Great store with a great selection and awesome bakery
Douglas Smith
I cannot rate every aspect of the market. It truly appears to have a ton of authentic Italian products and deli items. But…I ordered a Godfather sub, basically an Italian sub priced at over $13. Mario’s on 41, also very authentic, makes a better sub, in taste and ingredients, the same size for $7. I’ll try some other products but I’ll definitely compare prices before.
Vinny Penoro
Always great. Ground beef and braciole made fresh while I waited. Always accommodating. Everything is always delicious. Great pastries too
Kathy Weslock
Food is outstanding, atmosphere & staff even better
Hugh B.
A nice selection of Italian themed in house made sandwiches and a large selection of salads. Prepared meals such as Lasagna, Chicken Parm, pre packaged salads. Service is usually quick during the week, if busy grab a number at the entrance. A large selection of pastries. Wines, soups. All located in a nice clean store. A catering menu is also available. It's worth a visit.
Claudia Zenobi
The pastries I picked up for St Joseph's Day were delicious! I will be back!....hopefully the next time I don't lock my keys in the car lol. A big thank you to you all for helping me out! It was much appreciated!!!
Kevin Barreto
Best Italian deli in SWFL!
Kevin B.
This is a SWFL hidden gem and it does not get more authentic Italian than this place! You can trust that anything you get there will be amazing, friendly staff and quick service, would give it 10 stars if I could!
Mike Vizcaino
Must must go here.If heavens pearly gates had an entrance on earth, it would start here. They are from Manalapan NJ. I was blown away They know fresh food. They know flavor. This is sw Florida best kept secret. Mario's has nothing on Tuscany. You must must must get the chicken or eggplant sandwich. We are from Manalapan 5 years ago. We went to Tuscany weekly. If you love it, you owe me a gift card. Or a box of cookies leave it there with my name on it. SHANNON FROM MANALAPAN.. BRAVO Tuscany thank you for moving here. Sensational....
Staff wasn't overly friendly, standing around behind the counter and would make customers go get a number to be served even if no one else was in line. Food was ok, sandwiches very skimpy but over priced. Mario's Meat Market much better.
Charles Barbera
I arrived early for an appointment nearby so I stopped by for lunch and ordered a sweet sausage, pepper and onion panini and a chocolate mountain to share with my son. The sausage was the best I have had in SW Florida paired with beautiful peppers and onions on a nice crusty, soft bread. I could only eat half before the appointment and it sat in my truck for 2 hours before I could finish it. The bread held up like a good bread should and soaked up all the juices from the sausage and peppers making it even better. I have ordered sausage and pepper sandwiches all over Cape Coral, Ft Myers and Naples and they all have had inferior ingredients and have been mushy either when recieved or after a short ride home. The only sandwich I have had close to this in the area is from Mario's and thier bread was a little to tough for me making the sandwich a chore to eat. Good food is hard to come by around here and these guys are doing it right. I have seen some of the negative reviews and can empathize with the challenge of offering a large selection to a small customer base while trying to maintain freshness, value and quality. I hope enough people find out about this place and allow them to achieve that goal and continue to serve the community. My experience was 10 out of 10 and I will be back to sample more of thier offerings.
Jennifer Royle
Praise Jesus I found you. Delicious. Incredible! Thank you, Anthony and family. Keep up the great work.Jen from Boston
Michele Speight
Fresh Italian! Everything looked so good it was hard to select. They have a wide variety of deli options, prepared foods, quality meats & delicious bakery. Friendly & helpful staff.
Gretchen G
Great cheese and premade foods. However, service is inconsistent - if you look under 50 good luck getting treated with respect (sold out to the seasonals when the locals are always here - a lesson new businesses like this struggle to learn; when summer comes bills still need to be paid). Avoid the meat - it is browning and old and the wine is not worth the price - your cork will break from poor temp control and shipping. Place has potential but fails too often in areas it can easily excel. New business and clearly a new to business owner. Don't be fooled by the ny/nj origins…they would have already failed there if they tried to make business in either state. Be smart about what’s popular and what isn’t. Look to see what’s bought and what’s not. Mario’s and fresh market provide better meat options and total wine, better wine. If this business knew better, they’d do better.
