Sir Pizza Fort Myers Shores

13302 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers
(239) 208-4401

Recent Reviews

jason thrash

We live in middle Tennessee where we have 3 Sir Pizza locations. My wife and I are from Indiana and know all about the relationship between Pizza King and Sir Pizza. They both have a unique taste. The sausage is what we love at both places. Well, we stopped by this location today and the pizza was nothing like Sir Pizza or Pizza King. The pictures on menu and the photos on the reviews look like the pizza we know and love but it was not what we were served today. It's also very very hot inside this location. Over all we were quite disappointed.

Teresa Lindley

Very good Pizza!We are natives of Indiana, home of Pizza King/Sir Pizza origins. The pizza here was a little different, but definitely a great likeness to our favorite Indiana pizza restaurant. Great job and we will definitely see you again, Sir Pizza!

toni desesso

Placed order on 8/2/22 at 11 am. Salad order was wrong tried to get right order. Girl at counter just wanted to argue with me about order. Very rude. I hope the owner sees this. Then a big guy comes over with new salad practically throws the salad on the table. After being treated so rude we were afraid to even eat the food thinking if they act this way to there customers who knows what they might do to the food. Would give a zero but only could give a one. My past visits were always pleasant. New crew working there should not be serving food or even working with the public. Did not want to eat the food just left it behind. Bad Bad Bad experience.

Emily Dockery

I came here with my brother and it was absolutely gross, i seen not one but five roaches and mold. The meat i had on my pizzas tasted old like it had been sitting out. I wouldn’t recommend. the health department needs to take care of this place and they need to actually check this place correctly or shut it down.

Dennis Stull (The Funcles - DASHR)

Today’s experience ushered me back to central Indiana as a child, feasting on Pizza King (Sir Pizza) on Sunday nights after church. The service was kind, but lacked a welcome back, or hope you return feel. However, the sausage pizza excited every sensory experience from the visual to the smell, to the touch (crispy crunch) to the savory taste. A delightful dining event, one you must try to believe.

Scott Hamilton

Great pizza. Just like back home. We’ve seen four different owners since they opened but the quality of food is the same if not better.

Stephanie Schmitt

So excited to discover this gem!! We moved to the area last year and have been searching for “our” pizza joints I love the small diner experience and this place delivered!! Serving up delicious food and old school arcade games, I can’t wait to go back!!

Angela P.

I want to give no stars! I ordered a pizza for delivery, waited over an hour only to receive a message they cancelled the order! At 9:15 pm at night when you're hungry this is terrible customer service.

Daniel R.

We Just enjoy the pizza. It's very convenient to our house less than 10 mins. Staff is very friendly

Bestfourpaws L.

My first time here and I must say it was the very best pizza I have ever had Im a Florida girl and My favorite place in the whole world was Upper Crust Pizza 28 Duval St Key West they had to close due to rent push out So now many years later I find my new favorite place right here

Kimber Ann

I ordered on the phone and they answered immediately the man on the phone was friendly. The pizza was really good and now I can't wait to try other items on the menu. This pizza is different and I like different things and the place is unique. My food was ready when I came to pick it up. I'm very happy with the choice I made. Thank you for making my food I appropriate it.

Ashley H.

Had the royal feast, wings and cheese sticks. All were fantastic. Great pizza and yes, as the reviews say, similar to pizza king in Indiana. They even had some pizza king references inside the restaurant! Excited to find this and enjoyed it all.

Michael M

We live in Verandah and order carryout about once a week. Large Royal Feast. If you're from Wisconsin or the midwest and are familiar with Happy Joe's, this is very similar. Chopped toppings, sweet sauce, and a nice, chewy crust. If there is a downside, it's a bit slow. If hey tell you 20-25 minutes for carryout, probably about 40. Always pleasant to deal with and very reasonably priced.

Jakereed17

I’m from New York and work for Joe’s pizza in whitesboro an upside down pizza place! This pizza was exactly what I expected. Thin crispy crust. Lots of toppings and good sauce! I like this style of pizza. Ask them what they recommend they will say either meat lovers or mushroom/peppers/pepperoni/sausage.

Shannon S.

Fantastic pizza!! Been looking for a great place to get pizza....glad I found this place!!!

Load More