Pinocchio’s NEVER disappoints!Every time we come to Fort Myers we make our way to this gem.A cherished memory we used to share while on Sanibel Island, but now must come inland to enjoy.Gelato every time, Amarena & Stracciatella were delectable!But with all the flavor varieties of gelato, sorbets, ice creams and frozen yogurts!
I love the one on Sanibel. Since that one is temporarily closed, we went to the one on Fort Myers. Such a treat!
Ric Sadler
All pictures are from here and are past date! Long story here. Me and my family of 5 decided to try this place out and had another family of 5 meet us there. We all are very disappointed with this place and feel the health department should stop by and check all their products. We all bought ice cream and 2 drinks. 1 pink lemonade and 1 regular. Both had expired dates in pictures. I spoke with the kinds worker and she called the owner and they refunded us $4 for our 2 expired drinks and asked to keep them. We then went to the drink cooler and found almost all the drinks have old dates. Again they are pictured. Even orange juice and tropical juice expired. She said she was going to remove them. We sat in the parking lot for a while and she walked out with the drinks saying the OWNER said they are fine, the date is best by and they only been open 2 years ( per owner). Not sure why that matters saying all the drinks shouldn't be sold after that date. We all wish we wouldn't of ate the ice-cream and wonder if it's expired too.... pictures prove no slander here!
Amber Castillo
Pinocchio’s is my favorite homemade ice cream parlor I have ever visited. Every time I vacation in the area, I always make sure to get Dirty Sand Dollar and Gator Stew. It’s absolutely amazing!!
Scott Blasucci
We love it here! The BEST treats around town. So nostalgic for me as this was our first stop when we travelled to Sanibel as a child! Now that we live here, we frequent often! The flavors and the quality are off the charts!
Rachel Wimbley
We LOVE Pinocchio’s!!! I have been visiting the Sanibel location since the early 2000s and it is a must do every visit to Florida! I brought my kids to the Ft. Myers location in July and we all tried Sanibel Crunch and Dirty Sand Dollar and they LOVED it! I’m hoping the memories stick with them and they can bring their kids one day
denise dongilli
We love Pinocchios!! They have the best homemade ice cream hands down! Every time we visit the area, we make sure to get our full!
Random User
Fake Gelato. The banana is too yellow. We do not eat the peel. It’s not supposed to be that yellow. Too many additives and not stored in a covered tins. Gelato melts faster than ice cream so it should always be covered and stored at the right temperature but given these are open and exposed, they use preservatives to keep it from melting.
Very interesting flavor combinations.And very good
Valerie Nation
Oh my goodness! What a great place! I could try as many flavors I wanted before making my selection. They have so many varieties of desserts! Not just ice cream and they give huge portions. Plenty of space to eat inside. I would suggest this much higher than the Loveboat icecream place!
Sarah L
Our favorite ice cream! Used to go to the Sanibel location all the time. Happy there is another location since the storm came through. Great ice cream, great flavors, and great prices!
Paul Philabaum
Fabulous sundaes....On a Sunday.....A great selection of all kinds of goodies.....different type and style of frozen deliciousness...
Pinocchio’s NEVER disappoints!Every time we come to Fort Myers we make our way to this gem.A cherished memory we used to share while on Sanibel Island, but now must come inland to enjoy.Gelato every time, Amarena & Stracciatella were delectable!But with all the flavor varieties of gelato, sorbets, ice creams and frozen yogurts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Gelato was on point!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sundaes, Ice Cream Cones, Gelato
I love the one on Sanibel. Since that one is temporarily closed, we went to the one on Fort Myers. Such a treat!
All pictures are from here and are past date! Long story here. Me and my family of 5 decided to try this place out and had another family of 5 meet us there. We all are very disappointed with this place and feel the health department should stop by and check all their products. We all bought ice cream and 2 drinks. 1 pink lemonade and 1 regular. Both had expired dates in pictures. I spoke with the kinds worker and she called the owner and they refunded us $4 for our 2 expired drinks and asked to keep them. We then went to the drink cooler and found almost all the drinks have old dates. Again they are pictured. Even orange juice and tropical juice expired. She said she was going to remove them. We sat in the parking lot for a while and she walked out with the drinks saying the OWNER said they are fine, the date is best by and they only been open 2 years ( per owner). Not sure why that matters saying all the drinks shouldn't be sold after that date. We all wish we wouldn't of ate the ice-cream and wonder if it's expired too.... pictures prove no slander here!
Pinocchio’s is my favorite homemade ice cream parlor I have ever visited. Every time I vacation in the area, I always make sure to get Dirty Sand Dollar and Gator Stew. It’s absolutely amazing!!
We love it here! The BEST treats around town. So nostalgic for me as this was our first stop when we travelled to Sanibel as a child! Now that we live here, we frequent often! The flavors and the quality are off the charts!
We LOVE Pinocchio’s!!! I have been visiting the Sanibel location since the early 2000s and it is a must do every visit to Florida! I brought my kids to the Ft. Myers location in July and we all tried Sanibel Crunch and Dirty Sand Dollar and they LOVED it! I’m hoping the memories stick with them and they can bring their kids one day
We love Pinocchios!! They have the best homemade ice cream hands down! Every time we visit the area, we make sure to get our full!
Fake Gelato. The banana is too yellow. We do not eat the peel. It’s not supposed to be that yellow. Too many additives and not stored in a covered tins. Gelato melts faster than ice cream so it should always be covered and stored at the right temperature but given these are open and exposed, they use preservatives to keep it from melting.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Always friendly. Excellent variety of ice cream ?
Restaurantji Recommends
Rude staff, subpar ice cream.
Very interesting flavor combinations.And very good
Oh my goodness! What a great place! I could try as many flavors I wanted before making my selection. They have so many varieties of desserts! Not just ice cream and they give huge portions. Plenty of space to eat inside. I would suggest this much higher than the Loveboat icecream place!
Our favorite ice cream! Used to go to the Sanibel location all the time. Happy there is another location since the storm came through. Great ice cream, great flavors, and great prices!
Fabulous sundaes....On a Sunday.....A great selection of all kinds of goodies.....different type and style of frozen deliciousness...