Fantastic and open past 9 pm on busy holidays. Great staff and they were quick and efficient
Amazing ice cream hot chocolate and coffee
Lauren Miller-Mazzant
Great selection of ice cream! There were 18 flavours I believe when we visited. It always smells amazing going in here, as they make the fudge on tables on the left of the shop where you can see them making it and letting it set. There is a restroom available for customers.
GQ Traveler
Awesome ice cream from the amish Yoder. I was extremely happy when I saw where they source their ice cream. Well done guys!!
J K
Friendly atmosphere, seasonal ice cream flavors, great serving sizes.
Jorge Lima
The Hot chocolate is NOT GOOD. A paper cup with warm milk and a plastic spoon with a chocolate lump on it for you to stir and hope it dissolves is not Hot Chocolate
Sherry Crandall
Lots of yummy ice cream and fudge
S
It IS fantastic!! 😃🥰 They also have a lot of other goodies. The employees were great! Thanks!
Grant West
A fernandina classic. Just thinking about it makes me home sick. Be warned it can get extremely busy so be ready to wait a bit.
Joseph Lacey
Stopped in for ice cream ,it was wonderful the guys working were nice . Came back next day for fudge and few white coconut haystacks . Great young lady working. Highly recommend this shop.
Debbi Rigdon
Hands down, the absolute best fudge I've ever had (that wasn't my own, LOL)! This is a nice, tight confection, NOT the creamy, near-frosting type of fudge. Staff has always been pleasant & patient. This is a must-stop whenever we're nearby.
Fantastic Fudge definitely lives up to its name! When I visited, it wasn’t busy at all, which made the experience even more enjoyable. As soon as you walk through the door, you’re greeted with the sweet, irresistible smell of fudge — it instantly pulls you in.The fudge itself is unlike anything I’ve ever had before. It’s rich, creamy, and smooth, almost with the texture of Brie cheese — melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Each bite was decadent without being overly sweet, which made it hard to stop at just one piece.The shop has a charming, nostalgic feel to it, and the staff were welcoming and happy to answer questions. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to bring some home to share (or maybe not share!). If you’re a fudge lover — or even if you think you aren’t — Fantastic Fudge is worth the stop. It’s truly a one-of-a-kind treat.
CM
Greats service, good ice cream and amazing treats! Spoiled for choice, went twice, never disappointed.
Fantastic and open past 9 pm on busy holidays. Great staff and they were quick and efficient
Amazing ice cream hot chocolate and coffee
Great selection of ice cream! There were 18 flavours I believe when we visited. It always smells amazing going in here, as they make the fudge on tables on the left of the shop where you can see them making it and letting it set. There is a restroom available for customers.
Awesome ice cream from the amish Yoder. I was extremely happy when I saw where they source their ice cream. Well done guys!!
Friendly atmosphere, seasonal ice cream flavors, great serving sizes.
The Hot chocolate is NOT GOOD. A paper cup with warm milk and a plastic spoon with a chocolate lump on it for you to stir and hope it dissolves is not Hot Chocolate
Lots of yummy ice cream and fudge
It IS fantastic!! 😃🥰 They also have a lot of other goodies. The employees were great! Thanks!
A fernandina classic. Just thinking about it makes me home sick. Be warned it can get extremely busy so be ready to wait a bit.
Stopped in for ice cream ,it was wonderful the guys working were nice . Came back next day for fudge and few white coconut haystacks . Great young lady working. Highly recommend this shop.
Hands down, the absolute best fudge I've ever had (that wasn't my own, LOL)! This is a nice, tight confection, NOT the creamy, near-frosting type of fudge. Staff has always been pleasant & patient. This is a must-stop whenever we're nearby.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great little spot in the staff is really passionate
Very cool historic store. We got fudge and ice cream and everyone was very happy! Great for kids.
Fantastic Fudge definitely lives up to its name! When I visited, it wasn’t busy at all, which made the experience even more enjoyable. As soon as you walk through the door, you’re greeted with the sweet, irresistible smell of fudge — it instantly pulls you in.The fudge itself is unlike anything I’ve ever had before. It’s rich, creamy, and smooth, almost with the texture of Brie cheese — melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Each bite was decadent without being overly sweet, which made it hard to stop at just one piece.The shop has a charming, nostalgic feel to it, and the staff were welcoming and happy to answer questions. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to bring some home to share (or maybe not share!).
If you’re a fudge lover — or even if you think you aren’t — Fantastic Fudge is worth the stop. It’s truly a one-of-a-kind treat.
Greats service, good ice cream and amazing treats! Spoiled for choice, went twice, never disappointed.
Treats were good and price was fair.
Loading...