Cape Cod Fish Co

My sister and I had been looking at properties in Sarasota all day and were heading back to home base in Ft Myers late and we were both done in and starving. We shared the full bellies clam appetizer because I had tasted them many years ago in Massachusetts and loved them. They were awesome!! She had one of the specials, Cod and shrimp and said it was awesome. I ordered a “lobstah” roll at the recommendation of our awesome server, Jackie. Jackie was really knowledgeable and helpful with our food choices and also very accommodating when we decided to move from an outside table to inside, as it was a pretty chilly evening.

We stopped for dinner just before the dinner rush. The girls worked the dining room as a team. The service was excellent! We started with the bang bang shrimp, fish and chips and shrimp basket. Everything was so delicious. Both had the fresh brewed tea which was perfect. What a treat!

Take out food was not good. The Cruben was mushy and the seafood shrimp salad with grilled shrimp Was a poor excuse for a salad., Wilty lettuce, With stringy onions. The New England clam chowder was tasty but the clams were somewhat slimey in the soup. All that for $52 disappointed

This is my very favorite local spot for fresh seafood. It is hidden away in Iona, right off of McGregor and at the end of an old strip mall. Small dining areas inside and out and friendly young servers who are eager to please. I always get the clam chowder and the fried shrimp/cod basket and it is prepared perfectly and is always delicious. This is not fine dining but it is always good, filling and served hot. A bonus is a big menu with lunch and dinner. I really look forward to going there and be aware that it is closed on Sundays and Mondays. No tourists, just filled with locals.

This is hands down one of the best seafood spots I’ve ever been to not just in Fort Myers, but anywhere. We ordered the lobster roll (Connecticut style – warm with butter!) and it was perfection. Huge chunks of juicy lobster, perfectly toasted bun, and just the right amount of butter. absolute heaven.You can tell everything is made fresh and with care. The staff was incredibly friendly and made us feel right at home, which just added to the whole experience.If you're looking for authentic New England-style seafood with a local Florida twist, this is the place. Whether you're a local or just visiting, don’t miss this spot. Cape Cod Fish Co. is the real deal.

We had the Fishermanns Platter and Fish and Chips Baskets, we loved everything and the Service was great! We will be back soon. The homemade Breadpudding was the best I ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Bronzed Salmon over basil and balsamic with Saffron Rice and green beans was excellent! My b husband had lightly blackened shrimp and scallops which he also said was very good. Service was friendly and helpful. We will be back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food and service.I wish the portions were just a little bigger.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Had the Bronzed Salmon over basil with balsamic drizzle and saffron rice with green beans. It was a wonderful meal. My husband had lightly blackened shrimp and scallops and said it was very good. The service was friendly and helpful. We’ll be back.

My brother brought me here for my birthday dinner. I had lobster chowder then the Almond Baked cod, both were truly fabulous dishes. I can't recall a better meal that I've ever had.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I got the Connecticut lobster roll ,And my wife got the lobster tacos with truffle fries…..Wow it’s all delicious and our server was the best !!!! And we even seen a owl in the corner outside chilling with us 🦉🦉

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our server was wonderful! The food tasted amazing. We got the coconut shrimp and spicy lobster tacos. We sat at the patio and got to enjoy our dinner with the cutest owl friend. It made all the kids day!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely loved this place! The seafood was super fresh—probably the best lobster roll I’ve had in a long time, packed with sweet lobster on a buttery toasted brioche bun. The clam chowder was creamy and full of flavor without being too heavy, and the mussels were spot on. The vibe is cozy and relaxed, and the staff couldn’t have been nicer—really friendly and happy to make recommendations. If you’re craving authentic New England seafood, this spot is a must. I’ll definitely be back!

We came to visit for a few weeks, and of course, we had to enjoy some good seafood! Thanks to Tripadvisor, finding the perfect spot was easy—and wow, we have no regrets! The food was incredibly fresh, the service excellent, and the prices just right. What more could you ask for? We loved it and will definitely be back. This place might just become our new favorite!

We were craving for Seafood and this was #1 in Fort Myers everywhere so we had to check it out! Nice cozy atmosphere with calm music, great service and the food... not from this world! I could not even imagine how seafood could taste so different compared to other places. Unfortunately we are here only for 3 months of the year but this place got new regulars!