Fun experience on a date night or out with the family. The ice cream is made fresh to order. It is fun to see turn into the delicious delights. They also make fun experiments with cereal that is sure to delight the kids and the adult kids. A bit pricey for just a quick trip to get ice cream but a fun experience.
kayli haaland
This was an amazing experience with my kids we took some cute photos it was fast service wonderful ice cream I highly recommend mango strawberry icecream we did the dream cloud my kids was amazed will return
Stephanie Fillman
Best Ice Cream IS the best ice cream,super yummy served with a lot of TLC. If I were living in the area I'd visit often! Made from scratch! The woman who made our ice cream was really friendly (wore mask) and patient while we tried to make up our minds (great menu). We'll be back!
Steve Hogan
The name says it all, delicious ice cream made to order!! Yes you read that correctly, it may take a little longer than scooping your favorite flavor but it’s worth the wait. Seeing the liquid nitrogen poured into the mixer and the cloud that emerges to make the ice cream is fascinating to watch and fun for all ages. We will definitely be back for more.
Caitlin M
Unique experience! I went to a very popular ice cream place nearby and it paled in comparison to Best! The giggle snack(?) before the ice cream was hilarious and tasty. The manager was friendly and knowledgeable. The flavors were innovative. And the opportunity to create your own ice cream makes the experience even more special! I had a coconut base with chocolate toasted coconut, almond Joy, and a side of hot fudge. Came dressed in edible glitter! Super cute and tasted like Almond Joy in a bowl.
Angela T
This is not a typical ice cream joint, this is an ice cream experience. The employees are extremely knowledgeable as expert dessert chefs & take their time to explain their extensive menu. You are watching ice cream being made! The liquid nitrogen experience is quite exciting as they provide a snack while you wait- imagine it - munching on popcorn & treats that have been flashed by the liquid nitrogen. We placed a very special order, the Dream Cloud/Confetti. The cotton candy was made fresh & decorated with all kinds of candy while a bowl of specially made to order ice cream was in the center. This was a great 'shareable' treat! You are given a bag to take home the extra cotton candy, which was the best I had ever tasted. There are cute cards, small gifts, and other items to gaze upon or buy while you wait for your special creation.
Victoria
As others have said, it is not a walk in walk out place. It took about 15 minutes for us with two other customers in the shop. However, it was a fun way to end our day. The decorations are colorful and glittery and the nitrogen popcorn was hilarious, even for us almost 30 year olds. I had the lavender ice cream which is a delicious and unique flavor I rarely see at ice cream shops. Even better, you can combine whatever ingredients you want because they make it right there in front of you. Like Coldstone but even better. The edible glitter topping made my day.
Anya Alyssa Ciesienski
I love Best Ice Cream, and the owner, Ali, is awesome! I got a "dream cone" the last time I went, which was really good, and really pretty! I love shiny things, so the edible glitter is so cool! My mom, and I, each have one custom flavor so far... and, our little dog, Kilo, gets the ice cream made especially for your pups! My mom is in love with her lavender ice cream that she'd wanted so badly at first, but the couple times we'd went there they were out of the lavender. So, twice now, once yesterday for Mothers Day, i've stopped in to see if the lavender was in stock... luckily, it was, so I ordered that with extra dark chocolate pieces in it, so I could surprise her with it! She thought it was the best surprise, and really the best ice cream...i was so happy to make my mom happy! I tasted the lavender ice cream, and it was not bad at all... really light flavoring, but a lot of it, if that makes any sense... it's just not something that i'd order for myselfBut, it's definitely recommended by my mom! My creation is a salted caramel ice cream, then with little white chocolate chips mixed throughout it, and topped with strawberries that Ali cut to look like hearts... with the edible glitter, and those strawberries, the ice cream comes out AMAZING! We all three, Kilo the dog included, HIGHLY recommend going as soon as you can, if you haven't been already... you won't be disappointed! I can't imagine what a catered event, or party at the shop, would be/ look like... definitely magical, and unforgettable! I've read a few bad reviews regarding how long the people were there for, and that some orders from customers that came after them were started before the initial order placed was finished. They can be working on one order, then be able to start another, and still be able to present the original customers order first... it's just the way they do things, and find to be easiest, I'd assume. It's truly worth the wait, because of the quality, fun, love, and whimsical spirit, that's put into everything they make! Plus, there are so many things to look at, and/or do around the shop while your creation is being made... artwork, a piano, beautiful furniture, and other cool items... even a little, fun game on each table! There was a lot of thought, and love, put into this business by its owner, Ali! I'm so blessed to have met such a kind soul as hers! And, DON'T forget to take home at least one goodie... homemade ice cream sandwich, doggie ice cream, a treat for a family member/ friend/ etc! Oh yeah, one more thing that I am definitely getting next time I go is the creme brulee...as usual, it looks amazing just like everything else that has to do with Best Ice Cream "Land!" Have fun, and enjoy! ???❗
Brittany Brack
Stopped by this spot for a little late night dessert. Great selection of flavors and toppings! They even have plant-based/dairy free ice cream options. We enjoyed a complimentary appetizer of Giggly Popcorn (which was actually a lot of fun and DID make us giggle). The ambiance and decoration inside make the experience a lot of fun. Good ice cream made fresh on order, fun ambiance, and friendly staff. Glad we stopped by!
