Salvatore’s New York Pizza

Tommyyyyyy! Where are you? We're all eating bad pizza now.....sure do miss a good slice! Hope your okay.....waiting patiently till the end of time☺

The food is true authentic new York style got the best antipasto EVER!! THE PIZZA IS MY FAMILY FAVORITE. IM SAD TO SEE IT TEMPORARILY CLOSED I TRULY HOPE EVERYONE IS WELL. HOPE TO SEE YOU ALL SOON.

One of the best slices of pizza ive had in YEARS!!!Im from NJ, and family from NY. These guys know what theyre doing and take pride in their pizza!$5 for 2 slices and a drink!!!

My Husband and I love eating here. We always get our pizza from here and we recently tried the hero's. Being from up north this is the best place We have found since moving to FL. We usually order most of the time on Fridays. We do have a problem with getting a hold of someone to order. There have been plenty of times we had to just decide to eat else where because no one ever picks up the phone. I understand Fridays or any day of the week can be busy. It is just really disappointing because we love this place so much. Other then that you will not be disappointed. Great place and friendly owners.

It wasn't bad, but it wasn't my favorite if I'm being honest. The veggies weren't particularly fresh tasting. The crust was soggy in the middle and then charcoal crunchy at the end. The staff were friendly but I felt a little leered at. It was intense and yet not that flavorful at the same time.

Awesome pizza and awesome owners! Polite and hilarious! One of the best pizzas I have ever had! Amazing garlic bread! One bite everybody knows the rules!

We got a sausage pizza and a container of their sauce?it was delicious ?best we have had in a long time. Wonderful and friendly.

Authentic New York pizza! Definitely beats any of the chain joints!

Very disappointing. Limp crust, skimpy sausage topping. Very average at best. With Downtown House of Pizza just a few miles away I’ll be driving the extra distance when I want good NY style pizza.

Meat Stromboli, website hasn't been updated, but I understand. Got lucky to talk to the owner ,not knowing at first , polite and apologized that company hasn't fulfilled her request. Stromboli was amazing as always . And to know the whole delivery fee goes to the driver , was awesome. We'll eat here again as before.

Ordered from Salvatore’s for the first time, and the NY style pizza was spot on delicious. My kind of sausage too, as well as cheese. I highly recommend.

Another fort myers/cape coral pizza joint I tried that claims “ New York “ style pizza. Bland, overcooked dry and you call the chicken roll I got a roll? Small as can be. Prices are outrageous for the quality your serving and when you come in asking for the pizza acts like a tough guy paying attention to the woman in his pizzeria trying to get laid probaly, and acting like I’m not there, not even a thank you for helping his hole in the wall place. never spending 50 bucks on garbage at this place again.

If you're looking for a pie that reminds you of HOME (to all my NY people you know) this is the best BY FAR!! GIVE IT A TRY

pizza was nasty tastings half of the fried mushrooms dint even have mushrooms in them and the fries looked boiled

My go to pizza place. Great heroes. Pizza that dispels the Florida water myth. This place takes me back to the old style pizza joints on Long Island when I was growing up. You knew the owner He was out front He made just about everything and that's basically the way this place is. Sal is a great proprietor. With a really good personality. And the people that work for him are great also. I don't go anyplace else for my pizza or heroes.