Always purchase pizza from Tony’s every weekend, first time we experienced raw pizza dough.
Te'a Kurg
We were able to redeem a free pizza and definitely coming back to try the rest of their menu items!
Yomesh Patel
Best place to visit must visit this place ❤️
William Reynolds
Krissy provided me with the best service. I needed a pie delivered to my wife’s b-day party as a surprise. Krissy went above and beyond to help me surprise my wife. This was 1st rate customer service. My wife and I have eaten Tony’s food several times, and we love it. Classic NY-style pizzeria.
Jim Reed
I've been there on several occasions and was never disappointed by their offerings. All that I've had has been absolutely top shelf. Would most definitely recommend over anybody else.
Gabriel Kulpa
Extra sauce ❤️
Yuliya Anthony
Amazing pizza, new favorite pizza place! Their dough and toppings are a chefs kiss.
Sonya Bracco
Vacationing in ft myers from Michigan. My hubby was born and raised on Long Island/Queens and is ALWAYS looking for NY pizza!! Came across Tony's NY pizza, and ordered a pie and garlic knots. Hubby was doing the happy dance!! The pizza is so close to the real deal!! The crust was amazing!! Might have to take a couple pies back home to Michigan! The garlic knots we close, but definitely needed more garlic.
Tober Anderson
Crust was "very" chewy, tomato sauce was way too much. Won't order here again even in desperation for a pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Adam Ackerman
Pizza was great and the garlic knots were some of the best we ever had.
Wow, what a great experience. Great staff, tons of fresh slice options and very fair prices.
The old school Italian music really sets the mood. ? will be back.
EDIT: I actually removed a star. What a cold response to a review. I'm 99% sure its AI generated. Really kinda ruined my outlook on the business.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, The Greenwich Hawaiian Pizza
jay T
Great food ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leafer Asor
Service was great!! Pizza and garlic knots were amazing!!! Definitely eat here again
Food: 4
Service: 4
Christina Sievert
My Mom and I tried the Pizza here today (we try a new pizza place every week) check out CJPIZZA on TikTok The service was excellent, Alana you rock! Started off with Garlic knots, they were Amazing ! Then Pepperoni Pizza (solid 10) Then the owner was there and gave us each a homemade dessert, Brownie was huge and cheese cake was so good. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza Pies
SeanHoover219
This pizza is amazing. The garlic knots are fabulous. We come here almost every week and it’s always good. The crust is perfect.
The service is always pleasant and professional. You have to try this place.
Always purchase pizza from Tony’s every weekend, first time we experienced raw pizza dough.
We were able to redeem a free pizza and definitely coming back to try the rest of their menu items!
Best place to visit must visit this place ❤️
Krissy provided me with the best service. I needed a pie delivered to my wife’s b-day party as a surprise. Krissy went above and beyond to help me surprise my wife. This was 1st rate customer service. My wife and I have eaten Tony’s food several times, and we love it. Classic NY-style pizzeria.
I've been there on several occasions and was never disappointed by their offerings. All that I've had has been absolutely top shelf. Would most definitely recommend over anybody else.
Extra sauce ❤️
Amazing pizza, new favorite pizza place! Their dough and toppings are a chefs kiss.
Vacationing in ft myers from Michigan. My hubby was born and raised on Long Island/Queens and is ALWAYS looking for NY pizza!! Came across Tony's NY pizza, and ordered a pie and garlic knots. Hubby was doing the happy dance!! The pizza is so close to the real deal!! The crust was amazing!! Might have to take a couple pies back home to Michigan! The garlic knots we close, but definitely needed more garlic.
Crust was "very" chewy, tomato sauce was way too much. Won't order here again even in desperation for a pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Pizza was great and the garlic knots were some of the best we ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Wow, what a great experience. Great staff, tons of fresh slice options and very fair prices.
The old school Italian music really sets the mood. ? will be back.
EDIT: I actually removed a star. What a cold response to a review. I'm 99% sure its AI generated. Really kinda ruined my outlook on the business.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, The Greenwich Hawaiian Pizza
Great food ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was great!! Pizza and garlic knots were amazing!!! Definitely eat here again
Food: 4
Service: 4
My Mom and I tried the Pizza here today (we try a new pizza place every week) check out CJPIZZA on TikTok
The service was excellent, Alana you rock! Started off with Garlic knots, they were Amazing ! Then Pepperoni Pizza (solid 10) Then the owner was there and gave us each a homemade dessert, Brownie was huge and cheese cake was so good. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza Pies
This pizza is amazing. The garlic knots are fabulous. We come here almost every week and it’s always good. The crust is perfect.
The service is always pleasant and professional. You have to try this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pies
Loading...