The Proper Pie Company

511 Hwy 17 92 W, Unit 520, Haines City
(863) 438-2705

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Steak and Mushroom Pie
Chicken and Mushroom
Steak and Ale Pie
Chicken Pot Pie
Fish and Chips
Cornish Pasty
Afternoon Tea
Chicken Curry
Banger Rolls
Cod and Chips

Menu

Proper Steak Pies
Steak, Potato, Onion, and Cheese
Handmade with tender steak, potato, onion and some cheese, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry.
Steak and Ale
Handmade with chopped tender steak, potato and traditional ale (which one is our secret!), all wrpaped in our signature double puff pastry

Proper Chicken Pies
Chicken Curry
Handmade with tender pieces of chicken in a mild, but tangy, curry sauce, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
Lemon Chicken
Handmade with tender pieces of chicken in a creamy lemon and herb sauce. all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry
Chicken, leek & potato

Other Proper Pies
Shepherd's Pie in a Pie
A unique handmade pie made with finely ground lean beef, mashed potato and mixed vegetables with a sprinkle of cheese on the top, all wrapped in our signature double puff pastry

Proper Fish and Chips
Cod and Chips
Our freshly sourced succulent cod with our handmade double cooked chips (fries) in our own secret light and crispy ale batter is delicious on its own or with extra sides!
Chips
Our hand cut double cooked chips (fries) are the real deal
Onion Rings (Five)
Our 5 onion rings, lightly cooked to order in our secret light and crispy batter are a great accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips or any of our Proper Pies.

Proper Sides
Gravy
Our rich beef based gravy is a compliment to any of our Proper Pies
Curry Sauce
Our very own rich and tangy homemade curry sauce is an ideal compliment to our delicious fish & chips or any of our Proper Pies
Mushy Peas
A Northern English favorite as well as a great accompaniment to our delicious fish & chips or Proper Pies

Proper Snacks
Banger Rolls
2 handmade banger rolls with delicious pork sausage - a great snack hot or cold

Proper Homemade Sweets
Scottish Shortbread
A slice of our handmade scottish shortbread is unbeatable with an afternoon cup of tea or coffee
Scone
Our famous English scones (plain, raisin or cranberry) are a treat at any time of day
Eccles Cake
The quintessential English sweet handmade with raisins, butter and brown sugar, wrapped in our signature puff pastry

Soda & Water
UK Sodas
US Sodas

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+21 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+20 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We got the steak and potato and chicken broccoli cheddar pies frozen from the Clermont farmers market last week and loved them! After following the cooking directions the crust and temperature were perfect. We also got some scones which were delicious. Was a super easy meal on a busy day for us and can’t wait to grab some more!
March 2025
Purchased an 8oz Steak, Potato, Onion & Cheese Pie at a farmer's market. While the tast was good, there was not much to this $8.00 pot pie. Excessive amount of dough, not enough of the ingredients.
December 2024
After discovering The Proper Pie Company at the Winter Haven Farmers Market we had to try them in person. If you’re looking for great service and food this is the place to go! I wholeheartedly believe they are the home of the best fish and chips in Polk County FL. The British pies and Scottish eggs are also extremely flavorful, if you’re ever in the area stop in for a steak pie. You will not regret it!
December 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

China Wok - 617 US-17 #523
Chinese
Burger King - 505 U.S. Hwy 17-92 W
Fast Food, Burgers
Pizzano's Pizza & Grinders Haines City - 631A Hwy 17 #92w
Pizza

The Proper Pie Company

511 Hwy 17 92 W, Unit 520, Haines City, FL 33844
(863) 438-2705