The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
3324 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach
(941) 779-2253
About The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe
The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe Reviews
I have some food restrictions (dairy and gluten) and was so happy to see that Cheesecake Cutie had options for me! Their chicken salad is incredible on their gluten free bread, which is so soft and so good! They have vegan cheesecake, and it’s so yummy! Really good service and locally owned which we loved! Definitely a go-to spot for me when I’m on AMI!
We drive an hour just to come to Cheesecake Cutie! My family absolutely LOVES their cheesecake, sandwiches, and coffee! My 11 year old son LOVES their gluten free cheesecake as well as their gluten free sub rolls and if anyone has had gluten free things before you know they must be good if an 11 year old boy loves them!!
We came down from the Quad Cities area (Iowa/Illinois) for vacation and was told to stop in because the food is delicious. Well our friend was right! We had the best service and the food is to die for! We ate there 3 days. The cheesecakes are amazing that I had to order some to take home! Lol
Menu
People in Holmes Beach Also Viewed
.jpg)
The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe is a charming spot near Holmes Beach that offers a tasty selection of cold brew and treats. The salted caramel cold brew is highly recommended. The cafe provides indoor, outdoor, and takeout options, making it a peaceful place with a good crowd. Customers appreciate the friendly staff and the food's quality, which is better than chain coffee shops. They also serve a variety of snacks and food, including amazing sandwiches like the "Little" Joey Italian and cheesecake cuties in flavors such as classic key lime or lemon blueberry. The small cheesecakes are a popular choice, with thick textures and small size options that visitors love. While prices are a bit high, many find the food worth it, especially for supporting a local business. The restaurant can accommodate allergies and eating preferences, and customers have noted that ordering ahead can save time, as in-person orders may take a while. Overall, it’s a perfect spot for a coffee break or a sweet treat on Anna Maria Island.