We are from Chicago and we came out to Florida for my daughters birthday and she asked if she can get spaghetti for her birthday. So we found Tony's just doing a search at the pool and his place popped up and I will tell you I'm very glad it did. If you want some top knotch Italian food this is the place if you have the chance come here and get some food it's excellent and Tony himself cooked our food it was delicious. I will definitely come back here for food next vacation.
ZOHP
It really pains me to write this, because this used to be the best ice cream in Fort Myers. However it appears that someone bought this business with little idea on how to make ice cream, and they don’t appear to have the nitrogen experience they were well known for.
My ice cream came out mostly flavorless, with the consistency of mashed potatoes. Tiny amount for $8. From the best in town to the worst in SW Florida. Honestly ruined my day. Slow, bad texture, bad flavor.
Dan A
First time visiting this place. Disappointing! I was charged for a small cup of icecream for my grandchild and I, $17. I was going to turn away and go somewhere else, but I did not want to disappoint my grandchild. I was shocked! What a rip off! And to top it off, the ice cream is nothing to brag about. I will never go back there. Save a trip and more cash in your pocket and go to another ice cream place.
Karli Nalls
From Churned to Burned: A Sad Decline
This ice cream shop was once a true standout—easily the best in town and, quite honestly, the best I’d ever had. The magic was in the made-to-order process: every scoop freshly churned, rich with flavor, and impeccably smooth. It was an experience as much as a treat.
But that excellence is now a memory.
In switching to pre-made batches prepared each morning, the quality has taken a noticeable hit. The texture lacks freshness, the flavors fall flat, and the once-special experience feels subpar.
It’s disappointing to see such a beloved place compromise what made it exceptional.
RW
What happened to this place?? Seems like new ownership. They used to have fresh made-to-order ice cream. Now, the ice cream is grainy and practically melted. Disgusting! Paid $17 plus tip for two ice creams in a cup just to throw it away. Shame on you for selling this to customers!
Rezen Bomb
Once upon a time there was a ice cream shop that prepared fresh, made to order ice cream using liquid nitrogen. You would come in and they would make a cereal bowl of little goodies, cover it in freezing gas and throw a bit on you for fun... Awesome. The fresh made ice cream and candy clouds of cotton candy, and the atmosphere was great for a quick little stop with kids or adults. And everything tasted amazing. But alas, it's changed as many things do and not for the better. I received scooped ice cream...scooped? What happened? No mixing just toppings. It's a regular ice cream shop now. Perhaps the economics of having a unique ice cream style have been decimated by a shortage of customers..idk I certainly will miss the unique style and atmosphere... The ice cream here is just fine. If you like ice cream you can get some here.
Jessi Norvell
When they say “best ice cream”, they mean it! They made vegan ice cream fresh to order - any flavor available! Soft and creamy and delicious! Unlimited flavors nitrogen ice cream. ❤️
Javiela Quiroz
Honestly is not a good place 😒 maybe it was before but I went over there, the place looks dirty and Didn’t like the services, the ice cream and was expensive, I didn’t step out because my 4 years old didn’t let me, he was excited about getting ice cream.
Maidel Ramirez
Honestly, this has been the worst ice cream I have ever bought in my life. When I left, my daughter had to throw it away. The ice cream was bad, the service was bad, the place was also bad. Nothing to save from it. I see the reviews and I wonder if we are talking about the same ice cream shop because my experience was very bad.
John Castillo
“Best Ice Cream” lives up to its name. Every flavor is like nothing I’ve tasted before, it truly is the best ice cream.
Best ice cream spot ever, so fresh and creamy! Nothing compares lol
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael
Love this place! The dry ice is so cool! Great for kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anny Katherine Quevedo
Good attention, delicious ice cream ♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katerina Amidano
It really is the best ice cream in Fort Myers! The ice cream is made fresh each day, and with each order, an appetizer of popcorn, cereal flakes and other small snacks are splashed with a bit of liquid nitrogen that makes it fun to eat since vapor is spewing out of your mouth! 10/10 would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JR C
Best ice cream was amazing! Service was excellent and the ice cream really was the best! We are definitely coming back to try other flavors. Thank you!
