Didn’t actually get to eat and drink here, so I’m reviewing in order to encourage them to fix the discrepancy of their posted hours. Google Maps says they’re closed on Saturday. If you call their number, they say they’re open on Saturday. The business hours sign posted in their door say they’re open Saturday. If you show up there on a Saturday, they are closed. The menu looked good though, and I’m disappointed we didn’t get to try it.
Rory White
Great pizza parlor with a big selection of tap beer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Stanley
Our first visit , read a food critic blog and she raved about the brewery. We are not big beer consumers, but we are pizza critics and I have to tell you , the Pizza is by far the best Pizza we have had in Nassau, Duval, Clay, and Flagler County. This will definitely be our Pizza joint...... I wish they did have tea options along with an Arnold Palmer though......
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Phillip Smith
First time in somehow. Hatch chili cheeseburger was awesome and FF are 👍 TY!
Keith Maurer
Great place, very good food! Pizza was a bit salty but otherwise very good. Fries and wings awesome! All the employees were very nice and helpful. Good atmosphere! Also, the prices were pretty good for this current market$$$
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Andrew
Great brewery spot with delicious pizza, burgers, wings and salads. The service is friendly and attentive. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marc Hamerski
We went in the middle of the day a few weeks ago and were close to the only people there. We brought our children. The staff yelled at my wife and I for letting the kids walk around and be out of their chairs. I would get this if we weren't the only people in the restaurant but I'm not sure what we were disrupting.
I'll say the food was very good. The beer was okay. If you're not with a family I'm sure it's a good place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Beth Homans
Great food, beer, and fun atmosphere!
Kieran Kieran
Fantastic, steaming hot pizza and a kind and funny staff.
I will be coming back!
Michael Zadnik
Excellent beer and really good pizza. Stopped by with the pup so we grabbed a picnic table outside. The beer was cold and delicious. The pizza was sneakily good - crispy thin crust. Downed the whole thing with ease! Had a nice salad as well. Nice brewery!
Great staff! Menu looks good and fair but did not try the food - next time for sure! Great beer selection with great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Bender
I was hoping to leave a rave review this evening but such is not the case. Many reviews on Amelia and Fernandina Beach social media pages speak highly of First Love Brewing. I will, for one, echo that their beers are very good. My reason for visiting tonight was pizza which also receives good reviews. It must have been an off night as a nearly 30-minute wait (which was explained to me when I ordered) for to-go order produced a pizza with limp crust, little tomato sauce, not enough pepperoni to cover the surface but plenty of cheese. I wasn't going to wait until I got home to Yulee to sample it so I pulled over in Mocoma parking lot and ate two pieces. Nothing about it made me want to eat a third piece without first putting it in my air fryer at home, so off I drove. It did crisp it up but had I eaten it at the brewery, I would have sent it back. For those of you who rave about their pizza, this transplant from South Jersey begs to differ and will look elsewhere for a better pizza. But their beers are good. 🤔
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Lara Nofsinger
Wow, this might be the best dinner we've had since we moved to Amelia Island in early 2023. The burgers were high quality and cooked perfectly with excellent fries along side. My husband and son share some wings and still talk about them weeks later. My daughter's meatball pizza was a good value and high quality but probably not the best selection for our tastes. I wouldn't hesitate to try another pizza next time. I don't write reviews often but felt compelled to share my experience with First Love Brewery. There is no doubt that we'll be back.
I recently had my wedding reception here and gosh was it perfect! Kevin was great at communicating and working with us on everything! The staff was wonderful, friendly and accommodating. The food was so delicious, and most importantly the beer was fabulous! Everyone had a blast, and I can't wait to go back to enjoy some brews.
Didn’t actually get to eat and drink here, so I’m reviewing in order to encourage them to fix the discrepancy of their posted hours. Google Maps says they’re closed on Saturday. If you call their number, they say they’re open on Saturday. The business hours sign posted in their door say they’re open Saturday. If you show up there on a Saturday, they are closed. The menu looked good though, and I’m disappointed we didn’t get to try it.
Great pizza parlor with a big selection of tap beer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our first visit , read a food critic blog and she raved about the brewery. We are not big beer consumers, but we are pizza critics and I have to tell you , the Pizza is by far the best Pizza we have had in Nassau, Duval, Clay, and Flagler County. This will definitely be our Pizza joint......
I wish they did have tea options along with an Arnold Palmer though......
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
First time in somehow. Hatch chili cheeseburger was awesome and FF are 👍 TY!
Great place, very good food! Pizza was a bit salty but otherwise very good. Fries and wings awesome! All the employees were very nice and helpful. Good atmosphere! Also, the prices were pretty good for this current market$$$
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great brewery spot with delicious pizza, burgers, wings and salads. The service is friendly and attentive. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went in the middle of the day a few weeks ago and were close to the only people there. We brought our children. The staff yelled at my wife and I for letting the kids walk around and be out of their chairs. I would get this if we weren't the only people in the restaurant but I'm not sure what we were disrupting.
I'll say the food was very good. The beer was okay. If you're not with a family I'm sure it's a good place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Great food, beer, and fun atmosphere!
Fantastic, steaming hot pizza and a kind and funny staff. I will be coming back!
Excellent beer and really good pizza. Stopped by with the pup so we grabbed a picnic table outside. The beer was cold and delicious. The pizza was sneakily good - crispy thin crust. Downed the whole thing with ease! Had a nice salad as well. Nice brewery!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great staff! Menu looks good and fair but did not try the food - next time for sure! Great beer selection with great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I was hoping to leave a rave review this evening but such is not the case. Many reviews on Amelia and Fernandina Beach social media pages speak highly of First Love Brewing. I will, for one, echo that their beers are very good. My reason for visiting tonight was pizza which also receives good reviews. It must have been an off night as a nearly 30-minute wait (which was explained to me when I ordered) for to-go order produced a pizza with limp crust, little tomato sauce, not enough pepperoni to cover the surface but plenty of cheese. I wasn't going to wait until I got home to Yulee to sample it so I pulled over in Mocoma parking lot and ate two pieces. Nothing about it made me want to eat a third piece without first putting it in my air fryer at home, so off I drove. It did crisp it up but had I eaten it at the brewery, I would have sent it back. For those of you who rave about their pizza, this transplant from South Jersey begs to differ and will look elsewhere for a better pizza. But their beers are good. 🤔
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Wow, this might be the best dinner we've had since we moved to Amelia Island in early 2023. The burgers were high quality and cooked perfectly with excellent fries along side. My husband and son share some wings and still talk about them weeks later. My daughter's meatball pizza was a good value and high quality but probably not the best selection for our tastes. I wouldn't hesitate to try another pizza next time. I don't write reviews often but felt compelled to share my experience with First Love Brewery. There is no doubt that we'll be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza and beer are kill
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
I recently had my wedding reception here and gosh was it perfect!
Kevin was great at communicating and working with us on everything! The staff was wonderful, friendly and accommodating.
The food was so delicious, and most importantly the beer was fabulous!
Everyone had a blast, and I can't wait to go back to enjoy some brews.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Huli Huli Wings, Meatball Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Wings, Beer Flight
Loading...