Alden H.
Wanted to go for a quick ice cream break after a long day, but if you are looking for something like that then this isn't the place for you. Really great idea to start ice cream from scratch, and they had a wide variety of options to choose from, however the operation wasn't very efficient. Waited almost an hour for our ice cream, given they start from scratch we tried to brush that aside, but it was just far too long a wait for a single cup, which we all shared. Once we did get the ice cream it was ok, but we just couldn't get past the wait time. If you are ok with a long wait, then it isn't a terrible option.
Definitely recommend this. Coming from a big city and stopping by Sanibel Island, I highly recommend this. You will not go wrong.
Kim J.
BEST ICE CREAM I'VE EVER HAD!!! I would drive an hour to get this stuff again if I lived here. Truly ice cream artists. We designed an ice cream flavor by discussing what I like (birthday cake, almond, called is wedding cake ice cream). This should be a major tourist destination. But then it would need to be much bigger. The place is adorable too.
Katie Zerbe
This place is an interesting experience. If you like unique places this is it. For us it was a little too sweet, took way too long and was too pricey. Kids would probably love it.
Robert V.
Wow the details in this place is amazing. Ice cream is phenomenal. I'm a foodie and this place is a great ice cream spot. They had a gentleman playing piano while I enjoyed my ice cream with the wifey. Definitely coming back. If your in town or a local a must try!!!!
Vanessa T.
The best ice cream I have ever had. Customer service was amazing, they even made dog safe ice cream for my two pups. I will be coming back when I go on vacation again down here in Sanibel/Fort Myers. You do have to wait a little longer for ice cream but it is well worth the homemade taste. If I could give it 10 stars I would!!
Fun experience on a date night or out with the family. The ice cream is made fresh to order. It is fun to see turn into the delicious delights. They also make fun experiments with cereal that is sure to delight the kids and the adult kids. A bit pricey for just a quick trip to get ice cream but a fun experience.
This was an amazing experience with my kids we took some cute photos it was fast service wonderful ice cream I highly recommend mango strawberry icecream we did the dream cloud my kids was amazed will return
Best Ice Cream IS the best ice cream,super yummy served with a lot of TLC. If I were living in the area I'd visit often! Made from scratch! The woman who made our ice cream was really friendly (wore mask) and patient while we tried to make up our minds (great menu). We'll be back!
The name says it all, delicious ice cream made to order!! Yes you read that correctly, it may take a little longer than scooping your favorite flavor but it’s worth the wait. Seeing the liquid nitrogen poured into the mixer and the cloud that emerges to make the ice cream is fascinating to watch and fun for all ages. We will definitely be back for more.
Unique experience! I went to a very popular ice cream place nearby and it paled in comparison to Best! The giggle snack(?) before the ice cream was hilarious and tasty. The manager was friendly and knowledgeable. The flavors were innovative. And the opportunity to create your own ice cream makes the experience even more special! I had a coconut base with chocolate toasted coconut, almond Joy, and a side of hot fudge. Came dressed in edible glitter! Super cute and tasted like Almond Joy in a bowl.
This is not a typical ice cream joint, this is an ice cream experience. The employees are extremely knowledgeable as expert dessert chefs & take their time to explain their extensive menu. You are watching ice cream being made! The liquid nitrogen experience is quite exciting as they provide a snack while you wait- imagine it - munching on popcorn & treats that have been flashed by the liquid nitrogen. We placed a very special order, the Dream Cloud/Confetti. The cotton candy was made fresh & decorated with all kinds of candy while a bowl of specially made to order ice cream was in the center. This was a great 'shareable' treat! You are given a bag to take home the extra cotton candy, which was the best I had ever tasted. There are cute cards, small gifts, and other items to gaze upon or buy while you wait for your special creation.