Kid-friendliness: The owner was extremely friendly and great with the kids. They loved the appetizer of freeze dried treats!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Free Appetizer Sampler, Cookies N Cream
We are from Chicago and we came out to Florida for my daughters birthday and she asked if she can get spaghetti for her birthday. So we found Tony's just doing a search at the pool and his place popped up and I will tell you I'm very glad it did. If you want some top knotch Italian food this is the place if you have the chance come here and get some food it's excellent and Tony himself cooked our food it was delicious. I will definitely come back here for food next vacation.
It really pains me to write this, because this used to be the best ice cream in Fort Myers. However it appears that someone bought this business with little idea on how to make ice cream, and they don’t appear to have the nitrogen experience they were well known for.
My ice cream came out mostly flavorless, with the consistency of mashed potatoes. Tiny amount for $8. From the best in town to the worst in SW Florida. Honestly ruined my day. Slow, bad texture, bad flavor.
First time visiting this place. Disappointing! I was charged for a small cup of icecream for my grandchild and I, $17. I was going to turn away and go somewhere else, but I did not want to disappoint my grandchild. I was shocked! What a rip off! And to top it off, the ice cream is nothing to brag about. I will never go back there. Save a trip and more cash in your pocket and go to another ice cream place.
From Churned to Burned: A Sad Decline
This ice cream shop was once a true standout—easily the best in town and, quite honestly, the best I’d ever had. The magic was in the made-to-order process: every scoop freshly churned, rich with flavor, and impeccably smooth. It was an experience as much as a treat.
But that excellence is now a memory.
In switching to pre-made batches prepared each morning, the quality has taken a noticeable hit. The texture lacks freshness, the flavors fall flat, and the once-special experience feels subpar.
It’s disappointing to see such a beloved place compromise what made it exceptional.
What happened to this place?? Seems like new ownership. They used to have fresh made-to-order ice cream. Now, the ice cream is grainy and practically melted. Disgusting! Paid $17 plus tip for two ice creams in a cup just to throw it away. Shame on you for selling this to customers!
Once upon a time there was a ice cream shop that prepared fresh, made to order ice cream using liquid nitrogen. You would come in and they would make a cereal bowl of little goodies, cover it in freezing gas and throw a bit on you for fun... Awesome. The fresh made ice cream and candy clouds of cotton candy, and the atmosphere was great for a quick little stop with kids or adults. And everything tasted amazing.
But alas, it's changed as many things do and not for the better. I received scooped ice cream...scooped? What happened? No mixing just toppings. It's a regular ice cream shop now.
Perhaps the economics of having a unique ice cream style have been decimated by a shortage of customers..idk
I certainly will miss the unique style and atmosphere...
The ice cream here is just fine. If you like ice cream you can get some here.
When they say “best ice cream”, they mean it! They made vegan ice cream fresh to order - any flavor available! Soft and creamy and delicious! Unlimited flavors nitrogen ice cream. ❤️
Honestly is not a good place 😒 maybe it was before but I went over there, the place looks dirty and Didn’t like the services, the ice cream and was expensive, I didn’t step out because my 4 years old didn’t let me, he was excited about getting ice cream.
Honestly, this has been the worst ice cream I have ever bought in my life. When I left, my daughter had to throw it away. The ice cream was bad, the service was bad, the place was also bad. Nothing to save from it. I see the reviews and I wonder if we are talking about the same ice cream shop because my experience was very bad.
“Best Ice Cream” lives up to its name. Every flavor is like nothing I’ve tasted before, it truly is the best ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream spot ever, so fresh and creamy! Nothing compares lol
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place! The dry ice is so cool! Great for kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good attention, delicious ice cream ♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It really is the best ice cream in Fort Myers! The ice cream is made fresh each day, and with each order, an appetizer of popcorn, cereal flakes and other small snacks are splashed with a bit of liquid nitrogen that makes it fun to eat since vapor is spewing out of your mouth! 10/10 would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best ice cream was amazing! Service was excellent and the ice cream really was the best! We are definitely coming back to try other flavors. Thank you!
Kid-friendliness: The owner was extremely friendly and great with the kids. They loved the appetizer of freeze dried treats!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Free Appetizer Sampler, Cookies N Cream
Loading...