Fantastic Fudge

218 Centre St, Fernandina Beach
(904) 277-4801

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katie Jones

Ice cream was good but not home made. Fudge and other desserts were good.

Clint Smith

salted caramel ice cream delicious as usual. first time since the number system was added. we were the only ones at the counter to order and the girl only cared about our number. so I went outside and7 found the number dispenser while other customers got ahead of us. annoyed me more than it should, I guess.

Justin Hedrick

Fantastic experience. Great product and customer service. Price is fair. The espresso is top quality and they invested in good equipment. Would recommend.

Jeff Nelson

Busy shop, always cool to be able to see where the fudge is made. Staff was courteous and fast.

Laura Hunter Kirk

Yummy ice cream and could tell me what was gf. Prices were good too.

hannah

delicious ice cream!!! We went two days in a row during our vacation lol

Vickie Pastrick

Hmmm… we come here 3-4 times when we visit Amelia. Ice cream still good. Peanut butter fudge, which used to be AMAZING, is NSM this time. Has something changed? Still super creamy and not sugary and gritty like so much fudge. But just not as peanut buttery….more peanut butter please. LOL!

Courtney Kitchens

Best fudge in town and fantastic milkshakes

holly Petrocelli

Google maps says they are open until 10:00 walked up at 10 minutes after 9:00 to be told by 3 employees that they're closed.

Service: 1

Mate Family

Went in this afternoon my husband wanted fudge so I asked to taste the Chocolate then noticed they had maple which I know he likes but when I asked to try it I was informed that they only sample one per customer. I could understand if I was trying to taste every flavor but I was looking at the two I felt he might enjoy and wanted to taste them to make sure. We’ve come to this shop each time we come and normally get ice cream and have always enjoyed it. However, since the staff made me feel unwelcome I don’t think we will be back. I’m sure it won’t matter since around 8 people came in after I left.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Alberto Cappelletti

The fudge was actually fantastic as the name says.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

BRAD Mears

Delicious Fudge and Dark Chocolate Almond candy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fudge

Kathy

Lovely place. Nice people. I love peanut butter but can’t have chocolate so I got the bright idea to get some pb fudge (it looked so good!) and vanilla ice cream. We went outside and sat down to eat. But both the fudge and the ice cream were gooey. I couldn’t even tell the fudge was peanut butter. Tasted like vanilla. Very disappointed, but others apparently love it because we’ve gone by here every day for a week and there are lots and lots of customers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Sherri “Sherri Dawn” Leach

We opted for the maple and peanut butter fudge and pumpkin latte. All were delicious!! The staff is helpful and we loved watching how smoothly they all work together. I normally skip the fudge shops, but I'm so glad we stopped in...twice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William Niemiec

Came in for ice cream with my family. $6 for a single scoop and I don’t think it’s possible for them to make the scoops smaller. Honestly, it’s a ripoff!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Loading...