Casa D'Italia
2236 First St, Fort Myers
(239) 245-8496
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Service was very good. Food was ok. Cheap paper napkins and plastic plates. Yet happy to have a restaurant nearby.
Good job! Reliable. Reasonably price. Service was very good. Wine selection, meh if you care about such things.
Ashleigh was amazing! And the food was so good!
First, overall food was good & we will happily return in the future. Service was friendly, but not very attentive. Someone may have called out on this evening, because the bartender was also waiting tables which had to have been challenging for her. Food was good, but lasagne came out lukewarm vs. hot. Had obviously been under a food warmer for a bit. It was tasty, though. Their meatballs are terrific & I highly recommend you try them.
Food was OK , and service was just OK. Probably unerstaffed. Room for improvement, but they are trying hard.
We have been to this restaurant in the past and vowed not to return. New ownership led is to believe there would be a positive change. Upon being seated you are greeted by some lovely flowers, unfortunately they were very much dead. Considering the prices they charge are a little high considering they give you paper napkins and plastic plates. The meni has not changed and the food was okay. Service was fair.
We love visiting Casa D'Italia when we are in town. Both of our meals were delicious (clams in white wine/lemon sauce and mixed seafood pasta). Even better, Verandah residents receive a discount on Monday or Tuesday nights- even better! Thank you!
Delicious food- great service. Need a little less light in dining room- too bright for fine dining. My friend said she had the best cucumber martini ever. When we got there at 5:00- there were still chairs up on tables, which was strange- like a diner and not fine dining. Thanks for a good meal.
Booked 2 weeks in advance for Valentine's Day and they well overbooked. We didn't get seated for nearly an hour after reservation times and we weren't the only couple/group to experience this. They didn't tell us there was a limited menu at any point until the server handed it to us.
We're seated right away in a busy restaurant. Wait staff was friendly and efficient. We had 2 issues felt rushed but it was Valentine's Day so we understood about that and even though my wife's veal Madeira was very tasty the portion was very small. I would try to go again on a less busy day to get a better idea of what the restaurant is.
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent service. We were seated immediately. Server took our drink orders and starters as soon as we were seated. We started with Risotto "meatballs." Rice shaped like meatballs and served with marinara sauce. Salad was large and full of nuts and raisins with vinagarette dressing. We ordered Eggplant parmesan. Portions were plenty for 2 people. Overall the food was very good but everything could have been served hotter. Our friends ordered chicken masala and also enjoyed. The portion didn't seem as large to me but they were satisfied. I would definitely return and ask for items to be heated longer.
We went to Casa D'Italia on a Saturday evening with a reservation for 7 PM. We were not impressed by the thin paper napkins and paper tablecloth. We loved our server-can't remember his name. We ordered a martini and a cosmopolitan. Little did we know that we would be charged $16 for each drink!! Terrible. More upscale restaurants don't charge $16 for a drink. We ordered a very good large salad to share. After we got our salad, we ordered entrees. Before we finished our drinks and salad, the entrees arrived. I mentioned to our server that the food came too fast. He said yes. they came 8 minutes after the order was put in. Food was very good. The bill was $111 without the tip. Much too high for an out of the way strip mall place on Palm Beach Blvd. We still can't get over the price of drinks so will NEVER go back. We were there for 45 minutes from start to finish. Not a fine dining experience.
Beer in bottles only and served with an oversized plastic glass also used for serving water. Have to get your server to bring salt and pepper to the table. Food was good, service was good.
We ate at Casa D'Italia on Christmas eve. my wife ordered the ravioli and asked for meat sauce instead of the marinara. Someone else in our party of 4 asked for the vegetable in stead of the side of pasta, the waitress said no problem for both. When we received our bills they charged an charged of $6 for the meat sauce and $4 for the vegetable instead of pasta. The waitress nor menu mentioned this. Our waitress came back to our table 3 times because she kept forgetting what I had ordered. The bill also had a 3% charge if you used a cc, again nothing mentioned this. My wife ordered a cappuccino and they had no real sugar. Food was.good but the hidden charges and prices were to much. Not recommended.
Ala Vodka sauce was over loaded with salt and was not eatable. Left a full plate except the 3 scallops. They said maybe next time it would be better. Won’t go back. Presentation was good just couldn’t eat it
Loading...