As others have said, it is not a walk in walk out place. It took about 15 minutes for us with two other customers in the shop. However, it was a fun way to end our day. The decorations are colorful and glittery and the nitrogen popcorn was hilarious, even for us almost 30 year olds. I had the lavender ice cream which is a delicious and unique flavor I rarely see at ice cream shops. Even better, you can combine whatever ingredients you want because they make it right there in front of you. Like Coldstone but even better. The edible glitter topping made my day.
I love Best Ice Cream, and the owner, Ali, is awesome! I got a "dream cone" the last time I went, which was really good, and really pretty! I love shiny things, so the edible glitter is so cool! My mom, and I, each have one custom flavor so far... and, our little dog, Kilo, gets the ice cream made especially for your pups! My mom is in love with her lavender ice cream that she'd wanted so badly at first, but the couple times we'd went there they were out of the lavender. So, twice now, once yesterday for Mothers Day, i've stopped in to see if the lavender was in stock... luckily, it was, so I ordered that with extra dark chocolate pieces in it, so I could surprise her with it! She thought it was the best surprise, and really the best ice cream...i was so happy to make my mom happy! I tasted the lavender ice cream, and it was not bad at all... really light flavoring, but a lot of it, if that makes any sense... it's just not something that i'd order for myselfBut, it's definitely recommended by my mom! My creation is a salted caramel ice cream, then with little white chocolate chips mixed throughout it, and topped with strawberries that Ali cut to look like hearts... with the edible glitter, and those strawberries, the ice cream comes out AMAZING! We all three, Kilo the dog included, HIGHLY recommend going as soon as you can, if you haven't been already... you won't be disappointed! I can't imagine what a catered event, or party at the shop, would be/ look like... definitely magical, and unforgettable! I've read a few bad reviews regarding how long the people were there for, and that some orders from customers that came after them were started before the initial order placed was finished. They can be working on one order, then be able to start another, and still be able to present the original customers order first... it's just the way they do things, and find to be easiest, I'd assume. It's truly worth the wait, because of the quality, fun, love, and whimsical spirit, that's put into everything they make! Plus, there are so many things to look at, and/or do around the shop while your creation is being made... artwork, a piano, beautiful furniture, and other cool items... even a little, fun game on each table! There was a lot of thought, and love, put into this business by its owner, Ali! I'm so blessed to have met such a kind soul as hers! And, DON'T forget to take home at least one goodie... homemade ice cream sandwich, doggie ice cream, a treat for a family member/ friend/ etc! Oh yeah, one more thing that I am definitely getting next time I go is the creme brulee...as usual, it looks amazing just like everything else that has to do with Best Ice Cream "Land!" Have fun, and enjoy! ???❗
Stopped by this spot for a little late night dessert. Great selection of flavors and toppings! They even have plant-based/dairy free ice cream options. We enjoyed a complimentary appetizer of Giggly Popcorn (which was actually a lot of fun and DID make us giggle). The ambiance and decoration inside make the experience a lot of fun. Good ice cream made fresh on order, fun ambiance, and friendly staff. Glad we stopped by!
Wanted to go for a quick ice cream break after a long day, but if you are looking for something like that then this isn't the place for you. Really great idea to start ice cream from scratch, and they had a wide variety of options to choose from, however the operation wasn't very efficient. Waited almost an hour for our ice cream, given they start from scratch we tried to brush that aside, but it was just far too long a wait for a single cup, which we all shared. Once we did get the ice cream it was ok, but we just couldn't get past the wait time. If you are ok with a long wait, then it isn't a terrible option.
Restaurantji Recommends
Definitely recommend this. Coming from a big city and stopping by Sanibel Island, I highly recommend this. You will not go wrong.
BEST ICE CREAM I'VE EVER HAD!!! I would drive an hour to get this stuff again if I lived here. Truly ice cream artists. We designed an ice cream flavor by discussing what I like (birthday cake, almond, called is wedding cake ice cream). This should be a major tourist destination. But then it would need to be much bigger. The place is adorable too.
This place is an interesting experience. If you like unique places this is it. For us it was a little too sweet, took way too long and was too pricey. Kids would probably love it.
Wow the details in this place is amazing. Ice cream is phenomenal. I'm a foodie and this place is a great ice cream spot. They had a gentleman playing piano while I enjoyed my ice cream with the wifey. Definitely coming back. If your in town or a local a must try!!!!
The best ice cream I have ever had. Customer service was amazing, they even made dog safe ice cream for my two pups. I will be coming back when I go on vacation again down here in Sanibel/Fort Myers. You do have to wait a little longer for ice cream but it is well worth the homemade taste. If I could give it 10 stars I would!!