Timoti's Seafood Shak

21 N 3rd St, Fernandina Beach
(904) 310-6550

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica Brinkmann

My party had shrimp basket, lobster roll, tacos, and poke bowl. The only seating is outside, but it is too crowded and not enough tables. Fast service. French fries were not hot. Food was okay.

Cpt Bayley

STOP debating with yourself & just go to this restaurant already, you won’t regret it.
Ya know how you vacation to a coastal city & you gain that undeniable craving for amazing fresh seafood? That’s probably what you were looking for, like me, when you found this place.
• Great food
• Great prices for the area
• Exceptional friendly staff

Just go dude, this is the place.

Christian Duplantis

Quick and easy!

No frills, walk up and look at the menu, then order.

I had the T’s Wrap with blackened shrimp was great, that could be a daily eat! Also, I ordered the fired oyster basket (it’s my thing growing up in South Louisiana) and they were cook to perfection (not dry and too crispy)!

The better half had the Tuna Poke and she was pleased.

One teen had the Chopped Salad box and the other fried chicken fingers.

Great job and we will be back. !

Aletia Phelps

Food was very good, service was fast considering how many people were there

Noah Norman

When it comes to the fried seafood they have, its pretty good. HOWEVER- I ordered a poke bowl for the first and last time today, and no joke it was the worst poke bowl I’ve ever had. Publix has a TEN TIMES BETTER poke bowl LOL. There were no sesame seeds, no sauce, for some reason they're not using sushi rice and instead opted for coconut rice?? (I don’t know if that was their attempt at being original but it was terrible and dry with little to no flavor) There was no sauce, no seasoning - the poke bowl was literally tuna, shitty rice, some lettuce, and a couple avocado slices. Thats it. Served with a lemon wedge and container of soy sauce. Ive never had a poke bowl that was so boring and bland. There were no flavors other than the bare bones ingredients that were just thrown together. At least publix’s poke bowl has good rice, other actual ingredients for taste and variety that complement each other to enhance the dish, and at the very least had Teriyaki sauce to make it flavorful. This no joke was the worst attempt at a poke bowl ive ever seen. Your local grocery store has better save your time and money and just go there.

Michelle Coblentz

Great, fresh seafood. Tacos and fish sandwich were delightful

John Greene

Best place around for a seafood basket and a beer. Reasonable prices. Can be a bit of a line at busy times and all outside dining area with large play area.

Brittany Downs

The food was amazing as always. The service tonight from the cashier… unprofessional beyond measure. She rolled her eyes at every person who she took orders from along with making direct comments to the customers and comments under her breath. I also received attitude when ordering because she’d cut me off before I could answer, resulting in us speaking at the same time. As someone who lives here, absolutely unacceptable. Unacceptable regardless.

Boris Nikitin

Top notch seafood! Very laid back and relaxing atmosphere

William Browning

Smaller place order and find a table. Fun atmosphere nice people

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fresh Catch, Chowder

Jeff Reese

Fantastic fresh shrimp. I had the blackened po'boy and she had the blackened basket.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Choice of Shrimp

Jordan Kern-Fordyce

A little throw off at first because it only has outside seating and your order at a cashier and bring the food out yourself. However, the service was quick and friendly AND every item we had on the menu was excellent and cooked to perfection. Friends Oysters had the most amazing crunchy exterior and soft interior, not chewy at all. I had the Baja box and the was cooked to perfection and seasoned well with the blacken seasoning. Perfect avocado and nicely seasoned black beans. Also someone got the cucumber salad which was fresh and light. Loved how it was cut into long ribbons and came with red onions. We loved their hush puppies too. Would definitely return.

Kid-friendliness: Playground onsite

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish, Cucumber Salad, Choice of Shrimp

Steve

You can't get better fried seafood, great seafood stew.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Perfect, Fresh Catch, Fish, Sandwich, Chowder, Tuna

Heike Hausmann

Very tasty shrimp with delicious crispy, seasoned fries and hushpuppies. Absolutely recommended.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Asaph Contractors

If you are looking for a quick meal definitely stop here. Only negative is there isn’t much seating.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...