate what the manager did for us. All other area businesses need to learn from this. Not only are the orders always correct, but the taste and quality of the pizza is very good and consistent week from week unlike the other pizza places. If I could give them a higher rating, I would. Great job Little Caesar’s. Thank you.“

“Let me be real, this review could very easily have been 1 star if it wasn't for my call with the manager Chloe today. I ordered the big box online last night as a square cut pizza. When it showed up it was thinner than the cardboard it was delivered in, and harder than if it had been sitting out for a month.

While I could continue, and write a review that may shock the world, I will say that even though the staff was not answering their phone last night, I spoke to Chloe today, and she is by far the best kind of manager a store could have. Kind, de-escalating, sweet, informative, and went above and beyond to make it where I not only was happy to give Pizza Hut a second chance, I will actually order from them again moving forward.

Thank you Chloe for showing me humanity and kindness, and compassion. I know it's just Pizza, but your character and leadership is what changed this from a negative experience, into one that made me smile today.“

“Best pizza I’ve ever had! We were visiting from out of town and went 2x. Can’t wait to come back!!!“