Miss you in NJ. Fla is lucky to have you!!!
Great store with a great selection and awesome bakery
I cannot rate every aspect of the market. It truly appears to have a ton of authentic Italian products and deli items. But…I ordered a Godfather sub, basically an Italian sub priced at over $13. Mario’s on 41, also very authentic, makes a better sub, in taste and ingredients, the same size for $7. I’ll try some other products but I’ll definitely compare prices before.
Always great. Ground beef and braciole made fresh while I waited. Always accommodating. Everything is always delicious. Great pastries too
Food is outstanding, atmosphere & staff even better
A nice selection of Italian themed in house made sandwiches and a large selection of salads. Prepared meals such as Lasagna, Chicken Parm, pre packaged salads. Service is usually quick during the week, if busy grab a number at the entrance. A large selection of pastries. Wines, soups. All located in a nice clean store. A catering menu is also available. It's worth a visit.
The pastries I picked up for St Joseph's Day were delicious! I will be back!....hopefully the next time I don't lock my keys in the car lol. A big thank you to you all for helping me out! It was much appreciated!!!
Best Italian deli in SWFL!
This is a SWFL hidden gem and it does not get more authentic Italian than this place! You can trust that anything you get there will be amazing, friendly staff and quick service, would give it 10 stars if I could!
Must must go here.If heavens pearly gates had an entrance on earth, it would start here. They are from Manalapan NJ. I was blown away They know fresh food. They know flavor. This is sw Florida best kept secret. Mario's has nothing on Tuscany. You must must must get the chicken or eggplant sandwich. We are from Manalapan 5 years ago. We went to Tuscany weekly. If you love it, you owe me a gift card. Or a box of cookies leave it there with my name on it. SHANNON FROM MANALAPAN.. BRAVO Tuscany thank you for moving here. Sensational....
Restaurantji Recommends
Staff wasn't overly friendly, standing around behind the counter and would make customers go get a number to be served even if no one else was in line. Food was ok, sandwiches very skimpy but over priced. Mario's Meat Market much better.
I arrived early for an appointment nearby so I stopped by for lunch and ordered a sweet sausage, pepper and onion panini and a chocolate mountain to share with my son. The sausage was the best I have had in SW Florida paired with beautiful peppers and onions on a nice crusty, soft bread. I could only eat half before the appointment and it sat in my truck for 2 hours before I could finish it. The bread held up like a good bread should and soaked up all the juices from the sausage and peppers making it even better. I have ordered sausage and pepper sandwiches all over Cape Coral, Ft Myers and Naples and they all have had inferior ingredients and have been mushy either when recieved or after a short ride home. The only sandwich I have had close to this in the area is from Mario's and thier bread was a little to tough for me making the sandwich a chore to eat. Good food is hard to come by around here and these guys are doing it right. I have seen some of the negative reviews and can empathize with the challenge of offering a large selection to a small customer base while trying to maintain freshness, value and quality. I hope enough people find out about this place and allow them to achieve that goal and continue to serve the community. My experience was 10 out of 10 and I will be back to sample more of thier offerings.
Praise Jesus I found you. Delicious. Incredible! Thank you, Anthony and family. Keep up the great work.Jen from Boston
Fresh Italian! Everything looked so good it was hard to select. They have a wide variety of deli options, prepared foods, quality meats & delicious bakery. Friendly & helpful staff.
Great cheese and premade foods. However, service is inconsistent - if you look under 50 good luck getting treated with respect (sold out to the seasonals when the locals are always here - a lesson new businesses like this struggle to learn; when summer comes bills still need to be paid). Avoid the meat - it is browning and old and the wine is not worth the price - your cork will break from poor temp control and shipping. Place has potential but fails too often in areas it can easily excel. New business and clearly a new to business owner. Don't be fooled by the ny/nj origins…they would have already failed there if they tried to make business in either state. Be smart about what’s popular and what isn’t. Look to see what’s bought and what’s not. Mario’s and fresh market provide better meat options and total wine, better wine. If this business knew better, they’d do better.