Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff

Holy Cow Ice Cream is an absolute must every time we visit AMI. The staff are always so kind and helpful. Their ice cream is hands down the best on the island!

I walked in this place and I did not get greeted and everyone was just getting barked at and I felt like a bother. I came from two hours away to have a good fun time at the beach and wanted some ice cream after and I also got milkshake that tasted like straight milk I got (EXPRESSO MILK SHAKE BTW) really bad customer service never again.

The ice cream was so delicious! You definitely get your money’s worth coming here and the owner was so nice and friendly! I will not stop recommending this place to others!

Thanks for opening the door for my son! Absolutely incredible ice cream! The flavors were rich, creamy, and clearly made with high-quality ingredients. Every scoop tasted fresh and homemade, with the perfect balance of sweetness and texture. The staff was friendly, the shop was spotless, and the atmosphere made the experience even better. I’ve had ice cream all over the country, and this is easily among the best. If you’re in the area, this place is a must-visit. Can’t wait to come back and try more flavors!

Super friendly staff. I had the BEST dairy free strawberry Dole Whip

Every time we visit AMI, we find somewhere new. Holy Cow doesn’t disappoint! Highly recommended!

We have been visiting Holy Cow for years. Mel and family know my dad by name despite us only being vacationers that return for a few weeks each summer, so we only found it fitting to finally try Mel’s special. It’s just as sweet as Mel😉
Highly recommend trying Holy Cow and Mel’s special sundae!!!

The most friendly staff and they were quick to create my favorite shake (cookies and cream) even though they didn’t have that ice cream available. A great example of why we love coming to this place and strongly recommend others to support them.

Small business with the friendliest staff you will ever find and an amazing selection of everything-related ice cream with a ton of flavors to choose from. Go for it!!

So many good flavors to choose from. Will return!

Best coffe ice cream I've had.

Hey, its the daughter from the 2 daughters and mom that came in with matching outfits over Mothers Day weekend. We loved it so much, we came back twice. Super friendly staff. Took our pictures and remembered us when we came back. Absolutely a must stop on your trip to the Island.

Very cute ice cream shop! Owner was super awesome and extremely sweet and friendly, thanks for the tip about the manatees!!! The banana split was delicious, definitely try out the cinnamon swirl flavor! 10/10 would recommend!

Wonderful experience! Great selection! Very friendly and patient staff!
I had a great Dole Whip!

Amazing service with great insight from the owners on places to go and things to see. Fully wheelchair accessible